5 ms·
SCOTUS will definitely approve of this. After Scalia died, any shared concept of an individual right to privacy died with him. That's why we should be thankful
by pessimizer 4y ago
SCOTUS will definitely approve of this. After Scalia died, any shared concept of an individual right to privacy died with him. That's why we should be thankful that prior restraint on speech was banned in the Bill of Rights, so only enforcement of that restriction hinges on current nationalist fashion, rather than the entire concept as in the case of the "right to privacy."
Scalia's corruption, and his desire to deny the public the tools to prove it, was the thread keeping us all safe.
- pmoriarty 4y agoThose of us who value privacy and want to protect it have to find ways of convincingly demonstrating its value to others. Merely calling it a "right" is just too hand-wavy, and doesn't convince anyone who doesn't already agree with you.
- pessimizer 4y agoCalling privacy a right isn't an argument. Calling for privacy to be a right is what one makes an argument for. So I don't know who you're arguing with. edit: I mean, I deliberately put scare quotes around it.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoCalling privacy a right isn't an argument but it's a perfectly legitimate strategy for social legitimization. Repetition legitimizes, repetition legitimizes, repetition legitimizes and is a completely valid way of constructing a social reality in a way one wishes it to be. Besides, no one asked for a right and got it granted. These are socio-rhetorical problems, not logic problems.
- mdp2021 4y agoYou want a theorem. No problem. Privacy is a natural right. "I know what I am doing, and you don't." (It has to be interpreted as I did not write it in a literal form, but it will do at least for now.) Plus: one has the right not to be unnerved by peeking intruders. I have a viz for it, let me search for it and I will update the post. Edit: found: https://i.ibb.co/JCrzmbJ/clarkson-children-that-stare.jpg https://i.ibb.co/JCrzmbJ/clarkson-children-that-stare.jpg
- CyberDildonics 4y agoPrivacy is a natural right. People have claimed "natural law" to marginalize most of what are now protected classes of people. The rest of your comment is so incoherent I can't understand what you are trying to say.
- mdp2021 4y ago(Speech is generally "«incoherent»", best translated as "with missing linking pieces" - which is what the reader is tasked to do -, otherwise you would have to write something like Russel's Principia Mathematica to present a complete form. ...And people would go "TL;DR" on it. ... Edit: I could have been a bit more "complete", but body was so begging for rest I had to cut it short. Physiology.) I'll translate up to some point. I wrote that explaining the logic that shows that "privacy is a natural right" is not difficult: it is based at least on the principle that the individual is responsible on his self, and is endowed with a judgement to carry on that responsibility, and that the judgement of his peers is not qualifiable as worthy in such an amount to override that of the responsibility bearer, so, exceptions aside relevant to the impact on others, the peers will leave the individual "in peace" and in suspension of judgement. This produces (logically) one side of the inappropriateness of having peering eyes on you: the peers do not have the qualifications to intrude. In [that] short [form]: "I know what I am doing [much more than you can in general judge], and you don't". Very loose form, but can be used provisionally as a shortening. And another side is that shown in the picture, with that Jeremy Clarkson acting as the "annoying staring child": it's annoying to have peering eyes on you - it is more distracting than mosquitoes and one has the right to carry on one's business in peace. There may be even more sides.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoIf you're trying to make a point, just try to condense it to something simple and direct. The only thing I can extract from this is "I don't like someone looking at me so privacy is a 'natural' right" which isn't a great argument at all. Maybe if you said something about consent or an imbalance of information that would make more sense. Saying something is a 'natural' right is circular logic.
- modriano 4y agoScalia wrote a few pro privacy decisions, but Scalia is in no way the "defender of the 4th amendment", hagiographic obituaries notwithstanding. In his Whren v US decision [0], Scalia gave police the power to stop and search any driver as long as they assert a traffic violation as the pretext for the stop. In Florida v Riley [1], he agreed that it's not unreasonable to police to use a helicopter to fly into position to see into property not visible from any adjacent building or from adjacent land, assert they can see marijuana, and use that as a pretext for a search warrant. In Lawrence v Texas [2], which focused on a case where police entered Lawrence's apartment (in response to a reported weapons disturbance) and found Lawrence engaged in consensual sexual act with another man, and Lawrence was arrested on charges of violating a Texas statute against "sodomy". The court ruled that individuals have the right to engage in sexual acts with other consenting adults when in the privacy of their homes. Scalia wrote a rancid screed of a dissent. Sometimes Scalia stood up for the 4th amendment, but he didn't value it more than his prejudices and ideological mission. And that makes it hard for me to say he thought privacy was an individual right. [0] https://www.oyez.org/cases/1995/95-5841 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1995/95-5841 [1] https://www.oyez.org/cases/1988/87-764 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1988/87-764 [2] https://www.oyez.org/cases/2002/02-102 https://www.oyez.org/cases/2002/02-102
- jibe 4y agoWhren v US decision [0], Scalia gave police the power to stop and search any driver as long as they assert a traffic violation as the pretext for the stop. 1: it was a unanimous decision 2: they can’t just assert a traffic violation, there has to be an actual violation of the law.
- tstrimple 4y ago> 2: they can’t just assert a traffic violation, there has to be an actual violation of the law. How's that working out in practice?
- Petersipoi 4y agoSeems to me like GP is using the word "assert" intentionally to make it seem like Scalia supports giving cops the power to make up charges then act accordingly. No, Scalia didn't support police flying a helicopter up to your window and pretending they see marijuana then raiding your house. And yeah GP is going to argue that "assert" doesn't mean claiming something that isn't true. But the intention is obvious to the point that it's really difficult to see good faith here.