3 ms·
> I have nothing against the values Web3 claims to stand for. That said, Web3 is not going great. regarding "web3 is not going great", which links to a web si
by yieldcrv 4y ago
> I have nothing against the values Web3 claims to stand for. That said, Web3 is not going great.
regarding "web3 is not going great", which links to a web site showing exploits and problems in poorly run organizations, maybe someone should just put up a parallel site that shows the ever expanding group of projects and communities that have existed without incident?
like construction sites that showcase "X days without incident", maybe that industry started putting those signs up in the past because people only saw negative headlines and conflated construction with the entire concept of having office space, like people do with crypto
if there are, for example, 5,000 projects at time of writing, and 300 of them get funds stolen or exploited in some way, thats still a headline of an exploit every single business day of the year and none for the other 4,700 projects. that's pretty much the state of crypto discord today, and its been that way for the past 10 years.
- ehutch79 4y agoPlease do so.
- yieldcrv 4y agoI've been thinking about it, but there are already so many telegram bots that show smart contract deployments and you can look at the name of the smart contract and find the corresponding community on discord, in some periods of time they are deployments nearly every second so it's like who is it for? its not really useful for "web3 skeptics", the goal post would just move to something even further unrelated to not having negative incidents occurring to people that interact with the contract still mulling it over, since it takes time and effort with no benefit edit: actually, some of the grant programs would likely support development and maintenance of this
- throwaway22032 4y agoThe detractors have already made up their mind. I count myself as one of them in the wider space because I'm pretty much a BTC maxi, but the same applies there. I mean, Bitcoin has been running for 12 years and there's been, as far as I know, one hiccup (the 2010 overflow bug, before it was worth really anything at all, that was fixed by miners simply abandoning that chain). Yet it's "died" about a trillion times in the media. It doesn't matter if it works, it doesn't work _for them_.
- yieldcrv 4y agoI think about that standard from maxis and others as well, there are many projects and blockchains that grow much quicker than bitcoin did, but are put to an even higher standard than bitcoin was “Oh no, block propagation halted for a few hours in your first year since the genesis block, its dead! its unreliable! its different than bitcoin’s similarly embarrassing problems because there’s so much capital involved and all possible confidence must therefore be lost irreparably” and its like…. not really? the nodes will update their software just like bitcoin did
- UncleEntity 4y agoA “days without a $1,000,000,000 security incident” billboard? If it ever goes over 365 everyone gets a free taco. —edit— Which reminds me of these “your speed” digital signs with three digits they have in one of the suburbs of Phoenix, at that point it’s more of a challenge than anything.
- yieldcrv 4y ago> A “days without a $1,000,000,000 security incident” billboard? no project represents the whole industry or concept, that's the point. its frankly weird that is the level of discourse on this topic, currently. so you might be able to eek out some dopamine from your kind of humor, for now, but I think more accurate information amongst the non-incident creating projects will help the discourse improve
- justsomeadvice0 4y agoI think it's a good idea. I somewhat pay attention to headlines in that space, but I literally don't know of a single cryptocurrency community that has launched a successful product, outside of perhaps "platforms for trading other cryptocurrencies". My opinion of blockchains is that they aren't actually useful for anything except for implementing currencies, and currencies need a tangible market economy behind them to be useful. Maybe I am wrong, but I haven't seen it yet.
- yieldcrv 4y agothanks, yeah “existing without incident” and “product you would find useful for anyone that you’re aware of” are two different standards but perhaps seeing a list of things that are going great and wondering what everyone’s up to in those many communities would be a first step
- prohobo 4y agoThere's literally one project that I've seen being truly useful: https://pooltogether.com/ https://pooltogether.com/ It's cool because it's not possible to do this without crypto (in terms of trust). But because it uses a smart contract you can be sure that when you put your money into it, it won't steal it.