3 ms·
Against Taiwan? Why? Wouldn't they operate out of Okinawa? Maybe you'd bring some carriers into the area, but the air base already exists. Also it seems like th
by jeffbee 4y ago
Against Taiwan? Why? Wouldn't they operate out of Okinawa? Maybe you'd bring some carriers into the area, but the air base already exists. Also it seems like the Chinese would stand an excellent chance of sinking carriers. I think they're one of the more fanciful and unlikely assets in a war of peers. They only really work against non-technological enemies like the Libyans.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoCarriers as weapons really are technology for the previous century's war. Carriers as mobile military bases are still very useful for projecting power.
- jeffbee 4y agoThat does not seem at all obvious to me. It's a big, slow, easy target. Yes you can use them to project power into, say, Sierra Leone, but not against China. None of the expensive and fragile missile defense systems have a demonstrated history of doing anything useful.
- depereo 4y agoYou can project power hundreds to thousands of miles forward of a land mass or established base by using a carrier. Even operating it in a very cautious manner affords a great deal of tactical advantage you would not otherwise have available.
- hollerith 4y agoThe top speed of a US nuclear-powered carrier is secret, but it is known to be able to do 40 knots easily, which is not slow for a ship.
- jeffbee 4y agoIt's not a boat race. State-of-the-art anti-ship missiles may hit mach 5 in their terminal phase. Also a carrier that outruns its escort is an even softer target, and no other craft in a carrier group can keep up with the carrier's max speed.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoProjecting power is about bringing weapons to places where you want to blow stuff up, not about necessarily having a frontline fortress. That's why US military bases are everywhere (and nearly unfortified). An actual war with China will be a global affair. The aircraft carriers don't need to get in range of the missiles to bring airplanes, food, and hospitals to somewhere there is fighting. Practically, the bases in Japan are going to be the main hubs for forces fighting near China, not aircraft carriers.
- swagasaurus-rex 4y agoAir bases don't move at all. From a tactical standpoint they're much less useful than a carrier that can stay out of the range of all but the most expensive missiles.
- echelon 4y ago> Also it seems like the Chinese would stand an excellent chance of sinking carriers. Only if they can't hide. If the US disables Chinese satellites, then China will have to rely on air- and marine-based sensors. Satellites will be the first thing to go. The wars of the future will have a heavy space component.
- sudosysgen 4y agoThe Chinese have multiple geostationary orbit satellites with enough resolution to target a carrier. Meaning that by the time the missile reaches the orbit of the satellite (around 5 hours), the Chinese would have had the time to track and sink a carrier about 14 times over. On top of that they also have a fleet of unmanned submarines and an unmanned supersonic observation drone program as well as a sonarphone network. Beyond this the carriers are so slow and the missiles so fast that assuming they fire the missiles within a few minutes of their satellites being shot down, the carrier is still unlikely to avoid the missiles target acquisition zone.
- jeffbee 4y agoEven the idea that the U.S. could promptly launch a kinetic weapon into geostationary orbit is a bit fanciful.
- QuadmasterXLII 4y agothe kinetic weapons are almost certainly already in geo
- sudosysgen 4y agoIt's often less efficient and slower to hit a target in GEO from GEO than from the ground
- echelon 4y agoThere are presumably countermeasures already within striking distance from adversarial satellites. Kinetic, laser, radio jamming, clandestinely placed surface mines... The DoD has been thinking of space warfare since the 60's. The space shuttle program was built for defense purposes. Now they have X planes to carry out these missions, and they're continually launching classified payloads.
- dirtyid 4y agoDeemed not survivable. Hence US trying to get JP to do distributed basing across islands (ACE /agile combat employment), but for obvious reasons, JP is reluctant.
- tb_technical 4y agoMy understanding is that the US is getting kicked out of Okinawa because of sex crimes over a long period of time. Guam would be the next closest airfield the US is guaranteed to fly out of.