4 ms·
So what were the 10,000 people working on? How does that staffing number compare to Google Assistant or Apple Siri? Now that Google and Apple have offline on-d
by walterbell 4y ago
So what were the 10,000 people working on? How does that staffing number compare to Google Assistant or Apple Siri?
Now that Google and Apple have offline on-device speech models, Amazon could provide offline speech recognition plus the ability to script 3rd-party APIs without going through their cloud. They could even limit that feature to Prime or other subscription, if they want to retain a surveillance business model for non-subscription users.
For people with visual or physical impairments, Echo/Alexa can be life changing, as it can control lights, sound/video, TV, internet radio, fans, microwave and landline phones. Yet, it could do so much more, if their stellar far-field microphone platform was a trustable (offline) voice interface to any home/IoT device or cloud service with an open API.
New Echo devices even include motion detection, another under-utilized capability in a sea of sketchy IoT devices with questionable firmware. Amazon already has robust security for AWS and mindshare with developers, they are missing the opportunity to offer the most secure, most hackable voice platform for home security and automation.
Have big companies forgotten the cardinal rule of platforms? First you let creativity and innovation explode, THEN you steal the best use cases and incorporate them into the platform. It doesn't work in the other direction, no matter how many PMs, whiteboards and lego-filled rooms you throw at early markets. See the Twitter API for prior lost opportunity.
Voice UX is a combination of CLI grammar and a long tail of use cases which are unique yet frequent enough to memorize commands. It's not too late to make Alexa an offline-first, developer friendly voice platform for ... everything, not just whitelisted partner devices and interfaces.
- ghaff 4y agoThe vast majority of people don't care one whit about online vs. offline. At least outside of niches such as mobility and visual impairments. All those companies--and doubtless others to a lesser degree--have just spent billions developing what are loosely smarthome capabilities that most just don't care about or find useful. It's a case of solving the relatively half of the problem doesn't necessarily buy you much.
- walterbell 4y agoYes, we know that people only care about what they can do. Right now, they don't care about what (little) they can do with Alexa. Local-first would open up existing home automation systems, enabling new functions (e.g. composite, cross-device and cross-service actions) that are not possible today. Without removing restrictions on developers, people can't find out what they can do.
- ghaff 4y ago>open up existing home automation systems\ Most people don't have existing home automation systems to any significant degree and have very little interest in same. Devices are not remotely able to do the vast majority of the housekeeping cleanup/organizing/etc. things that I would like someone/something to do for me. I only have a single smart light because it doesn't have a convenient wall switch.
- walterbell 4y agoOne could argue that Echo/Alexa was the first mass-market home automation system, in terms of the number of controllable devices. It was certainly bigger than anything that came before. But that doesn't cover niche devices, for which open interfaces are the most likely path to gaining support, e.g. HomeAssistant integrates with 1000 devices. It's not about the general ability of devices to solve your household problems, it's about whether all of your favorite devices (which you already have) can be controlled by your chosen voice platform. Same issue with "universal" remotes.