3 ms·
>why would affirmative action be viewed as so important that schools abandon participation in the premier ranking system in order to pursue it through a backdoo
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
>why would affirmative action be viewed as so important that schools abandon participation in the premier ranking system in order to pursue it through a backdoor? I am genuinely curious why affirmative action is considered so sacred that elite schools suddenly reject the ranking system they have spent decades trying to climb. Rankings are really a pretty critical part of US education.
One hypothesis is that they feel the reputational damage from getting dragged through the mud for lack of diversity would be more damaging to the school than loss of the US news rank.
Another is that they truly feel that furthering racial equality is a higher priority for the school than reputation.
- slowmovintarget 4y agoThe way to end discrimination based on race is to stop discriminating based on race.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI said furthering racial equality, not ending discrimination.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoTo clarify, you can have a completely race- blind Merit system but still have inequality of outcome due to differences in the applicant pool. The whole point of affirmative actions is to make a race conscious selection system to achieve equality of outcome, not a quality of selection
- slowmovintarget 4y agoYou must work to resolve the prerequisites to the outcomes. Academic success comes from exposing children to a consistent viewpoint (from role-models, usually parents) that values knowledge and education, and insists that those children spend their time on such pursuits. Attempting to correct for those missing prerequisites at the point of college admissions presupposes that getting in is the only thing needed for success. It isn't.
- puffoflogic 4y agoThis is racist.
- onetimeusename 4y agoThat might be so but like I was saying it could lead to having more unqualified lawyers if they can't get past the bar or hired. Then the bar exam will be the target of needing more diversity and then we have more unqualified licensed lawyers and then maybe they need to win a certain percentage of trials in order for there to be equality of outcome for them. to hell with their clients. I am being sort of sarcastic, sort of. This could also be a sign we are producing too many lawyers. I think elite overproduction is a real thing and it is damaging to society. There is even a study that shows GDP declines proportionally to the population of lawyers. I don't know if it's a good idea to have a lot of underemployed, racially aggrieved, lawyers. So if they basically don't care what the outcome is for society (and their students) so long as they are not accused of racism that really makes me view them differently.