5 ms·
I feel like this has been a long journey but I think at this point I grok the fundamental differences. - I know that what trans folks experience with dysphoria
by Spivak 4y ago
I feel like this has been a long journey but I think at this point I grok the fundamental differences.
- I know that what trans folks experience with dysphoria isn't "hurt feelings" and is a medical issue more akin to triggering someone's PTSD.
- I view the absolute bare minimum of what is required for acceptance of trans women is using their names, pronouns, treating them as you would cisgender women in all situations not directly related to medical care where chromosomal differences are relevant, recognizing dysphoria as a medical condition, and providing them access to the medically necessary healthcare of medical transition in the same manner as any other medical treatment.
If there was a treatment that could alter a trans person's brain chemistry so they would no longer feel dysphoria it would without question be deemed medically necessary and covered. I view medical transition as the same thing.
And if you oppose any of those things that is opposing trans people since every single one is fundamentally necessary for trans people to exist in society. I would think you mad if you tried to argue that a law banning two people of the same sex from having sex was not opposing gay people and that it was enough to simply view them as people instead of monsters.
- I view fighting for the usage of the word man and woman that is consistent with the medical community (yes I know you disagree with that bit) as convincing people to include trans men and women when using those words so that the meaning changes, not telling people that they have to. You are under no obligation to accept trans women, but in my view calling them women is a prerequisite to that.
It's great that you're now not shunning them from polite society, locking them up in mental institutions, or lynching them but that alone doesn't constitute acceptance. I view what you're doing the same way I would view someone who said they "accepted black people" but were insistent that they were "black people" not "people" because the overwhelming majority believed that "people" means humans of white skin.
Also lol at SF or Seattle. I live in a deep red state.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago
- Spivak 4y ago
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago
- Spivak 4y ago
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago
- Spivak 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]