5 ms·
Class-action lawsuit filed against US state agency over mobile 'spyware'
- LinuxBender 4y agoHere is the lawsuit filing [1][PDF] I am curious if this would have occurred on rooted and de-googled phones using alternate operating systems. [1] - https://nclalegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Complaint_Wright-with-Exhibit.pdf https://nclalegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Complaint_W...
- oaththrowaway 4y agoI would assume this was forced through the Play Store, so my best guess would be that a de-googled phone would be safe
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y agodo you consider an unrooted device with at least 1 goog account synced - but with goog play disabled - a safe de-googled phone?
- oaththrowaway 4y agoIn this case, it might not be effected. But in general I wouldn't consider it "De-Googled" unless it didn't have any Google services on it.
- slim 4y agoyou can't disable google play services
- btdmaster 4y agoYou can disable it, it's just a bit more difficult: https://android.stackexchange.com/a/219376 https://android.stackexchange.com/a/219376 (use the builtin package manager pm over ADB debug permissions, pm uninstall --user 0 package)
- account-5 4y agoWould this have happened on normal Google phones but without a Google account set up on it and with play services disabled? If Google were able to I stall this without user interaction then android phones are compromised bemy default!
- hammock 4y ago>I am curious if this would have occurred on rooted and de-googled phones using alternate operating systems All 12 of them?
- ed25519FUUU 4y agoIs the headline some weird example of “republicans pounce”? Is the story about the Koch brothers lawsuit or about the fact that the government installed spyware on citizen’s phones without their knowledge or consent?
- namdnay 4y agoIt’s kind of both? The fact that the previous litigation of this group was to allow landlords to evict tenants during lockdown is more than interesting. And the fact that the state thought it would be OK to force install the app is interesting too
- factsarelolz 4y agoIt’s not kinda both. It’s the equivalent of scary quotes. By framing this as Koch funded, anti Koch people already made their decision and grabbed their pitch forks without reading anything past the headline.
- HideousKojima 4y ago>was to allow landlords to evict tenants during lockdown Framing is everything, y'know? You could just as easily call it a lawsuit to stop a blatant and unconstitutional power grab by the CDC.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoIndeed, ends vs the means. People who think one or the other is more important will talk right past each other, never see eye to eye.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 4y agoIf Charles Koch doesn't want state governments to secretly install surveillance apps on my cellphone, I don't even want any constitutional rights. That'll show him.
- anonuser123456 4y agoKoch is to the left what Soros is to the right; a scary oligarch bent on world domination for the other team. In reality, the Koch brothers have an eclectic mixed bag of ideas, some of which are batshit crazy, some of which are good, most of which are meh.
- InTheArena 4y agoThe Koch’s aspire to the level of financial destruction for personal gain that Soros pulled off.
- JaimeThompson 4y agoGiven how much they have fought against clean energy it isn't a given they are behind Soros in that metric.
- anonuser123456 4y agoI think this falls under their ‘batshit crazy’ category. Libertarianism in general seems to filter/select for people that insist mankind can’t possibly alter the climate and that it’s just a huge leftist plot. It’s the primary try reason I stopped identifying with the concept. Disappointing because there are a lot of good ideas / principles in the philosophy, but the degree of pedantic extremism exhibited by the community is weird.
- guelo 4y ago
- jsmith99 4y agoWhatever you think of the Kochs, their views are generally more libertarian than Republican, eg pro marijuana, anti Trump, David Koch was (inconsistently) pro abortion. So this policy is pretty typical for him.
- cercatrova 4y ago[flagged]
- namdnay 4y agoI thought the article was quite clear - it’s obvious the Koch brothers are doing this because of the covid angle but it’s still pretty shocking that the state thought it would be OK to force install an app
- oaththrowaway 4y agoSo you're okay with Google installing government tracking apps on your phone because the Koch brothers are against it? Weird flex
- factsarelolz 4y agoSounds like it, that’s why the headline has Koch in it, by framing it this way the anti-Koch crowd grabs their pitch forks without reading past the headline.
- pessimizer 4y agoAlso, you probably wouldn't be making excuses for it if it weren't a covid app, so covid provided an excellent opportunity to set a precedent.
- orangecat 4y agoThis "spyware" (which even the article title quotes as so) is just a CoViD contact tracing app. It's an app that collects personal information and that was installed without the knowledge or consent of users. How is that not spyware?
- guelo 4y agoIt does not collect private information
- anonymousiam 4y ago
- dudeinjapan 4y agoIt reminds me of that time that Batman enabled echolocation on everyone's smartphones so he could catch the Joker.
- javajosh 4y agoYes, but this was a Big Ethical Deal in the movie, and a power so great that it was deleted after one use. It's a good cultural touch point about this issue; I wish it was better used.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoUgh, I hate it when articles leave out the most crucial information, namely: 1. How did Mass install these apps in the first place if it was "clandestine" as the lawsuit alleges? 2. Google is not in the business, generally, of just giving access to private data to government agencies just because they asked. Was there some sort of legal requirement or court order involved here? In other words, I'm taking this whole filing with a giant cup of salt until more details are available, never mind that legal filings are by definition highly biased to the side being represented.
- factsarelolz 4y ago> 1. How did Mass install these apps in the first place if it was "clandestine" as the lawsuit alleges? Discovery will probably shed some light on this. How would the plaintiff know the exact method used? > never mind that legal filings are by definition highly biased to the side being represented. Tell me you’ve never been a plaintiff in a lawsuit without telling me you’ve never been a plaintiff in a lawsuit. Why would the fillings _not_ be biased to the side being represented? Why would the side being represented be biased to the defense? That makes no sense at all.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> How would the plaintiff know the exact method used? This is not exactly difficult. They are alleging that this was installed on a million phones, I'm sure doing some straightforward technical forensics would make it clearly apparent what was going on. > Why would the fillings _not_ be biased to the side being represented? You've misunderstood my point, though I don't understand yours. Of course the filings are biased, that is exactly what I'm saying. I've just seen numerous cases (myself included) where people get out their pitchforks when they've only read one side's version of events, well before a complete picture emerges of what actually happened.
- factsarelolz 4y ago> They are alleging that this was installed on a million phones, This allegation is based up the number reported by Google that is available to the public. > I'm sure doing some straightforward technical forensics would make it clearly apparent what was going on. Why? Why spend the money to hire a forensics analyst or a team, when through discovery you can learn that information straight from the source. In my opinion it would be worth it to wait to see if the lawsuit actually progresses and is not immediately slapped down by a judge. If immediately slapped down then you just wasted money, by waiting to ensure it’s approved to move forward you can save some money. I will admit I have not read completely the actual filing, which probably will shed more light on it than an article.
- jrm4 4y agoHa. "Enemy of my enemy" I suppose, on this one. (It is interesting the extent to which people don't tend to think in these terms. Yeah, the Koch's are terrible. But they're 100% correct on this one)
- foostepsndpics 4y agoIt is embarrassing that this case had to be brought by a firm otherwise known for suing to let landlords evict tenants during a pandemic moratorium. Why was this not brought by an organization like the EFF or ACLU? I remember writing to my Senators at the time because of how unprecedented and troubling this action was. Here's an article from The Verge with more details from the time this was rolled out: https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/21/22543486/massnotify-covid-exposure-android-google-apple https://www.theverge.com/2021/6/21/22543486/massnotify-covid...
- ispo 4y agoFreedom to not being observed while they burn the Climate.
- guelo 4y agoThe contact tracing protocol for that app was developed in cooperation with Apple with encryption and privacy as top concern. Calling it spyware and a 4th amendment search doesn't make sense, the state can't centrally track people's location using this app
- kramerger 4y agoI believe the protocol was specifically designed to prohibit identifying individuals, but then someone found a flaw in it. Don't remember what happened then, I guess Google+apple updated the protocol or killed the app.
- NickRandom 4y agoI think you might have a misunderstanding of what is under discussion - to quote from the filed complaint "To increase adoption, starting on June 15, 2021, DPH worked with Google to secretly install the Contact Tracing App onto over one million Android mobile devices located in Massachusetts without the device owners’ knowledge or permission" which is very different from installing an app!
- scarface74 4y agoI in no shape form or fashion could be considered leaning right. But why the emphasis on Koch funding instead of being more concerned with giving more surveillance power to the state?
- jfengel 4y agoBecause the Kochs have a habit of using their wealth to suppress their political enemies. It would not be beyond them to file a lawsuit of no merit to harass Google. Not saying that's what happened here. I don't know. But it's a relevant bit of context.
- taolegal 4y ago> using their wealth to suppress their political enemies You could say that about practically every Democrat. Usually they brag about it “we have the most donations under X amount.”
- mindslight 4y agoThe state did not gain more surveillance power. The state asked a surveillance company for help, and the company saw a common goal and exercised the surveillance power that it's been building for the past two decades. Power inevitably coalesces, and the only way to opt out of our brave new surveillance society is to be running software that represents your own interests.
- scarface74 4y agoSo if the state asks random people to break into your house to find out information about you should you move to another country?
- mindslight 4y agoI don't understand the analogy you're drawing? If the state asks an arbitrary person to break into your house, and that person breaks into your house, they should be prosecuted. Only if they are not prosecuted is there an argument to be made they're acting with de facto state authority. What Google did here was not illegal. It should be, but it's not.
- binkHN 4y agoFrom the article, because the title is purposefully vague: > The Massachusetts Department of Public Health conspired with Google to secretly install a COVID-19 tracing app onto more than 1 million Android users' devices without their knowledge and without obtaining warrants...
- kramerger 4y agoWait, wasn't the covid19 contact tracing app (the "spyware" in question) installed as a part of the android (and also iOS) system and was disabled by default? Or did they turn it on by default in US?
- nyolfen 4y agoit sounds like they turned it on by default in massachusetts
- Confiks 4y ago> secretly install a COVID-19 tracing app The Register's article is a complete shitshow in emulating the confusing language from the lawsuit. Luckily the complaint itself [1] refers to an Ars Technica article from 2021 which finally explains a bit more [2]. [1] https://nclalegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Complaint_Wright-with-Exhibit.pdf https://nclalegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Complaint_W... [2] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/06/even-creepier-covid-tracking-google-silently-pushed-app-to-users-phones/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/06/even-creepier-covid-...
- colpabar 4y agoFunny how the post without “Koch-funded” in the headline had such a different discussion when it was posted here last year. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27558500 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27558500 edit: I think it’s also worth pointing out that they are not suing for money (only lawyers fees and $1 nominal fee), they are just asking the government to stop working with google to install covid tracking apps that users cannot uninstall.
- throwaway5752 4y agoWhy is that surprising. What Massachusetts and Google did is bad. This awful Koch funded group filing a class action lawsuit is also bad. Both are bad. edit: you ought to read the actual lawsuit - https://nclalegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Complaint_Wright-with-Exhibit.pdf https://nclalegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Complaint_W... before you make mistaken claims like "they are just asking the government to stop working with google to install covid tracking apps that users cannot uninstall". They have other goals.
- colpabar 4y agoWhy is filing the lawsuit bad? Isn’t that exactly what should happen here? Don’t you ever roll your eyes when you see a headline with “Soros-funded group does X” in it?
- 4y ago
- Zamicol 4y agoWhat are the anticipated damages?
- citilife 4y agoI don't know why we have to start the article with "kock-funded" -- just to make it political? Here's a less political website: https://www.bostonherald.com/2022/11/18/massachusetts-dph-google-secretly-installed-covid-spyware-onto-1m-phones-lawsuit-says/ https://www.bostonherald.com/2022/11/18/massachusetts-dph-go... Ars Technica (from 2021!): https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/06/even-creepier-covid-tracking-google-silently-pushed-app-to-users-phones/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/06/even-creepier-covid-...
- ajross 4y agoThe NCLA is absolutely a partisan organization. They're funded by republicans, they're run by republicans, they hire republicans (Jeffrey Clark couldn't get a job anywhere post-insurrection, so they picked him up) they file suits only against democratic states or the Biden-administered federal government. Frankly I think tagging them as a partisan group adds important context, though I agree that should be exposed in the article rather just left as code in the headline.
- citilife 4y ago98% of political donations from employees at Netflix go to democrat candidates. Should we start calling them a partisan organization? https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/02/most-liberal-tech-companies-ranked-by-employee-donations.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/02/most-liberal-tech-companies-...
- joemazerino 4y agoI don't trust Google so I don't allow Google on my device. Full stop.
- Ptchd 4y agoWho do you trust?
- stormcode 4y agoI remember finding this BS on my phone and being pretty annoyed about it.