3 ms·
What I don't understand the value of is NFT. What is the value in digital ephemera? How would it be different from copyright?
by WalterBright 4y ago
What I don't understand the value of is NFT. What is the value in digital ephemera? How would it be different from copyright?
- knorker 4y agoThat's kind of off topic, but here's a great explanation of NFTs: https://onezero.medium.com/nfts-arent-as-stupid-as-you-think-bffab89697e3 https://onezero.medium.com/nfts-arent-as-stupid-as-you-think... Edit: to answer your question, NFTs expressed in traditional speak would be this: An exclusive transferable license to claim that you are the current holder of a string of bytes loosely associated with a work of art. No copyright is assigned to you, and you get no other rights either, such as rights to duplicate, re-license, or create derivative works.
- ogogmad 4y agoExactly, and what if you forget or lose this string of bytes? Or what if someone finds it, and transfers ownership to himself? It's impossible to get it redeemed because of how the technology works. No court on Earth would - or even should - recognise something like this.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhat I thought. They are stupid.
- cykros 4y agoNFT's are fine, in that the represent a token that isn't fungible, and as such, would be a great way which, if regulated, would allow for things like selling real estate (deeds) or automobiles (titles) and other things of this nature using the blockchain to avoid the possibility of forgery, and to cut out the overhead associated with verifying chain of custody in conventional systems. Obviously, the adoption needs to happen and regulations need to be written for this to happen effectively, but it very well could. As far as trading silly gifs that you "own", well...yes, it's asinine. But not really any moreso than how much money kids these days are pumping into Fortnite skins and similar nonsense.
- knorker 4y ago> would be a great way which, if regulated, would allow for things like selling real estate (deeds) or automobiles (titles) Absolutely not. The source of truth for real estate is the local government's land registry. The NFT blockchain can never be the source of truth, since ownership can change due to court action, bankruptcy, eminent domain, or whatever. You cannot have someone refuse to give up their passwords, and just give up "ok, I guess you own this real estate or car forever, then". No. The police will come arrest you if you squat. The government will not care that you have the private key to an NFT of the house. Blockchain solutions inherently cannot be the source of truth. Which means they'll drift away from the truth. Which means they become pointless.