5 ms·
Trust in Musk or go federated with Nextcloud Social
- politelemon 4y agoSo not fully familiar with Mastodon, are they basically saying, they will add a new NextCloud feature, which lets you turn your NextCloud server into just another Mastodon server. Which means you can join the Mastodon uh... 'universe' and your tweets would be under `youruser@yournextcloud.example.com` ? I assume some kind of public presence would be required though, since a NextCloud server can run on an internal only space.
- msk-lywenn 4y ago« Fediverse »
- madacol 4y agoThe protocol that allows to federate is called "Activity Pub". Mastodon is just an implementation of it that looks like twitter, similar like how peertube is an implementation that competes with youtube. And this NextCloud Social is another implementation of Activity Pub
- yogthos 4y agoThink of it exactly the same way as email. You have different servers with users on them, and they can all talk to each other using a common protocol called ActivityPub. The really interesting part of all this is that different types of platforms can focus on different kinds of content while allowing users to talk across platforms. For example, Pixelfed is an Instagram clone, PeerTube aims to be a distributed YouTube, Lemmy is a federated Reddit clone, and so on. Thanks to using a common protocol it's possible for users across these platforms to communicate with each other. It's possible to follow content, reshare it, leave comments, etc. So, instead of having a bunch of walled gardens you have an actual ecosystem of different platforms. And I think that open source and non profit hosting is fundamental for this model to work. Commercial social media platforms have an incentive to prevent users from sharing content to other platforms because they're locked into a zero sum competition for users with them. On the other hand, Fediverse is a positive sum game where more users on the network means more content for everybody. There is no incentive to keep users locked in on your particular platform. This is a huge advantage from user perspective because you don't have to juggle a bunch of accounts on different social media sites just to follow content there.
- verylook 4y ago> Thanks to using a common protocol it's possible for users across these platforms to communicate with each other. It's possible to follow content, reshare it, leave comments, etc. So, instead of having a bunch of walled gardens you have an actual ecosystem of different platforms. I can understand why you believe this, because it's part of the ActivityPub marketing, but it simply isn't true. ActivityPub is extremely loosely defined, and the protocol it builds on, ActivityStreams, places no limitations on the type of data that is transferred. What this means is that in practice you can only federate with other instances of the same software as your homeserver without degradation. It's very hit or miss. The best cross implementation communication comes between Mastodon and Pleroma, but Mastodon is more popular and implements a number of other protocols in addition to ActivityPub, so to keep up Pleroma actually matches their API, not the protocol. The other implementations that you mentioned mostly federate among themselves. Sadly this undoes many of the benefits you've listed. You do very much need a Lemmy server account, a Pixelfed server account, a Mastodon account, etc, if you want everything. And you have to pick a homeserver each time, and it isn't easy.
- yogthos 4y ago>I can understand why you believe this, because it's part of the ActivityPub marketing, but it simply isn't true. ActivityPub is extremely loosely defined, and the protocol it builds on, ActivityStreams, places no limitations on the type of data that is transferred. I'm literally using ActivityPug this way right now. I follow Pixelfed and PeerTube accounts as well as Lemmy feeds using my Mastodon account right now. The developers of all these platforms are actively ensuring that they are interoperable. I really have no idea what you're basing your claims on here. You can use your Mastodon account right now to follow my Pixelfed @yogthos@pixelfed.social and subscribe to my feed. You can even leave comments and I'll see them on my Pixelfed.
- jeroenhd 4y agoActivityPub can in theory only federate with a whitelist of servers or remain entirely closed off. You don't need to make your account public, but I don't see the advantage of using ActivityPub if you're going to stay private. Your activity would be posted under @username@nextcloudserver.com, yes. I believe Nextcloud has had ActivityPub features for collaboration for a while now, I suppose building in a social network interface is just the next step.
- recuter 4y ago
- _jal 4y ago> He has a monopoly on what exactly? You can argue about about the exact contours of different markets if you like, but they're quite obviously pointing to FB and Twitter being controlled by two tech billionaires. What "hatefulness", exactly? They're stating a fact. Many people take issue with individuals with mercurial opinions having that much control over everyone else's communication. > Social media is for losers. Thanks for sharing all the opinions. On a message board.
- Bilal_io 4y ago> Social media is for losers. It is for users*. It has a lot of issues, but it has its use cases. Before you judge the post's tone, watch yours, and stop generalizing all social media users as losers.
- recuter 4y agoI won't, thanks.
- themgt 4y agoFrank Karlitschek also tweeted just two weeks ago: "Elon Musk just axed key Twitter teams. Sure. Who needs human rights, accessibility, AI ethics and curation. " Not sure I fully understand the synthesis of "communication is too important to be controlled" and "firing the teams that controlled communication is bad". https://twitter.com/fkarlitschek/status/1588865171900203008 https://twitter.com/fkarlitschek/status/1588865171900203008
- Tao3300 4y agoToo important to be controlled by few. The guidance of teams with expertise in human rights, accessibility, AI ethics and curation (though I'm iffy on that one) is better than the whim of a rich egomaniac.
- 4y ago
- adriand 4y agoI honestly wonder if these various social networks / Twitter clones are solutions in search of a problem. Do most people really care to comunícate with each other in this manner any more? What’s the point? It seems to me (anecdotal, so I’m interested in your views) that the use-case for reasoned argument has moved to podcasts and substack and the use-case for group comms has moved to discord. Meanwhile, feed-style networks, which were always junk food disguised as nutrition, have been displaced by TikTok, which is more like digital crack.
- yogthos 4y agoIf you don't understand the internet was meant to be decentralized then what are you even doing here?
- TobyTheDog123 4y agoI agree in the decentralization mantra (though cryptocurrencies have not been a good public representative of the concept thus far), but this is the exact opposite of what you want to do to attract people to your cause. "What are you doing here, believing in centralization, on a centralized news site?"
- ericd 4y agoI don’t think the parent’s tone was good for discussion, but HN is literally all links off to other sites with some meta-discussion, it’s not “centralized”.
- VLM 4y agoHow big will his market be? I theorize it will be the same population whom moved to Canada back when Trump was elected. Maybe smaller because of network effects.
- tweezy 4y agoI think you’re right that the market for this is probably pretty small. But more so because these federated solutions won’t replicate the addictiveness and vitality of Twitter. I think the big thing that’s missing when comparing people leaving Twitter to people who said they’d move to Canada is switching costs. Like it is a heavy lift to move countries, much less so to stop using one platform and start using another.
- Tao3300 4y agoI deactivated and deleted Twitter last week and added it to my filter list in ublock. Most of the accounts I was following already have a Mastodon presence, though YMMV depending on your personal interests.
- rodolphoarruda 4y ago> Communication is too important and sensitive to be controlled by a few. Wasn't it controlled by a few even before Musk decided to buy it? Where I live, the supreme court controls all the content and user accounts from all major social networks, Twitter included. It takes literally 5 minutes to a single judge to suspend or cancel any user account and its contents.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoIn the old days there was IRC, which: - anyone could spin up a server - servers can link together, scalable - it's pretty much the absolute minimum you need on top of TCP to implement a chat, so extremely lightweight and a server can literally handle 10s of thousands of users - anyone joins any server they want - decentralized - works over dial up - mature ecosystem - decades of time to work out kinks and issues - 7000 engineers? I can set up a server in about an hour. Has drawbacks but just saying, the future is in the past.
- memish 4y agoYes, but it was the anointed few in control of Twitter before. Key difference.
- TobyTheDog123 4y agoIt seems Mastodon and NextCloud don't seem to understand is that the only people still using Twitter are people who want to be outraged, and people who want to be outraged but claim they only follow people tailored to their interests ("I only follow tech people!")
- kevinh 4y agoThere are plenty of people who just use twitter for art or science or what have you. They, by their very nature, won't be what you see the most.
- Tao3300 4y agoThere's a lot of outrage in those niches too.
- jeroenhd 4y agoOn the contrary, the people I've recently seen leave Twitter were all waiting for the network effect to lessen. Switching communication stacks suck, especially if not everyone you want to follow is on your new stack. I've set up my own BirdsiteLive instance that only my own Mastodon server can access, but it's slowly seeing less and less activity as people switch over to Mastodon or something I can't bridge. Plenty of people are going to keep Twitter as their cesspool, but it'll be a while before everyone who wants to switch has switched. Musk's behaviour and the following downward trend for Twitter is still recent news, it's only been a few weeks.
- deburo 4y agoThere's still plenty of left-wing tech people on Twitter, althought they recently created their Mastodon account. I think they're waiting for the final nail in the coffin (a big outage ?), which may or may not come. And I'm on Twitter to follow them. Outrage is mainly not part of my feed unless those same tech people start ranting on Musk or what have you.
- jszymborski 4y agoWe've been told for ages, implicitly by FAANG algos and explicitly by people who misread research, that we prefer to be outraged. Very Online (TM) people with large Twitter followings like Marcus Hutchins are coming to realise that it made Twitter a compulsion, and given an alternative are willing to ditch the Skinner button [0]. Compulsion and addiction is different from desire or pleasure. When we're offered meaningful alternatives, people often find more peace and happiness when they adopt them. [0] https://infosec.exchange/@malwaretech/109368403091846997 https://infosec.exchange/@malwaretech/109368403091846997
- malikNF 4y agoSince this is HN, if you have your own domain you should give the fediverse a try. Try to set up an instance of mastodon, you don't need that much hardware if you are only setting it up for yourself. The official documentation is straightforward and easy to follow along. The fun part is once you set it up you can interact with other people on other nodes, the more people you discover the more things you suddenly start to discover, I was trying this out for the past few days and honestly it feels like discovering the web for the first time. So many interesting people so many interesting topics.
- robobro 4y agoPleroma is easier to set up and demands fewer resources. Looks a lot more like Twitter and has the Mastodon frontend built in, too!
- lflflofkdnd 4y agoBe careful and don't use your real name on a Pleroma instance if you work in an industry sensitive to the culture war https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/issues/9708 https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/issues/9708
- jeroenhd 4y agoAs someone out of the loop about Pleroma, why do some people associate Pleroma servers with nazis?
- Kye 4y agoThey're just dredging up old beef for some reason. Very, very early on Pleroma was popular with people who found the general anti-fascist stance of early Mastodon instances offensive and chose Pleroma, so it kind of became The Fascist Platform for a time until a wider range of people chose it for its lighter resource use. That post is from 2019. The poster later worked on Pleroma for a while, so it's safe to say things changed. Three years is a long time.
- Existenceblinks 4y agoI wished facebook death in 2014. It didn't happen, all my friends are still there. I don't want to socially isolate myself more, it's peaceful but at a significant cost. I become pessimistic about bad things will disappear.
- nbzso 4y agoSince this i s HN, I can be this boomer and say: We survived with blogs, forums and IRC. Without a problem. Dear, friends, your "convenience" and "dopamine" habits created monopolies which normalized surveillance to the point of no return, and literally are giving away data and your future to the algorithm overlords. The results of this immature behavior are the pillar on which WEF and other billionaires are building "the fourth industrial revolution" where you will have literally zero value in the production chain, you will eat whatever they tell you and play it "safe" in the name of your "positive" social score. So I say it again: Find the way to decentralize, create new habits, throw away your phones and fancy toys and start working for humanity and against the dark patterns of today's pharaohs. Outside the tech bubble, the real world is waiting patiently and asking for your help. Transhumanism is not the future of humankind.
- techdragon 4y agoAs an existing NextCloud user, with plenty of personal data in my self hosted instance, this does absolutely NOTHING to inform me why the FLYING FUCK i want to risk exposing my NextCloud to the internet with these new social media related features, no discussion of how important security is, no emphasis on how I can trust NextCloud with being a public web accessible server the public can access and simultaneously trust my most personal of self hosted data to the same server. I want things like this to help people control their own data, it’s important for these projects to exist lest the future be ruled by or entirely dependent on big corporations… but when your existing business is building the tool(s) I trust with the data I trust no one else with… do a fucking better job not making me dismiss shit like this as “crap I’d have to run a second server to be able to use” Because my life is busy enough I barely have the time to manage my one self hosted NextCloud at home… if you make this one micron harder I’m just going to say “Fuck it“ and use a different isolated tool for running my own fediverse server. And I say this as someone building my own personal social site aggregator based tool. Do. Not. Make. It. Hard. To. Trust. You.
- poisonborz 4y agoI agree this feature isn't really wished by the userbase, and they could spend development resources better, but like everything in Nextcloud this will be just an app that you can disable with a click, so no reason to rage about it.
- kornhole 4y agoNobody is telling you to make your server public. Configure it the way you want. Naturally you won't be able to use features like this if you don't make it publicly accessible.
- Krisjohn 4y agoWhen our customers' marketing departments want in to the "Fediverse" with company-branded usernames, this is what I'm going to recommend.