3 ms·
> Only if your problem exhibits the above property (and it's a distributed system) does using a blockchain make sense. I think we also need to specify that it'
by Terr_ 4y ago
> Only if your problem exhibits the above property (and it's a distributed system) does using a blockchain make sense.
I think we also need to specify that it's also an extremely distinct and rare type of "distributed": When you must support unrestricted and unlimited creation of new participant nodes.
That's the fundamental requirement that drives an entire cascade of other blockchain design choices, such as proof-of-work to prevent a takeover by sockpuppet-nodes, and mining to incentivize regular consistent participation by a presumed-benign majority. Without that requirement and workarounds, we're left with a kind of regular distributed database, pre-hype technology that already featured hashes and linked-lists.
This requirement ("anybody can become part of the network anonymously") also makes for a great litmus-test for whether you need blockchain.
For example, in national elections we probably don't want/need literally any number of computers anywhere in the world to jump in and deciding what happens based on their CPU power. It would be dramatically faster/easier/safer to simply define a fixed list of nodes, where each state runs a couple plus the federal government, and then rely on the fact that evildoers would have to compromise too many different systems and agencies.
- akrymski 4y agoI think the word is "decentralised" rather than distributed: no single authority that controls membership of a distributed system, in a P2P style
- pid-1 4y agoI think Byzantine Fault Tolerance is the name of such propriety (being resilient to a limited number of adversarial nodes).
- adolph 4y agoPeople don’t use that term anymore because the generals of many countries present the same problem, not just those of the Eastern Roman Empire. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/byzantine-generals-problem/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/byzanti...
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoThis seems like another case of deprecating language based on an individual or cohort realizing something that a reasonable person would have already assumed.