3 ms·
This is a bit like carbon capture from the air. Yes, energy is going to be cheap, and yes we can do this, and in some cases we may have to. But there's so many
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
This is a bit like carbon capture from the air.
Yes, energy is going to be cheap, and yes we can do this, and in some cases we may have to. But there's so many simpler ways to just stop wasting the water we do have, this should be a last resort.
- akira2501 4y agoYou can either solve the problem with money, or you can change human behavior with regulatory burden that ultimately depends on force. I'd think you're way better off just solving the problem. Someone else called this "solutionism." Well, this article makes an exceptionally good case that the amount of input cost justifies the output economic activity by more than order of magnitude... so with this in hand, what would the justification be for forcing unnecessary changes in human behavior?
- lm28469 4y agoIt's not solving the root cause though, it's more like a bandage on an open wound. Tech allowed us to live in ways that are 10-100x time to wasteful to be sustainable, we should learn to be frugal again
- akira2501 4y agoThe root cause is humanity. You cannot "solve" this. You can only force people to do what you want as opposed to what they would want. Our frugality was not a learned trait that we've simply discarded.. it was purely a consequence of our lack of technological progress and the austerity it forced on us. It's the oddest thing to me to live in this world of amazing technological progress, while openly suggesting that throwing this technology away and returning to austerity is the only viable "solution."
- baxtr 4y agoWhile I would love to agree, I even like it better to see statistics about this. What are biggest lever for saving water? Would you mind sharing?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoAgriculture is about 1/3rd of water usage in California, we have more efficient irrigation schemes available that are only used in some places. They even have co-benefits like using less fertilizer which saves money as well as being good for the environment. Can even help the crops grow better if they get the right amount of water. But just as people won't buy EVs if they're allowed to pollute for free, as it'll make the EV seem expensive, it doesn't make business sense to install modern irrigation systems if you're paying close to zero for your water. This is where it becomes political and about legal claims to water rather than tech though.
- ars 4y ago> stop wasting the water You need to define that carefully. If I use water in a city, and dump it down the drain, that water is not wasted - it's cleaned, and then returned to the watershed for the next city downstream. On the other hand, water used in an arid area to irrigate (especially flood irrigation) could be wasted - but it depends on where it ultimately rains. some places that extra water causes rain in places that need it, other places it rains in places that have plenty of rain. Are you on septic? That seems like the water is wasted - it goes underground. But if it refills underground storage reservoirs, it's not actually wasted. So defining "water waste" is much more complicated than it may appear.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoAlso in utah, at least there's nothing 'we' can do about it, as lay people. All the households combined account for less than 2% of water usage. Industry, Farming, and Golfing account for the rest.