3 ms·
> If people wanted cheap, low-powered cars, they would just use golf carts. The article author (me) lives in Wisconsin, where the weather is currently snowy an
by lapcat 4y ago
> If people wanted cheap, low-powered cars, they would just use golf carts.
The article author (me) lives in Wisconsin, where the weather is currently snowy and 18 F. Golf carts are a nonstarter.
Besides, an electric golf cart's range is only about 25 miles, which gets you around a golf course a few times but not much farther.
- rglullis 4y agoSeems like the article author has a problem to understand the concept of hyperbole...
- lapcat 4y agoPoe's Law. If you want to make a serious argument that's understood, then perhaps avoid the hyperbole. Without the hyperbole, though, the argument seems to fall apart, because there are many car models that are significantly cheaper than Teslas.
- rglullis 4y ago> because there are many car models that are significantly cheaper than Teslas. The problem is that you are anchoring your argument on the price of the Tesla. A company that wanted to bring, e.g, an all-electric version of the Honda Fit/Fiat 500/Peugeot 100/Renault Twingo/etc wouldn't be competing with Teslas, they would be competing against the ICE version of a compact/economic car. Price-sensitive people are never going to buy a $18-25k electric car, if the ICE equivalent version costs half of that. "Oh, but it's cheaper than a Tesla" is not relevant.
- lapcat 4y ago> Price-sensitive people are never going to buy a $18-25k electric car, if the ICE equivalent version costs half of that. "Oh, but it's cheaper than a Tesla" is not relevant. Most people are price-sensitive. This doesn't mean they purchase exclusively based on the cheapest price. If the wealthy can spend more to save the environment, why can't the non-wealthy? They just can't spend the same total amount.
- rglullis 4y agoIt's a curve. Try to model how many people would pay 50%-100% premium on a small car EV car when they the $25-$30k would be getting a bigger/better car, and compare with many people would be willing to pay the 20-30% premium of a Tesla (or a EV Mustang, or EV BMW, etc) vs the ICE equivalent. Let me put another way: if the market for smaller EV cars were an actual profitable opportunity, don't you think that at least some of the car companies would be going after it?
- lapcat 4y ago> if the market for smaller EV cars were an actual profitable opportunity I've been arguing that Musk's motive is profit, not saving the Earth. If he truly believed the Earth's environment was in danger, and saving it was his life's goal, then I don't think the question of "profitable opportunity" would stand in his way. I'm not interested in evaluating Musk as a businessperson. I'm interested in his self-promoted reputation as a "humanitarian". Making EVs is not inherently a humanitarian act. The other auto companies are doing it now too, and nobody ever thought they were trying to save the Earth. There's obviously a lot of money to be made, and Musk has made it. As I see it, he's really good at making wealthy people feel good about themselves.
- rglullis 4y ago> I don't think the question of "profitable opportunity" would stand in his way. There is absolutely nothing that can be done on a large scale if you don't have any type of economic power. Don't forget that even today none of his post-PayPal large ventures have turned any actual profit. People are only investing in Tesla, SpaceX, SolarCity and etc because they believe that it might be profitable. If it was known to be a money sink, we would still be stuck in the status quo. > I'm interested in his self-promoted reputation as a "humanitarian". And I don't care at anyone's ideology or their intrinsic motivation. Just look at the whole FTX saga to see how an "Effective Altruist" is responsible for the largest scam of this generation. What matters at the end of the day is that Tesla broke the dominance of the big car companies and turned EV cars from mere prototypes into actual vehicles that people can buy. (Yes, it is still the exception, but soon it will become the rule)
- SyzygistSix 4y agoThey have a problem understanding a lot of things.
- lapcat 4y agoDo we really need personal comments/attacks like that here? Debate the issues, but don't insult my intelligence.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoThe entire reason other companies are now making electric cars and will be making cheaper electric cars is that Tesla forced them to by eating into their profits. And I realize the Model Y isn't cheap. Yet. But it will likely be the highest selling car in the world next year, replacing Toyota. You can gripe about them not being economical but replacing the use of fossil fuels is the bigger issue being addressed. And isn't having the wealthy and people with expendable income fund that transition what we want?
- lapcat 4y ago> The entire reason other companies are now making electric cars and will be making cheaper electric cars is that Tesla forced them to by eating into their profits. No, many governments have imposed requirements on manufacturers to produce a certain number of low emission vehicles. > But it will likely be the highest selling car in the world next year, replacing Toyota. I don't know about that. > And isn't having the wealthy and people with expendable income fund that transition what we want? Yes and no. Should they fund it? Sure. But the transition has to expand far beyond their personal vehicle ownership, as the wealthy are only a minority. Tesla gives the impression of wanting to cater exclusively to a certain class of people. Which is fine for a luxury auto maker, but Porsche, Lexus, etc., don't offer the pretense that they're saving the Earth. We don't really have any time to wait. It may be too late already. Global warming has arrived in force. We're blowing through all the numbers that scientists warned about.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoToyota can make Corollas and Camrys cheap because they can produce en masse. No new industry can scale to that size quickly enough to replicate that production model. Even legacy auto makers are struggling to scale and produce EVs cheaply. Expecting Tesla to do that right away is ridiculous and unfair. And the only reason regulators as well as automakers moved to EVs was because it was shown to be possible and really, really popular. Tesla did that. And voting in public officials who will implement mass transit is not Elon's job. It's ours. He's busy doing the things private industry can do, despite criticism and naysayers. Maybe we should get on our part.