3 ms·
So the most likely universe has "no appreciable curvature and just a touch of dark energy. Weirder types of cosmos are vanishingly rare." OK. This doesn't seem
by Animats 4y ago
So the most likely universe has "no appreciable curvature and just a touch of dark energy. Weirder types of cosmos are vanishingly rare." OK.
This doesn't seem to be an answer to why the fundamental constants are set for an interesting universe with stars and atoms that do chemistry. Not ones full of dispersed hydrogen, or one big mass, or ones with uninteresting chemistry where nothing happens. See "fine-tuned universe".[1] Still, it's a step forward.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fine-tuned_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fine-tuned_universe
- zwkrt 4y agoThe fine-tuned universe is not a scientific concept though. The only hypothesis at a high level is that the constants or initial conditions of our only observable universe could have been different. However we have no data or reason to believe this is the case. We have no other universes to observe. We have no statistics about the distribution of possible constants. There are no experiments we could run. Even the headline of this article smells bad, right? Typical as opposed to what? When I see an albino squirrel, I know that it is atypical. I have seen thousands of squirrels, and other mammals, and I have good reason to believe that an all-white squirrel with red eyes is out of the ordinary. I can calculate how many of them there are out of the population and get a ratio to operationalize my definition of "atypical". I can learn more about genetics and biology and melanin and understand an underlying cause for the condition and make predictions about albino-ness in other animals that is falsifiable through further investigation. In this case though we just have an untestable mathematical model for 'possible universes' (whatever that means) that puts our universe near the top of some abstract bell curve. I understand that smart people made it and that it is very technical and fancy, but I also know that it is made outside of the scientific process becuase I know that we have never observed another universe, we don't have an understanding of how universes are made, we don't know what the possible bounds are for the constants of nature (because they are...constant...). So I consider this to be like a very technical art project. The argument that god created the universe is also a fine tuning argument, but no one seems to give that one much credence.
- technothrasher 4y agoWhen I asked a Jehovah's Witness who was proposing the fine tuning argument to me, "So what would a non-designed universe look like?" He just stared for a second and then said, "Are you like, a scientist or something?"
- kulahan 4y agoI'd probably get thrown off by such a basic question too. "Look, these cards are only standing because they were so carefully placed!" "So what would it look like if they weren't?"
- pixl97 4y agoThat's easy "Entropy"
- nxmnxm99 4y agoThat’s not as clever an answer as you seem to think
- technothrasher 4y agoIt wasn't a clever answer. It was a very basic question. The point was that the guy who was throwing out the fine tuning argument hadn't even given it an second's though himself.
- a9h74j 4y agoNotably, a combination of: 1) significant (improbable) information content, and 2) appearance of fulfilling a functional specification ... is taken by some philosophers as supporting a hypothesis of design. FWIW, Return of the God Hypothesis by Stephen Meyer is a surprisingly well-argued book, exploring such support.
- technothrasher 4y agoOn point 1, how would you know it is improbable? We're back to the initial issue of having nothing else to compare it to. Perhaps it's not improbable but in fact inevitable? Can't tell with only one example. On point 2, it only looks to fulfill a functional specification if you beg the question. Otherwise, we're simply generating a description of what is. Stephen Meyer is a founder of the Discovery Institute, a political group who lobby conservative issues and state as part of their mission to promote "a rigorously God-centered view of creation". That doesn't mean Meyer's work on intelligent design is incorrect, per se. But it does strongly suggest that he is starting with a conclusion and then working backward, which is the antithesis of proper scientific research. There are also plenty of eviscerating rebuttals to Meyer if his bias doesn't dissuade.
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoBrownian motion and the Casimir effect in the early universe should be enough to jumpstart accretion.
- GuB-42 4y agoYou have the anthropic principle: you can only observe a universe that produces observers. More specifically, if a universe existed that is full of dispersed hydrogen, we wouldn't be there to observe it. The universe must be fine tuned in some way, not just the constants but the very laws of physics. But this is an undecidable and therefore unscientific problem. The reason scientists want our universe to be "typical" is that the more we can generalize our findings, the more we can make predictions. For example if we can find an equation that gives us the cosmological constant exactly, we can get rid of it as a free parameter. Not only it is philosophically satisfying, but we may also use that equation to find something else, like a new particle, maybe even a practical application.
- Barrin92 4y agoNever really understood why that requires an explanation. A universe full of life is 'interesting' from the perspective of life but that's a subjective sentiment. If the universe was only full of rocks it'd be 'fine-tuned' for rocks. If you were one big mass you'd probably think this universe is tuned awfully wrong. 'Carbon chauvinism' of the wiki page alludes to this but I think you could even generalize it to 'life chauvinism'. Or alternatively you could ask, why isn't it fine-tuned even harder, with life in every corner? After all it's astonishingly empty in most places.
- Buttons840 4y agoIn other words: The puddle of water looked at its oddly shaped surroundings. Every odd curve and unnamed shape that comprised the edge of the puddle was perfectly fit by the surrounding terrain. The puddle marveled at this, such a thing was surely not chance, what phenomenon is behind this mystery? Why does the terrain surround me, a mere puddle, so perfectly?