3 ms·
They have a billion dollars in assets and are making $600 million/annum if I'm reading their financial statement correctly. That is well into the 'corrupt until
by roenxi 4y ago
They have a billion dollars in assets and are making $600 million/annum if I'm reading their financial statement correctly. That is well into the 'corrupt until proven otherwise' range of wealth. Firefox's development needs orders of magnitude less than that, the browser's market share collapsed and it is notable that Eich [0] of all people went on to develop a browser based on Chrome after thinking about what would be the best base for a company. And Brave is at least trying things - it probably won't work but there is a vision there of reshaping the internet and toppling Google's advertising model. That could be Mozilla. It isn't.
There is a lot of room here to criticise this project. It seems to be off the rails, and it is likely to go further off the rails.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brendan_Eich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brendan_Eich
- chomp 4y ago$600 million in revenue (across all subsidiaries), $200 million on software development, $100 million on management, are you upset at Mozilla for running a healthy balance sheet? I'm confused about your complaint. Should Mozilla be packing itself to the gills with software developers for Firefox? It seems like they are trying to broaden their holdings and assets to build wealth for the company and Foundation so that they can become less reliant on Google. Eich chose Chromium because Webkit is dominant and was in a better position in 2015. I'm not seeing how this is can be made to an indictment of Mozilla corruption.
- roenxi 4y ago> ...are you upset at Mozilla for running a healthy balance sheet... Charitable foundations aren't supposed to be corporations. If we've got an entity like Mozilla running a healthy balance sheet it should be a public corporation that we can all be shareholders in. So yes, I am upset by that too although that wasn't the point I was trying to make. They've set up a situation where they are going to be corrupted. A billion dollars in assets attracts charlatans and they won't have sufficient defences to stop the money being siphoned off into pet projects and general shenanigans. There will probably turn out to be fraud involved sooner or later. > ... Eich chose Chromium because Webkit is dominant and was in a better position in 2015... As far as I care, their purpose is to make a good web browser. This is absolutely an indictment of Mozilla.
- yoasif_ 4y ago>Charitable foundations aren't supposed to be corporations. If we've got an entity like Mozilla running a healthy balance sheet it should be a public corporation that we can all be shareholders in. So yes, I am upset by that too although that wasn't the point I was trying to make. >They've set up a situation where they are going to be corrupted. A billion dollars in assets attracts charlatans and they won't have sufficient defences to stop the money being siphoned off into pet projects and general shenanigans. There will probably turn out to be fraud involved sooner or later. It is very confusing what you want - you want Mozilla to be publicly traded so that you can share in its success (and open itself up to being corrupted), yet have an issue with it not being publicly traded? Do you just want to be upset?
- roenxi 4y agoI don't want anything in particular, I walked away from Firefox a while ago so the failures of the Mozilla corporation don't affect me. Most former Firefox users are in the same boat if the stats are accurate. They could wind the whole foundation up and almost nobody would need to notice. But I don't think you can dispute the basic point here - there is a huge honeypot here to attract people with bad intentions, and they have failed to use it to promote any useful aims given the magnitude of the amount involved. > Do you just want to be upset? You've got me, I was bluffing. I'm not really upset. I just think it is bad form, philosophically. The foundation is failing at its goals, they shouldn't be trying to make a profit. If they want to make money they should start a normal company and have shareholders.
- yoasif_ 4y ago> But I don't think you can dispute the basic point here - there is a huge honeypot here to attract people with bad intentions, and they have failed to use it to promote any useful aims given the magnitude of the amount involved. They may attract people with good intentions as well - or do you have to be starving to be pure of heart? PS: I don't see how they haven't promoted "any useful aims" - Firefox continues to exist, Rust exists, Let's Encrypt exists, and they are healthy. Those seem like promotions of useful aims. >The foundation is failing at its goals, they shouldn't be trying to make a profit. Profit is just what is left over after what needs to be paid for is spent. Would you rather they have no money left at the end of every day? How do you imagine that that works?
- rascul 4y ago> Eich chose Chromium because Webkit is dominant and was in a better position in 2015. Actually they chose Gecko in 2015. Chromium came later on. https://brave.com/the-road-to-brave-one-dot-zero/ https://brave.com/the-road-to-brave-one-dot-zero/
- trap_goes_hot 4y ago>That is well into the 'corrupt until proven otherwise' range of wealth. What is your best argument for why others should accept such a standard? > Firefox's development needs orders of magnitude less than that, Any link to data justifying such a claim?
- lucideer 4y agoCompare it to operating finances of other open source projects, run by foundations, within a similar complexity (possibly lower, but within order of magnitude): Blender: ~1 million (2020) Libreoffice: ~1.3 million (2021) Apache: ~900k (2017) Debian: ~340k (2019) One can argue that browsers are exceptionally complex (even linux distros like Gentoo that build everything - including the kernel - make exceptions for firefox due to its complexity) but even considering that, the figures are staggering by comparison. To be absolutely clear on this we have a situation where: - most Mozilla advocates & supporters are so because of Firefox - most of Mozilla's income comes from Firefox - most of Mozilla's income does not go towards Firefox development - Mozilla continue to provide financial supporters with no means to donate directly to the Firefox project - Mozilla's income is 2 orders of magnitude higher than any comparable charitable foundation Add to that the decline in Firefox's userbase & the stewardship of the project becomes really difficult to justify/defend
- trap_goes_hot 4y agoComing back to the point being discussed - Where exactly does wastage occur inside Firefox's development team? Specifics and data are very persuasive!
- lucideer 4y agoFirstly noone has mentioned anything about wastage within the Firefox project - this thread is about Mozilla as a whole, not just Firefox. Not sure what point you're "coming back to" specifically. Secondly, I don't work for Mozilla, so unless you know of some source more granular than their very high-level annual reports, the specific & data you're talking about would need to be sourced internally. Mozilla don't publish any breakdowns on a per-project basis: for all I know the Firefox team may well be operating at peak financial efficiency. If we're to speculate, the closest thing Mozilla publish to a per-project breakdown is under activities in their expense report where they have a "software development" category costing ~250 million (not Firefox software development, all general software development). That's still very high compared to other similar open source projects, but it's just over a third of the gp's quoted income figure. So you've got 2/3rds of that figure to look at before you even get near the idea of Firefox dev wastage.