3 ms·
The UN report declared that taking away all access to the Internet over claims of copyright infringement was too large of a punishment for the crime. And one of
by pyre 15y ago
The UN report declared that taking away all access to the Internet over claims of copyright infringement was too large of a punishment for the crime. And one of the U.N.'s human rights is a functional justice system (or something like that).
By the logic that says that UN is saying that the Internet is a human right, theft is a human right because I say that the death penalty for stealing $1 worth of stuff is too large of a punishment.
- greenyoda 15y agoPunishment for the crime? What crime? Under this system there is no actual determination that a crime has been committed. That can only be done via due process of the legal system, not by a copyright holder making an assertion to an ISP. Is it really a good idea to be able to punish somebody because two corporations agree that he should be punished? And the punishment could be severe -- if you're a self-employed software developer, depriving you of internet access could cost you your livelihood.
- pyre 15y ago"The punishment doesn't fit the crime" is a turn of phrase. If I see a parent kick a child because the child was annoying the parent and say, "the punishment doesn't fit the crime," is your first reaction, "BUT THAT CHILD WASN'T CONVICTED IN A COURT OF LAW! DON'T CALL IT A CRIME! RETRACT THAT STATEMENT IMMEDIATELY! PARSE ERROR!" Also, you seem to be mistaking that I agree with 3-strikes laws due to my comment. The point of my comment was that the parroting of "The UN thinks the Internet is a human right," is wrong. If the UN really thought that the Internet was a human right, then every country that didn't supply free Internet to its citizens would be guilty of 'human rights violations.'
- throwaway64 15y agothe RIAA is not my parent, nor a court of law, due process exists for a reason.
- pyre 15y agoYes, of course. Because in all of my comments, I was advocating the MPAA/RIAA position. </sarcasm>
- duggan 15y agoNo, by that logic, life is a human right, because I say the death penalty for stealing $1 worth of stuff is too large a punishment.