15 ms·
I don't want to go back to social media
- Proven 4y ago
- retrocryptid 4y agoI gave up Facebook a decade ago and Twitter about four years ago (after being banned for calling Mitch McConnell an **hat.) Strangely, HN comments fill some of that void. The troll to decent human ratio here is pretty decent, and I get references to several decent sites / blog posts / ideas per day. But I probably only spend 10-15 min per day on average here. With the rest of the time I recovered from quitting social media, I've been reading books. (I should also mention the last child left the house recently, so I have A LOT more spare time. I'll be damned if I spend it on twitter-like time sinks.)
- loceng 4y ago
- headsoup 4y agoHN being focused on tech allows it to be somewhat like a streamlined forum section with clear and implemented moderation guidelines. Without any of the other fluff/crud. I.e, Facebook could work similarly if it was just private/public groups run by group admins/moderators. (except it kills their ad model) Twitter could work similarly if there was no pure 'public' thread and everything had to sit under a topic or group. (except it kills their ad model) - or it switches to having business/personal accounts, where business accounts can broadcast yet personal accounts must be in a group/topic or responding to a business post. In other other words, I think one big issue is the "I can post whatever to everyone any time" in no particular topic or group or category, and the money that chaos can bring.
- revskill 4y agoWait, if Musk left Twitter, will you come back ?
- browningstreet 4y agoJust last night I unfollowed everyone on Twitter and kept only the lists I use for travel. There are some hard to replace twitter services/accounts related to weather, travel, roads, snow, etc. I have equity in my Tesla. I would replace it with another vehicle that connected to the supercharger network, but no one has taken Elon up on that. Elon’s an issue, but open social and algo feeds are the biggest problem. Not being able to get away from recommended content is an enormous problem. It’s the open dunking, hot takes and karma posting that finally did me in. Elon’s just another tweeter, really. But I don’t need it. I don’t want exposure to any of it. And I’m won’t endure another election cycle on social media. And truth be told, more than half of the posts I write on HN I delete immediately. It feeds on a part of me that isn’t necessary to keep alive. I have some creator accounts. I’m a YouTuber. One of the benefits of that platform is I don’t have a super direct & immediate conversation with my audience or the accounts I follow. I consume a lot of YouTube, but the hard work and displaced temporalness of the content makes it generally more thoughtful and kind. Twitter has this sense that it represents the current global POV, which I never get on YouTube. It is really hard work to put together a 10 minute YouTube video, usually 4-8 hours, and keeping/growing an audience is easier when you aim your tone a bit higher. The disconnect and lack of immediacy removes a lot of the bad temptations. Not all of them… but it’s better for me. It’s not just Elon on Twitter, but Elon was my tipping point.
- bumblewax 4y agoThe Twitter implosion has made me realize how I really used Twitter and what sort of alternative I'd join. Primarily a place where I can get a filtered list of news articles and posts from people I'm interested in what they have to say. Comments on posts are fine but it's more about getting all the content in the same place. HN is pretty close to that, but maybe a bit too niche.
- headsoup 4y agoWhy can't you do that on twitter?
- jader201 4y agoThere’s a big difference in Twitter and HN. On Twitter, the filtering is done by you (mostly: you can’t choose what content is posted by those you follow, or the comments others post). On HN, the filtering is done by others (mostly: you can filter by “Show HN”, “Ask HN”, new, etc.) Twitter is like an RSS feed of specific people/companies/interests that you get to select and everyone’s is unique, where HN is a crowd curated — and dang moderated — list of links, and everyone sees the same list. I don’t think HN is close at all to what Twitter is (for better and worse).
- Markoff 4y ago> On HN, the filtering is done by others (mostly: you can filter by “Show HN”, “Ask HN”, new, etc.) That's why I read HN via Serializer (disabled all other websites), because I don't really wanna curated HN homepage from certain brigades and I wanna choose what I read and what _I_ find interesting. You can also get your individual URL to share across devices, which I find very useful. https://serializer.io/ https://serializer.io/
- egberts1 4y agoImplosion? 100M tweet per hour sure sounds like Twitter is already more than ready for the Qatar World Cup tweets.
- jader201 4y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoHeh. I get the feeling that Mr. Johnson is not a Mr. Musk fan... > I've come to feel that social media is an addiction, unhealthy for me and also for humanity in general. I find this to be very true. But addiction is a market, and people who sell to addicts make a lot of money. "Junk is the ideal product... the ultimate merchandise. No sales talk necessary. The client will crawl through a sewer and beg to buy." –William S. Burroughs
- thenerdhead 4y agoI'm torn on the topic. On one hand, you can accomplish so much in your life in a short amount of time by not endlessly consuming social media. From personal experience, you read more, write more, build more, and enjoy being in the moment with your loved ones more. On another hand, being a creator on social media can change your perspective of how much impact you can have on the world by helping others with whatever you're able to help with. Create a lot, consume little. This however comes with a responsibility: "The more you create, the more powerful you become. The more you consume, the more powerful others become."
- bsnnkv 4y agoThis is a great comment. Over the last year I have become a creator. I teach and translate Afghan folk poetry on TikTok, I livestream code contributions to a complex open source project on YouTube, and I'm thinking of starting to stream myself working through difficult language learning textbooks as well. After seeing the positive impact I'm able to have in people's lives; showing them that open source and Rust are not so scary, getting teenagers in exile and diaspora reconnected with their languages and roots etc., I'm no longer comfortable making blanket "social media bad" comments anymore.
- carapace 4y agoFor me the crucial point is that those services are closed and proprietary and they do not make hardware, in other words, they are packaging capabilities that your machine(s) already have, they are not fundamentally adding anything to the system. All those positive impacts you're making are orthogonal (in my POV) from the companies who are using them as a kind of camouflage or stalking horse for their parasitic and (ironically) anti-social behavior.
- bsnnkv 4y agoIn the case of TikTok and Afghan folk poetry, there is just no way that I would have been able to reach the audience of tens of thousands that I have without TikTok. I didn't even have to do anything besides upload videos; their algorithm figured who would like it, and put the content in front of them. I don't necessarily disagree with anything you're saying, but at the same time I can't just dismiss the difference that this makes, especially when creating content for non-white, non-Anglophone audiences.
- hunter-gatherer 4y agoHe comments at the end, particularly to Tesla cars and their affordibility, I wish wouod get more mainstream attention. I would love a Tesla without all the bullshit gimmicks that exist in cars today. I literally use nothing but the ac/heater and AM/FM radio. Give me manual windows for all I care. Cars just aren't affordable to the middle or lower classes.
- pmoriarty 4y agoThe things that are important about modern cars to me are the safety features. It's amazing that cars these days will warn you or even steer you back when you're drifting out of a lane, for example, or alert you when you're backing up and they sense a car or pedestrian coming your way, or cameras that are so much easier to see through than fogged-up or snow-covered windows. I wouldn't want to give those up. Touch-screen displays and bluetooth, however, I could live without... not to mention all the tracking and spying today's electronics do on you. A big "no thanks" to that!
- lotsofpulp 4y agoTouch screen displays and Bluetooth cost a few hundred dollars for budget options, and a thousand for nice ones. Surely the utility of CarPlay/Android Auto is worth that for most people, even if just from navigation apps. https://www.bestbuy.com/site/sony-6-2-apple-carplay-built-in-bluetooth-in-dash-digital-media-receiver-black/6283607.p?skuId=6283607 https://www.bestbuy.com/site/sony-6-2-apple-carplay-built-in...
- douglaswlance 4y agoYet the author's Twitter account still exists. Why wouldn't they delete it?
- lapcat 4y ago1) To prevent imposters. We already saw how this became a big problem with the blue checkmark fiasco. 2) I made it a practice to delete most of my tweets within a week, so there are only about 3000 tweets remaining. A lot of those are referenced by external links that I don't want to break. Some of my tweets have even appeared in news media stories. So it's about preservation of the web rather than preservation of Twitter itself.
- PeterStuer 4y agoI was never into Twitter but I quit Facebook in 2017. I felt social media brought out a worse version of not just me but many others as well. So gg on quitting for the author. That said; "Why did I leave Twitter? My biggest fear about the Twitter acquisition had quickly become an incontrovertible reality: the new right-wing ownership group of Twitter intended to exploit the service to promote political propaganda." I'm sorry author. Twitter has always been a political propaganda platform. I think you didn't mind that at all under the previous regime.
- Pigalowda 4y agoEveryone loves the smell of their own brand!
- OctopusLupid 4y agoThe author mentions that they don’t want something similar to Twitter. I feel like they should give Mastodon a try. It differs from person to person, but for me the Fediverse is a lot more personal, equitable and smaller due to the way federation currently works. That seems in line with what the author wants, no? Related article: https://wordsmith.social/elilla/a-futuristic-mastodon-introduction-for-2021 https://wordsmith.social/elilla/a-futuristic-mastodon-introd.... Feel free to submit. Furthermore, the author says that they don’t want QTs due to the toxicity they generate. Mastodon fulfils that too.
- the-printer 4y ago> And how does it make sense for a space pioneer to support a political party currently dominated by Young Earth Creationists? What is the correlation (or contradiction) here? I do not know what a Young or Old Earth creationist is and the corresponding Wikipedia entries are more rabbit-hole inducing than I’d like to endeavor upon. I do understand the general thesis of the author’s lament, his ideological influences aside. I think that social media as it is popularly perceived is dead for anyone who wants to use the internet with some sense of dignity or literacy. In my opinion, the future of social communication online will be led by the “anti-social”; meaning people who do not care about protocols, engagements, “The Fediverse”, the “SmolWeb” or anything like that. They are driven by a basic interest in sharing files/data/whatever via the internet. There is no glowing, humanistic, vaguely vogue vernacular associated to it. “I’m going to send you a tarball of my grandparents favorite recipes in OPML format. If you don't know what any of that means and don’t want to learn, how could you ever fathom putting in the effort necessary to prepare their 7 cheese lasagna? Things take time, Allen!”
- pronlover723 4y agoIt a stupid "republicans believe in creationism and democrats don't" falsehood. 68% of democrats believe in creationism vs 72% of republicans. That's hardly a difference.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoWhats your source for these numbers? America has a lot of people who believe evolution happened but was guided by god, and very few (1 in 9) who belive it was just evolution with no god, but the ones that belive that there was no evolution lean fairly heavily Republican.
- lapcat 4y agoI can't find more recent polls at the moment, but polls from 2014 and 2008 show a 20% partisan gap in "no evolution" beliefs: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/01/03/republican-views-on-evolution-tracking-how-its-changed/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/01/03/republican-... https://news.gallup.com/poll/108226/republicans-democrats-differ-creationism.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/108226/republicans-democrats-di... And the ultra-religious Republicans tend to turn out heavily in their primaries to select candidates for office, which skews the politics even further.
- sys_64738 4y agoWell, don't. We don't need to make this into a drama. Does anybody really care what individuals do or the choices they make?
- kkoncevicius 4y agoTo me this also seems like the right attitude and the right comment. The author blames twitter for negativity and arguments, but spent quite some time on his post criticising the new Twitter ownership and then went on a rant about Elon Musk. How is that better. Is the idea here that people should express their criticisms on blogs rather than tweets? But blogs have to be shared on some kind of social media to be read by others too (like this on on HN). I would agree more with the message of "do what you like and don't go around telling others what they should be doing". Doesn't matter the platform. If everyone practiced this then most problems with social media would go away.
- sys_64738 4y agoI'm also curious who submitted this to HN? Was it the author trying to monetize their blog?
- lapcat 4y agoNo. I'm the article author, and I didn't submit it to HN.
- lapcat 4y ago> The author blames twitter for negativity and arguments, but spent quite some time on his post criticising the new Twitter ownership and then went on a rant about Elon Musk. How is that better. > Is the idea here that people should express their criticisms on blogs rather than tweets? But blogs have to be shared on some kind of social media to be read by others too (like this on on HN). My blog is mostly technical, focusing on software development. As far as I can recall, this is the only instance I've ever gotten "political" on the blog. It's an exception, not the rule. I was wary about doing it. And I purposely put that discussion in the addendum, because the main point of the article wasn't about Musk. I wrote the addendum because I knew that some people would be curious exactly why I left Twitter, and also because I did feel like ranting about Musk, which I generally didn't do on either Twitter or my blog until the very end. (Before he acquired Twitter, I had blocked his account and muted all mentions of him.)
- boh 4y agoClosed/private social media is the future of social media (if not already the present). Cultures rely on exclusivity. HN is what it is because most people don't use it and it's self-selecting. At the end of the day people don't want to hear just anyone's opinion.
- tartoran 4y agoI think Twitter will thrive (or just do ok) in the short term as there appears a new wave of conservative users will keep it afloat. But the larger timeline doesn’t look so good. Only time will tell.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pxoe 4y ago
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI don't get Twitter or similar platforms, but it sounds like Mastodon is at least attempting to fix the problem being described. Just some thoughtful tweaks to make it less addictive, less of a game, less of a competition. Not sure it will work, I'm not the audience anyway, but I feel like Mastodon is worth a try for this user.
- kyledrake 4y agoI also started using Twitter, more or less, during my visit to C4 (a very well put together indie mac dev conference in Chicago). That's also where I met al3x for the first time, back when Twitter was almost more famous in the States for being a working Ruby on Rails app. It was a surprisingly influential conference, I'm learning in retrospect. My thoughts drift back to that weekend from time to time, which has increased since I stopped using Twitter this week. If I could go back in time, I might go back to that conf and make a couple different decisions just to see how timeline divergent my life ended up. I still have the weirdly colorful tie I got there.
- ianbutler 4y agoThis whole ordeal made me realize that I'm less interested in following people and things they say and more interested in getting neat information and projects behind those people. I hardly read opinion pieces since to me they're not worth that much, even coming from a prolific person, I find the clock is only right a few times and those pieces will make their way to me. That's a reason I like HN. The link is the important bit, sometimes it links to a person who is writing things, other times it's just a nice github link. But it's always about the content. I deleted Twitter off my phone last night and may join Mastodon but honestly I've just realized that Twitter style social media is something I don't care for much.
- lijogdfljk 4y agoI've not been on social media in .. ~8 years or so, if we ignore link aggregators at least. Even with link aggs, i've been deleting my accounts semi regularly on both HN and Reddit, and making several accounts, in an effort to distance myself from caring about Karma/etc and add noise. Ironically, unrelated to this Twitter stuff.. i've been searching for a social network recently. Specifically a semi-niche (Blender) community, moreso than a social network. I was reasonably attracted to Twitter as a fair bit of the community that i'm interested is there.. but these days Twitter feels.. chaotic. I was hoping there would be a Blender instance on Mastodon but no such luck yet in my searching. Some random Discord communities also seem viable, though there's something about the Twitter/Mastodon interface i enjoy. edit: I suppose i could just pick a sane default on Mastodon and keep an eye out for other instances blender artists are on.
- ratsmack 4y ago>I've not been on social media in .. ~8 years Is Hacker News not social media?
- DeltaCoast 4y agoPeople seem to go back and forth, I think yes it is. I sometimes think when people say social media and implicitly exclude reddit/hacker news is that it's not less identity based and more topic based.
- lijogdfljk 4y agoYup. Also as i mentioned i purposefully delete my accounts and rotate them to ensure i don't keep identity either. Frankly the lack of identity to me is the core of what makes or breaks a "social" network. Having no permanence to the accounts kinda makes it feel more forum like. Where i can pretend there's no point system, it's just content, people discussing and helping, etc.
- UncleEntity 4y agoBlender users are still pretty active on the IRC if you want to chat with people real-time I believe. And the BlenderArtists forum for ‘social media’ without being the product. I can’t imagine if someone approached Ton with a proposal to host an official blender mastodon instance on foundation hardware he’d be opposed. The worst they can do is say no.
- rchaud 4y agoSocial media as we understand it is really algorithmic feeds with ads in between. People genuinely do not seem to be able to conceptualize a different model. The reaction to Mastodon's learning curve has been very disappointing. You would have thought that the people that most want to leave the site would welcome an alternative model that is specifically un-Twitter like. And yet the complaints are all "Hey this isn't like Twitter, I can scroll right to the bottom of the page. Where is the randomness?" It is that very randomness that keeps people addicted to scrolling, keeps them viewing more ads, and eventually, has them responding to the quoted tweets of people they don't like to 'dunk' on them, ignorant to the fact that dunking counts as engagement, and boosts the reach of those posts. Mastodon specifically avoids all those things, but most Twitter users can't see that forest for the trees.
- goldenchrome 4y agoAt the end of the day, people would like to be entertained with as little effort as possible. That’s how we got to the current system. Largely speaking, people are not sick of Twitter, they’re sick of the current ruler. If Mastodon can reduce the friction and be more engaging then it might have a chance. If it’s not possible to do that without becoming everything that’s wrong with Twitter then it may be true that we have the best system already. This is similar to how some people want a new economic system because they’re sick of capitalism but it turns out it’s very difficult to improve on it without causing a great deal more suffering.
- lapcat 4y ago> Social media as we understand it is really algorithmic feeds with ads in between. From the article: > Many people blame "the algorithm" for making Twitter unpleasant. I don't believe it's the algorithm, as I've always used the reverse chronological feed exclusively. I personally used a 3rd party client and an ad blocker in the browser, so I never saw the algorithm or the ads.
- jdaw0 4y ago>You would have thought that the people that most want to leave the site would welcome an alternative model that is specifically un-Twitter like. I don't think this part is right though. Most of the people looking for Twitter alternatives at this particular moment aren't looking because they're unhappy with Twitter the product. They just want Twitter Exactly But With No Elon -- that's why half the word count of this post about social media is a rant about how the author dislikes Elon's version of futurism. You're right about Twitter's addictive design, but that's what the people complaining want: to indulge their Twitter addiction without using Twitter.
- dawnerd 4y agoI’ll keep buying Tesla vehicles despite absolutely despising Elon. He is a fraud and people are starting to realize it. I used to respect him too. But he doesn’t make the cars or the rockets so I’m okay looking the other way there. I’ve given up on Twitter. It’s gotten much worse since he took over and I’m already feeling better without it.
- ratsmack 4y ago>He is a fraud Could you clarify and elaborate on that?
- SyzygistSix 4y ago>He is a fraud... But he doesn’t make the cars or the rockets so I’m okay looking the other way there. Funny how no one else was able to do either of those until his companies did. Other large auto companies are still struggling to produce EVs as cheaply and in quantity. Kind of makes the fraud comment ring hollow. As do the accounts from people who have worked with him.
- ratsmack 4y ago>Why did I leave Twitter? My biggest fear about the Twitter acquisition had quickly become an incontrovertible reality: the new right-wing ownership group of Twitter intended to exploit the service to promote political propaganda. The above is laughable. If you believe giving everyone an equal voice is a bad thing, then you need to reevaluate your position in society.
- iainctduncan 4y agoIf you think owners have an equal voice with users, then you need to reevaluate your understanding of society.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoHow was that not the case with the previous owners?
- ratsmack 4y agoI also believe the current owner is more neutral than the previous, and has stated as much in his belief of free speech.
- bluenomatterwho 4y agoWhy is he distracting from the obvious point that we should all tar and feather that fascist Musk, destroy Twitter and replace it with something which will only enforce our clearly infallible views?