9 ms·
Betting on things that never change (2017)
- quickthrower2 4y agoA good article but feels more table stakes than secret sauce stuff. The advise crosses to non startups too. It is a why you have a bunch of different X targeting market segments for all X. For example Pizza, flights, cars.
- bilekas 4y agoIt's amazing how well it reads for something that really seems like just common sense.
- Swizec 4y agoThe best insights feel like obvious common sense after you read them. But you didn’t know it, or know how to verbalize it, beforehand.
- cs702 4y agoAs usual, I find myself nodding in agreement whenever I read anything written by Morgan Housel on this blog. It is evident he has thought deeply about the topic of each post, and wants to share his hard-earned insights with the rest of the world. Long-term compounding of wealth indeed comes from betting on things that won't change over the course of a lifetime.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoThere is something of a campaign going on now and it is not 'cool' to compliment some billionaires. Apart from this, there are valid real reasons to dislike to former Amazon's CEO. That said, reading his early interviews it hard not be impressed by the foresight and insight. I personally do think he got some things wrong ("if you can't measure it, you can't manage it" mantra being one of them ) or at least got others to misunderstand it, but it is hard to deny the results he helped manifest. It is the same impression I have of Thiel.
- nordsieck 4y ago> I personally do think he got some things wrong ("if you can't measure it, you can't manage it" mantra being one of them ) Could you explain this point more. I'm genuinely curious.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoSure. Some context may be needed. I suppose my views are formed in this way partially, because I became an MBA after having soul crushing jobs, which does tend to change your perspective a little bit ( and give you an insight into what is going on in a head of the front line drone that is forced to implement orders the best way he/she can ). << "if you can't measure it, you can't manage it" 1. It is wrong in a literal sense. You obviously can. Maybe you should not ( which is a valid question to ask ), but you absolutely can manage things and not measure everything. 2. It is wrong when taken metaphorically to a logical conclusion. The mantra seems to encourage ( and did encourage based on some of the things managers tried to measure -- lines of code come to mind ) measuring everything. In accounting, there is a concept similar law's 'de minimis' ( I kinda don't want to use that name, because I worry people wills start questioning that from tax perspective, which is its own animal I don't want to touch, but in practical terms, the name matches the concept exactly - basically 'too small to matter'), where accounting for some items in some processes is borderline pointless ( say a screw ). Every so often, people in accounting classes go 'but what if', 'but we can track it'. And the answer is invariably: 'You can, but is it worth it?' Naturally, you could counter it with: 'Well, you don't know if you don't measure it.', but there has to be a point at which the tracking of atoms get too crazy. So that is my basic thought on the matter. I can expand a little more, but I think that covers it. Note, I am not saying it is not worth it to measure stuff. I am saying it is important to be discriminating over what you pick to measure, because, people being people, will optimize for it.
- triceratops 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- extragood 4y ago
- yellow_lead 4y ago(2017)
- ttul 4y agoWhat rings true for me in this article is the notion that, as a founder, it’s better to pick a problem space than it is to pick a solution. Amazon chose to live in the problem space of how to bring consumers more products, more conveniently, at a lower price. Geico chose a similar goal but in insurance. Technical founders often focus on a particular cool way of solving a problem and burn lots of capital building that thing. Sometimes the thing is the right thing and everyone makes money. But sometimes it’s not. Yet if you stick with the same problem space for long enough, and aren’t too connected to your particular solution, I think you have a greater chance of succeeding. Okay, go ahead and poke at my pontifications now. I’m ready.
- barumrho 4y agoI generally agree with your statement, but it depends on what your goal is. Ultimately, do you want to build a successful business or bring a (specific) new technology into the world? I suspect the former is true more often and it can lead to innovations along the way, but there is nothing wrong with the latter.
- yobbo 4y agoDepends on perspective. What is one thing and what is a problem space. Is a microprocessor or a mobile phone one thing in many different problem spaces?
- TuringTest 4y agoBusinesses are not built on things they sell, they are built on the customer problems they help solve. If you build microprocessors, you better understand how your clients are using them to create electronic devices, and provide all the services and documentation they may need. A less potent microprocessor paired with a website that perfectly explains how to use it and what use cases it supports will win any day over a more powerful chip that no one understands.
- yobbo 4y agoYes, but the investment in things can be so great that it becomes impossible to change according to customer preferences. The business then has to find new problem spaces for their things.
- melenaboija 4y agoYup, that is similar to what my grandma used to say and that will always work: “buy cheap and try to sell as expensive as you can” and sometimes adding “it does not matter if clients need it as long as you can convince them they do”. She was an entrepreneur of 1950’s that started a small retail business.
- dpatru 4y agoIt seems to me that at the implementation stage, the things that never change and the things that do change are the same. For example, customers will always want low prices and fast delivery. Internet ordering and robots in warehouses are things that change. But the changes are better ways to fulfill the unchanging needs. So Bezos sees investments in internet ordering and robots as investments in what does not change. Whereas Andreessen sees the same investments as betting on change. So what difference does their point of view make if both entrepreneurs end up making the same investments?
- a_c 4y agoI thought the article is about change is the only constant yada yada hence we should embrace change. How wrong was I. > which is that an insurance company selling directly would have a cost and convenience advantage over those paying brokers. Put it into software, to me it is about eliminating abstraction/boundary/communication. Frontend and backend is an invented boundary. Product and Dev is an invented boundary, CS/QA/Documentation and dev is also an invented boundary. Whoever break the most of the imaginary boundaries is going to make software building so much faster
- itissid 4y agoAd infinitum: Fire, or equivalently burning something, is an unchanging idea which is the only way humans have and used over and over to get where we are.
- breck 4y ago"If you want to invent something that will still be used in 30 years, invent something that would have been used 30 years ago." - [taleb i think]
- mnsc 4y agoI'm not an Amazon customer so it doesn't apply to me, but I hate/don't use Amazon because it's too cheap and deliver too fast.
- sedeki 4y agoDo you live by this motto more generally? I'd love to have you as a customer.
- mnsc 4y agoI also hate a lot of companies that are too expensive, trying to sell you status but not backing it up with quality. So I would love it if you could sell me high quality products that are repairable and doesn't unnecessarily tax neither our planet nor the humans involved in creating them. What are you selling?
- iamwpj 4y agoAmazon has never paid dividends to investors. Its only value is to invest against interest rates or inflation. In fact, if investors wanted dividends it might upset the ability of Amazon to provide its objective. It's stable, but only philosophical. This isn't a land investment or something. It's an extension of a long term trend of consumerism.
- ChadNauseam 4y agoAmazon did a $10B buyback in march
- hardware2win 4y agoSo seems like I should invest in semiconductors
- elefantastisch 4y agoThis article seems like a good reminder to know what your fundamentals are and to be deliberate about picking them. But I'm not convinced that this advice can be used to pick your fundamentals, your core business model. Amazon opted for more choices and lower prices. Barnes & Noble stuck with faster solutions to problems (get your book today not after a week of shipping as was common when Amazon started), deeper human interactions (you can go into the store and ask someone for recommendations, meet authors, etc.), and increased confidence/trust (you know what you're getting because you can hold it in your hand and read it before you buy it). Low-cost carriers have moved in on traditional airlines because while it's true that people will never stop caring about added comfort, it turns out they care about lower prices much more. But Apple built a staggering market cap relying on the assumption that while people care about lower price, they care about great control of your time (just works) and higher social status more. So it seems like this article provides a good framework for thinking about your business, but doesn't give any answers as to the actual strategy you should use. Or am I missing something?
- eric-hu 4y agoPretty solid point. I read TFA’s take on fundamentals as neutral on the examples given. There was mention that Amazon survived where Beenz did not because they picked the right mix of changing and unchanging. On the other hand, the juxtaposition of Andreeson and Buffett says that you can find business success with seemingly opposite fundamentals.
- bippingchip 4y agoFor me this is a good example of the old adage that you should not confuse vision with strategy. The vision is you realize the universal truth (in Amazon’s case people want things cheap and fast). The strategy is how you deliver on making that visions reality. This is what you call (rightly so) your core business model. Only experience people tend to get all caught up in the big ideas of the vision (especially middle managers) but spend far to little time on making the hard choices that come with deciding in strategy: it’s as much, if not more, about deciding what not to do as it is commitment to what you will do to realize your vision.
- 4y ago
- sacrosanct 4y agoAmazon blends both worlds together. Invention coupled with stagnant business models which have worked for millennia.
- locallost 4y ago> customers want low prices, and I know that’s going to be true 10 years from now. They want fast delivery; they want vast selection. It’s impossible to imagine a future 10 years from now where a customer comes up and says, “Jeff I love Amazon, I just wish the prices were a little higher.” Actually there is one thing people are starting to desire -- less choice. I think some kind of curated content for anything has a lot of potential because mostly I do not care if I get the 100% perfect thing, I care about it being 80% right and not a headache. The time investment is not really worth the trouble to find the perfect thing.
- themitigating 4y agoThat might be for you. I actually prefer options and customization and if it's taken away I'm more annoyed than if I never had it.
- pfdietz 4y agoI prefer having the choices I want not being submerged in an ocean of crap.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoI think similar but maybe not quite the same as you. Crap has a place sometimes. But I want the same things to be grouped. IE I don't need one knockoff product with 30 different brand spellings of random letters taking up 30 slots of space in my viewport. Show me: - that option, price range, ability to dig deeper into that if I want. - 29 other things.
- locallost 4y agoPeople are definitely different and that people want choice has definitely been correct for a long time. But I'm noticing it not only in me, but with people around me -- they're just tired from dealing with choosing from 100 different things when they only need 3. Especially because most of them are the same. The internet has made this worse than ever. Companies like Apple have shown this is possible - they basically tell the user "this is what you need" and people accept it and it's worked.
- highfrequency 4y ago> I very frequently get the question: “What’s going to change in the next 10 years?” That’s a very interesting question. I almost never get the question: “What’s not going to change in the next 10 years?” And I submit to you that that second question is actually the more important of the two. You can build a business strategy around the things that are stable in time. In our retail business, we know that customers want low prices, and I know that’s going to be true 10 years from now. They want fast delivery; they want vast selection. Also Bezos (paraphrased): "While working at D.E. Shaw, I heard that the internet was growing at 2,300% per year. And I asked myself: 'what kind of business makes sense to start in the context of that kind of growth?'" The Holy Grail is when a big change allows you to get a foothold in solving a fundamental, unchanging problem better than it has been solved before - and then leveraging that foothold with rapid iteration and growth.
- makestuff 4y agoI wonder if back in 1990s people were as skeptical of the internet as they are of the metaverse/web3/crypto/autonomous driving today. All of the big money bets seem to be in these areas, and I wonder if there were a similar group of 4-5 industries that all of the money was going to in the 90s only for the internet to win out in the end as the best returns for investors.
- tabtab 4y ago"It's tough to make predictions, especially about the future." ― Yogi Berra For every ten IT trends/fads, roughly only one has staying power in my observation. The others often move into niches or fade. If anyone was that good at predicting the diamonds from the duds, they'd be golfing with Warren Buffett instead of poking around Hacker News. Note that I thought the internet had big potential in the late 90's, as I was getting hooked on Compuserve (a precursor to webbish things). I just didn't think it would ruin biz CRUD/GUI's, rather staying in the consumer lane.
- galdosdi 4y agoI remember that time, and no, it was nothing like crypto. A better analogy would be electric vehicles today. Yes, a loose analogy can be made in that there was a hyped technology that some people thought might become huge, others thought might merely become large or medium sized, and most others were pretty unaware or didn't care. Unlike with crypto, during the late 90s internet/PC/web usage explosion, though, there were decades of successful smaller scale use (BBSes, academic use of the internet, etc). It was just a matter of scaling it up. The future was already here, just unevenly distributed. Unlike crypto, a lot of the usages were not just emotionally exciting, but actually practical. You could look up a stock quote right away instead of looking at an outdated quote in the paper, or calling a broker on the phone, or having a dedicated fancy service just for that. You could email a friend half way around the world. You could read the full text of a book for free, if it was from before 1923. In general, you could transmit information freely and cheaply across the world -- as long as both recipient and sender were on the internet somehow. All of those things previously were not possible that easily. There were faxes and landline phones already, but they had their obvious limitations. Crypto is totally different. It's been hyped for two decades and, except for illegal activities, still hasn't enabled anything that could not be done more efficiently with SQL database to track who owns what, and a system of courts and law enforcement to enforce property rights and enforce contracts. If you think they are similar you probably don't remember just how different it was to not have a single simple easy way to get and receive information. You had to actually go specific places or talk to specific people. You would do stuff like check movie times in the newspaper, and make specific plans to meet people at specific times. I still remember when Tell Me came out. It was a phone number interface to some basic internet applications like weather, news, sports, movie times. You called 1-800-TELL-ME and followed the prompts. It was massively popular. Where is crypto's TellMe moment? Nowhere. The only useful thing I've ever been able to do with crypto is accidentally profit $8000 because I forgot I had owned some I had bought as a joke... which came directly out of someone else's pocket later when it crashed. If you're looking for a historical analogy, tulipmania is a good one. So is the boom in joint stock companies in the 1600s. So is the plank road boom of the late 1800s. Nobody had as strong opinions about the internet being a horrifying scam, like many do about crypto. Because it wasn't, and there was no reason to think it was. The main "issue" was, would it catch on? Was it too nerdy? I mean, it's not like now, where the internet is almost slightly cool to some young people. Buying a modem was extremely uncool. And it cost a lot of money. So it was more of a question of "Is it really ready for prime time yet or does it need to become easier to use and cheaper?" much like EVs today. And, again, like EVs today, the problem was solved gradually but exponentially... each succeessive cost decrease or simplicity increase lead to another wave of converts, which made the whole thing more useful, solving the chicken and egg problem gradually
- barbazoo 4y ago> It’s impossible to imagine a future 10 years from now where a customer comes up and says, “Jeff I love Amazon, I just wish the prices were a little higher.” Except that many consumers these days do look for business that are more socially responsible and pay their fair share downstream. Personally I am seeking out business that pay good wages and are responsible to the environment. Obviously that'll lead to higher prices so in some way I am wishing for higher prices.
- hallqv 4y agoBasically what YC has been touting for years, focus on problems not solutions.
- bovermyer 4y agoSomething that we often forget is this: Do boring things well. It's easy to chase the newest technology, the newest features, the newest markets. But unless you pay attention to the boring things too, you've set your feet on sand instead of stone.
- tomrod 4y agoReminds me of: https://boringtechnology.club/ https://boringtechnology.club/
- ismail 4y agoI like to think about it this way. The “what” is often timeless and stays the same. The “how” the what is achieved changes. I need to get from point a to point b (the what) V1: walk/run/horse V2: carriage V3: train V4: cars Etc etc There is another dimension to this as well. Sometimes the what has to completely be re-architected since society has fundamentally changed. As an example: Consider education (what) this will always be required in society. A naive version of innovation in this space would be to keep things the same and just change the delivery mechanism (online) A better innovation would be to re-imagine what it means to be educated/schooled. The best place to start is identifying the assumptions inherent in the current system. , and asking are they still relevant?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CPLX 4y agoThe irony of comparing Andreeson and Buffet and claiming they have completely opposing investment theses is pretty hilarious. They both have the exact same approach, which is to seek companies that have or will create monopoly effects in their markets, using dominance of a market segment to raise prices and extract rents. Same investment strategy that’s made basically every vast fortune since we invented the cotton gin.
- TimPC 4y agoSo they have the same strategy in the sense that absolutely everyone who ever made money had one strategy and they have a different strategy in a way that is useful and informative? I’d label that different rather than same.
- CPLX 4y agoMost people have a different strategy, which involves producing a product or service of value. Megalomaniacal monopolists such as these two seek to extract monopoly rents by cornering markets. Their differences with each other are trivial, and the contrast between them and nearly everyone else in the normal business world is stark. They are robber barons, it’s not some new and exciting story, it’s a tiny class of humans, there’s only a few dozen at any given time. > the term was typically applied to businessmen who purportedly used exploitative practices to amass their wealth.[2] These practices included exerting control over natural resources, influencing high levels of government, paying subsistence wages, squashing competition by acquiring their competitors to create monopolies and raise prices, and schemes to sell stock at inflated prices to unsuspecting investors. Sound familiar? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robber_baron_(industrialist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robber_baron_(industrialist)
- refurb 4y agoIf you're extracting rents then you're not creating any economic value. One look at the GDP tells me that's not true.
- findalex 4y ago- Everyone wants affordable housing (lets find ways to bet on it) - NINJA loans, swaps, CDOs, etc. - housing markets collapses
- llanowarelves 4y agoDon't know why you are getting downvoted. There's a lot of directions and strategic business opportunities in all 3. And it's apolitical.
- tabtab 4y agoThis reminds me of Oracle Forms: It was by today's standards simple, cheap (overall), facilitated compact code that mirrored close to biz logic, and easy to deploy. It used a kind of "GUI browser" so you didn't have to install executables to use and update apps, just one "browser". But Oracle rewrote the client into Java, and Java's deployment flaws dogged it, so co's had to gradually abandon it. They should have kept it in C. (The developer's side stayed mostly the same, it was deployment's side that got the headaches.) It wasn't esthetic, but got most CRUD jobs done quick and simple. I've never coded in it myself for production, but observed amazing productivity at multiple orgs. There's something magic about it. Oracle originally had to cater to many OS's, so were parsimonious with GUI features. Thus, it has just enough to do typical CRUD jobs but not enough to distract, confuse, and over-complicate the tool. They didn't get feature-happy over time. Once you learned how to milk existing features, you realized you really didn't need boatloads of pluggins. Current web stacks are bloated nightmares and business money sinks in comparison. I'm not saying bring back Oracle Forms as-is, but at least borrow its best lessons. We'd have more practical GUI web standards by now. (Most CRUD productivity don't need mobile UI's. Also, it may not do well for big "enterprise" apps, but for small and niche it groves.)
- CrypticShift 4y ago> You can make big, long-term bets on these things, because there’s no chance people will stop caring about them in the future. I wish more VCs thought about investing in our sustainable future on earth, the way Morgan Housel thinks about investing in sustainable companies. The only assumption that keeps us from that step is that all people care about is their short-term rational self-interest. of course, they do! what else would they care about? How can you even imagine a Market without that assumption? Yeah... let's just continue to bet. I personally bet there are some "timeless" things that will definitely change soon.
- PaulHoule 4y agoLike a stopped clock? I'd grant that Amazon has a large selection and that's an advantage over competitors. As for pricing, I wouldn't say Amazon is expensive but it is not consistently low cost and it is not unusual to see something on the shelves at Target for $50 that is selling for $70 on AMZN. I think after all these years, and particularly with Prime, AMZN has gotten people in the habit of looking to AMZN first and you'd expect them to cash in on it. The better selection than other retailers is a durable advantage. I'd call out Best Buy for having a poor selection in comparison, particularly being overly wide (they sell washing machines, grilles, and mirrorless cameras and parts to build PCs) but not sufficiently deep (no selection of lenses for those cameras, no quality tripods, a very limited supply of PC parts.) It begs the question of "Why am I going to drive to Best Buy where they might have some of the things I need when I can order them all online from Amazon or a specialist retailer?" The flip side is that the marketplace puts a lot of junk products in the AMZN catalog. I'd never buy anything that is likely to be counterfeit on AMZN (Nike only from the Nike store) and I learned the hard way not to buy a thermal printer that is marketed with a size in mm instead of inches.
- m0llusk 4y agoAmazon is mostly driven by AWS which is a very new paradigm for building business services. Insurance has been revolutionized by new methods for collecting and analyzing data in order to estimate risk. Monsanto's latest growth play is farmland and crop insurance. The examples used in this piece appear to demonstrate the opposite of what was intended.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bjornsing 4y ago> It’s impossible to imagine a future 10 years from now where a customer comes up and says, “Jeff I love Amazon, I just wish the prices were a little higher.” Or, “I love Amazon, I just wish you’d deliver a little slower.” Impossible. Interestingly that is kind of what people have started saying. Perhaps not in those exact words, but in the form of “Jeff, don’t outcompete all the Mom & Pops” and “Jeff, treat your workers better”.
- slickdork 4y agoExactly the quote that caught my guard. I don't really shop with amazon, because two things: 1) the rune goldberg machine of suffering of amazon laborers and, more selfishly: 2) everything is so cheap, that it's useless. I would rather have the choice between two or three premium options rather than having thousands of cheap knock offs.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 4y agoOnly if the premium options are worth it. More and more brands seem a hollow shell that charges a premium price worth nothing to show for us. It feels increasingly difficult to find quality products.
- shepherdjerred 4y ago> Interestingly that is kind of what people have started saying. I would be surprised if >10% of the US would prefer to pay Amazon more so that others could be treated better. Amazon is doing exactly what companies in a capitalist society are geared to do.
- ignoramous 4y agoI wrote about this and other things (viz. 'you can't fight gravity', 'start with the customer and invent on their behalf', 'one way doors / two way doors' etc) about Amazon's culture here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26180074 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26180074 Andy Jassy's 2020 re:Invent opening keynote goes a bit deeper into these ideas, which makes for a fascinating watch: https://youtube.com/watch?v=xZ3k7Fd6_eU https://youtube.com/watch?v=xZ3k7Fd6_eU
- paulpauper 4y agoThe best is rapid growth, high profit margins, but also dominance. Hence, Google, Facebook and Amazon's success. I think you need at least two of those.
- hoseja 4y ago“I love Amazon, I just wish you’d deliver a little slower.” There may be ethical concerns.