10 ms·
Why some feces float and others sink
- ttrrooppeerr 4y agoThis has igNobel written all over itself.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Overtonwindow 4y agotl;DR!: Fat content.
- ttrrooppeerr 4y agoActually, from the article: > Experiments showed that not to be the case. Instead, trials with healthy human subjects showed that the difference was due to the amount of gas in a given fecal sample.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoI’m impressed that you read the whole thing. I came away with fat content, as gas permeates away.
- jtefera 4y agoThe article is pretty short and it mainly says that it is due gas content. The amount of gas seems to be dependent on the presence of certain gut bacteria. According to the study, naturally about half of the population of mice produce floaters. When you collect stool samples of that half and inject it on the other half, they also start producing floaters. On the other hand, when you sterelize the gut of the floater group, they start producing feces that sink. Fat content seems not to be related.
- pantulis 4y agoWho would have said that it was all the Archimedes Principle.
- aidenn0 4y agoA book I read as a child (ca. 1990) claimed it was gas content; good to know it was correct (even if by accident).
- _dain_ 4y agonope, it's fart content
- DonHopkins 4y agoThere needs to be another "fart content" dimension to the Bristol Stool Scale. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bristol_stool_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bristol_stool_scale
- bitwize 4y agoI smell an IgNobel in the authors' future. Given the subject matter, that's not all I smell. And gut bacteria are involved, so this is super relevant to Hackernews.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoAt school, I was taught that floating poop was a sign you have enough fiber in your diet. A quick Google suggests that digesting fiber changes the gas/air content.
- lost_tourist 4y agonotice this on keto, many more sinkers with fat/protein heavy poo I guess?
- largepeepee 4y ago
- johnthuss 4y agoIn space they are all floaters.
- jcims 4y agoTL;DR - poop is alive! Maybe it's because I've gone through various hobbies related to fermentation but trapped gas seems like the most obvious and likely answer. Especially when you see bubbles around floaters. It's also very simple to test...take a floater, put it in a vacuum just above where water will start to boil off, then see if it still floats. Alternatively, compare its displacement before and after smooshing it through a fine grate. (Note I said simple, not easy xD)
- anonu 4y agoSo far the discussion in this thread is lacking, some would say its shit. Understanding our gut is an overlooked part of medicine and biology. I think theres a certain taboo around the subject. But you can learn a lot about health, your mood, sleep cycles, etc from what comes out the other end. We need more research in this area. A decade or two ago, fecal transplants were considered joke medicine. Now its an important tool in treating certain gut infections: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fecal_microbiota_transplant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fecal_microbiota_transplant
- RupertEisenhart 4y agoStrong agree. For all the evidence and talk about 'the microbiome is a newly discovered organ', people sure do struggle to look beyond the surface reading of the research-- yes, all the research in this area is research about shit, and often involves putting things inside arseholes. Hilarious as arseholes undoubtedly are, its a real shame seeing this research held back by this. One interesting corollary of the article-- I wonder if human corpses sink or swim in accordance with their former flatulence-- and how much the old tale about eating after dinner is determined by these selfsame gasses!
- jack_pp 4y agoI'm not familiar with the literature but I was rewatching Scrubs recently which is a 10-20 y/o show and it was mentioned in an episode that you could tell a lot about a person's health by looking at their stool, even made a joke about a "Doctor Toilet", a smart toilet that analyzes your stool
- dec0dedab0de 4y agoIn the musical episode they have a song called everything comes down to poo. https://youtu.be/2BDd0XseGtU https://youtu.be/2BDd0XseGtU
- vxNsr 4y agoFirst thing I thought of when reading this study.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Iwan-Zotow 4y agoThis is IgNobel right away
- kinleyd 4y agoI feel this study is incomplete - we should ask Austin Powers and Fat Bastard to weigh in as well.
- groffee 4y agoWhat a time to be alive.
- gorkish 4y agoI see someone else is looking forward to Károly Zsolnai-Fehér's presentation of this exciting research.
- roland35 4y agoAsking the big questions here!! What I really want to know is what happens to "ghost feces"... Sometimes you know one dropped into the toilet but it is nowhere to be seen...
- gravitate 4y agoTypically that's very heavy feces with no gas caused by various bacteria in it, and it slips right down the plumbing without needing to flush.
- bombcar 4y agoYep, if you want to experiment, take a dry toilet (no water) and roll marbles until you get it just right to "halfpipe" its way out the drain. Water affects this but not much; or you get a rocket-floater that dives down and comes up on the "other side" of the built-in trap.
- Maxburn 4y agoRocket floater!
- lost_tourist 4y agoninja poops
- vianneychevalie 4y agoI call them dolphins
- eCa 4y agoIf you want to avoid it, get a german toilet[1]. Depending on your opinion on stool inspection, it’s either the best thing ever or the opposite. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=german+toilet https://www.google.com/search?q=german+toilet
- newsclues 4y agoThankfully in the pre cellphone era, I was on a canoe trip in Algonquin Park. In the middle of a large Lake, the call of nature struck with a sense of urgency that required a solution quicker than just, "Paddle harder to land." A jump into the lake and removing of trousers resulted in an "Aqua Dump". But alas it was a floater, rather than sinking to the unknown depths. It was a shocking discovery at the time.
- jonsen 4y agoJust wonder, what would you have done if you had a cellphone?
- fipar 4y agoPerhaps they were not alone, and today someone would have documented the result?
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoYeah, now they wouldn't need to tell the story, they could just link the YouTube video.
- newsclues 4y agoTook a video of my camp councillor trying to swim away from a floating turd and gone viral on TikTok.
- DonHopkins 4y agoCue the Jaws theme. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TPxiXGr9nFM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TPxiXGr9nFM
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 4y agoOh, boy, Yancy. You reek, ah!
- smithcoin 4y agoThe article didn't answer the one question I had. Which is more indicative of a healthier gut biome - a floater or a sinker?
- rhacker 4y agoA stinker. No seriously my wife and I were just talking about this a few days ago. The floaters indicate you're not processing fats very well. So the sinkers.
- kingofpandora 4y agoThey are all stinkers.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoBut the article says that floating vs non-floating has little to do with fat content. It's the gases generated by bacteria that cause the stool to float, not the fat.
- throwaway89201 4y ago> The floaters indicate you're not processing fats very well. No. As a cited article concludes: "Thus, stools float because of an increased content of gas or water (or both); the floating stool should not be considered a sign of [excess fat in feces]." [1]. [1] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM197205042861804 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM197205042861804
- mrpopo 4y agoThey reject your argument in the article, just into the 2nd paragraph. > Prior to the 1970s, scientists believed that fecal matter either sank or floated depending on the amount of fat it contained. Experiments showed that not to be the case.
- dennis_jeeves1 4y agoNot sure of the healthier gut biome, but that of health, it's the sinker
- awiesenhofer 4y agoPhys.org might want to reread european cookie notice legislature, just linking to "about cookies" when clicking "cookie options" with no direct way to reject doesnt fly anymore.
- jordinl 4y agoCan these be reported somewhere?
- barbarbar 4y agoI think it would be a good idea if they made an app with more info. And maybe fecesbook would be a good name for such app.
- tag2103 4y agoSocial media is already a pretty shitty situation, this would fall right into place. =)
- scrivna 4y agoWhen I walk in to a public men’s bathroom I hear a lot of noises I don’t hear in my own house, I often wonder what’s going on with other peoples bodies given I only know my own experience, clearly we’re all very different ;-)
- MisterTea 4y ago"Public restroom shyness"? Some people are so uncomfortable going bout their business in public that they have trouble getting things moving. I used to work with a guy who would leave work for the day if he had to take a dump as he would only shit at home which was an hour commute one way.
- civilized 4y agoBack when I was commuting to an office, my favorite thing to learn about a building was where the least-used bathroom was. I would make my daily paid-to-poop pilgrimage to this sanctuary. It was a slow and spiritual journey, like walking on knees to the Basilica of Guadalupe.
- gattr 4y agoI was quite uncomfortable (but managed to get the business done) for the first week or so after arriving in the US (business trip) due to the inch-wide gaps around stall doors. When flying back, going to the toilet in the first European airport was very... moving.
- wlll 4y agoI contracted for a company in the US (I'm in the UK usually) and the stalls were terrible. Big gaps between the doors and frames, and really big gaps underneath the dividing walls too, so you could identify your co-worker by their shoes. The ability to put a noise to a face was really quite off-putting.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoBe assured, no one is spying on you or cares that you are pooping.
- mcoliver 4y ago"what's your poo telling you" is one of my favorite white elephant gifts. Gave it to a family member when they were in college, they kept it in the bathroom and it was stolen almost every time they had a party. https://www.amazon.com/dp/0811857824/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/0811857824/
- marshallward 4y ago
- adolph 4y agoThe gut-brain axis (GBA) consists of bidirectional communication between the central and the enteric nervous system, linking emotional and cognitive centers of the brain with peripheral intestinal functions. Recent advances in research have described the importance of gut microbiota in influencing these interactions. This interaction between microbiota and GBA appears to be bidirectional, namely through signaling from gut-microbiota to brain and from brain to gut-microbiota by means of neural, endocrine, immune, and humoral links. In this review we summarize the available evidence supporting the existence of these interactions, as well as the possible pathophysiological mechanisms involved. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4367209/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4367209/
- ispo 4y agoThe other day someone shared a paper linking some gut bacteria to oxytocin levels, which regulate sociality.
- swader999 4y agoQueue the next Elizabeth Holmes to get into this in a revolutionary world beating way.
- samhickmann 4y ago
- zanethomas 4y agoIs this related to the reason some stinks and others don't?
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI nominate this paper for an Ig Nobel. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ig_Nobel_Prize https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ig_Nobel_Prize
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- djaouen 4y agoI for one am glad we are finally investigating the real issues of society
- cmoski 4y agoI look forward to the day when I can buy probiotics specifically to make my poop sink or float.
- SCLeo 4y agoI should not have read Hackernews while having dinner...
- qwertox 4y agoSince I've stopped eating bread I only have sinkers. No more floaters, no more stinking toilet, no more multiple flushes. I still don't know exactly what caused it, if it was the gluten or the modern issue that industrial bread (even whole grain) isn't given enough time to rest (long-term fermentation?) so that it then continues to work inside the gut causing the problems, given a certain unhealthy gut microbiome which either can't deal with it or somehow goes crazy on it. It was not just bread, though. Also oatmeal and cereals, so it isn't that clear. It was always related to the amount of gas which would end up in the feces.