7 ms·
Baby shortfall is so bad that the labor shortage will last for years
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoAutomation will make up much of the gap.
- black_13 4y ago
- bediger4000 4y agoThis is good. All the changes after the Black Death lowered Europe's population were the end of the medieval world and the beginning of the Enlightenment. Lot's of exciting changes in store!
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoThe plague killed people of all ages, it didn't just reduce the relative proportion of young people.
- blahblah1234567 4y ago[flagged]
- advisedwang 4y agoMore info if anyone wants to understand this in depth: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/what-is-great-replacement-theory-and-how-does-it-fuel-racist-violence https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/what-is-great-replacem...
- mikem170 4y agoDeclining birth rates are happening everywhere in the world, not just in the christian liberal west for the reasons you gave. The primary causes seem to be urbanization and women's access to education and birth control. It makes sense to have more kids living on a farm, not so much in a city. This will drive lots of changes, both cultural and economic. Is it a good thing or a bad thing? Probably depends on who you ask. Are lot of people scared of these changes? Definitely.
- rjprins 4y agoSo many problems are created because of the huge number of people on earth. A shrinking population is only bad for people with a vested interest in growth; investors and employers, but good for everybody else, including future generations, the climate, and nature.
- kmlx 4y ago> A shrinking population is only bad for people with a vested interest in growth; investors and employers, but good for everybody else a shrinking population is a disaster overall. productivity goes down, more elderly, social services strained, smaller taxable cohorts. the needs will still be there, the money and the people to solve them won’t.
- Qem 4y ago*more unassisted elderly.
- jmoak3 4y agoYeah exactly. What the original commentor is hoping for is a reset to a previous point in time. Which would be nice in many of ways they've outlined, but isn't possible. Imagine if a large corrupted and bloated city could simply not be large, corrupted, or bloated. In real life we've seen when such a city loses people or revenue, the trauma of the pullback is devastating and the bloat and corruption do not simply go away. Detroit, 1970s NYC after the suburban flight, and the people clinging to shrinking regions of Japan come to mind. As our countries have a population pullback wealth will shrink, corners will be cut, innovation will slow, and likely more coal than ever will be burned.
- webdood90 4y agoLet it burn. I'm not bringing kids into this mess. Climate change, war, pollution. An endless list of problems due to humanity's greed. There is no changing the trajectory at this point. Human's are in denial about our future but we've already laid our beds.
- blahblah1234567 4y ago[flagged]
- rayiner 4y agoI hate the argument we can make up for labor shortfalls with immigrants. Chuck Schumer says “we have a population that’s not reproducing on its own.” https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/restoring-america/community-family/schumer-right-falling-birthrates-are-bad-wrong-immigration-is-solution https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/restoring-america/communi... He says we can fix that with immigrants. But if there is something causing people to not want to “reproduce,” it seems like that needs to be fixed. Otherwise, you’re just shifting the burden of dealing with whatever that is onto immigrants trying to raise their families here. Like, I’m glad I’m raising my kids here instead of in Bangladesh. But it’s a lonely and isolating here in comparison to the way it is back home.
- ido 4y agoIt's not just "here" though, birth-rates are dropping worldwide with economic development.
- tjs8rj 4y agoThis is often touted as a good thing, but the more I think of it it just seems like it isn’t “having such a good life in a developed economy” that makes people have fewer kids. It seems more and more clear that increasingly competitive economic conditions are the reason people in the developed world have fewer kids.
- rayiner 4y agoThe US had sustainable birth rates throughout the 1990s to 2008. Not exactly the Stone Age. But they began a consistent downward trend since then.
- theandrewbailey 4y agoMeanwhile, there's lots of unemployed people in small towns, homeless are filling our cities, and most jobs that can be had pay little. Adding a never ending stream of immigrants to that mix feels like pouring gas on a fire.
- aliqot 4y agoThis reminds me of when you get 2 or 3 little mosquito fish in your tank, soon you have 50 in a few weeks and you're wondering what you're going to do. Eventually the brood sizes get smaller and the tank finds its own equilibrium.
- poxwole 4y agoWonderful, workers will have more power
- anonymouskimmer 4y ago"the number of people of working age (15 to 65) is set to decline in the coming years." 1) In richer countries with better working conditions "working age" can be, and for many people has already been, extended into the 70s and 80s. "Working age" and 'retirement' are new concepts, not a fixed part of being human. 2) While so-called 'unemployment' is low, labor force participation rate has continued to drop: https://www.bls.gov/charts/employment-situation/civilian-labor-force-participation-rate.htm https://www.bls.gov/charts/employment-situation/civilian-lab... Broken out by age: https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/civilian-labor-force-participation-rate.htm https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/civilian-labor-force-particip... Both of these things mean that there is still a lot of room to accommodate a decreasing "working age" population.
- yamtaddle 4y agoHaving a kid in the US is retirement-suicide at best, if you're not rich. As in, it'll all but completely kill any hope of a decent retirement. And if you get unlucky (as far as the kid's health) it's like winning a reverse-lottery ticket that condemns you to lifelong poverty. Except the odds of that happening are way better than hitting a lotto jackpot. I get that birth rates are also low in Europe so a good social safety net can't be all of the solution, but I know an awful lot of people in the US who'd like to have kids, or who'd like to have more of them, but it's such a bonkers-bad financial decision that they can't bring themselves to do it. That is, I'm pretty sure there's a lot of desire in the US to have more kids, but you're punished so badly for it that people avoid it anyway. I think fixing our healthcare system and improving our public pension scheme to something better than "if you have to rely on it, you're probably fucked" would help a ton.
- labrador 4y agoI'm retired and I'd be looking for options like Canada's voluntary euthanasia program if I didn't have my adult children. It's surprising to me how meaningless money has become now that I am old and lacking the energy to enjoy it. I'm grateful I still have something to live for.
- yamtaddle 4y agoRight, the in-hindsight value may make it worth it, but when you're 25 or 30 or 35 and start to run the numbers on the terrible shadow having a kid will cast on your future savings and then realize opportunity cost makes it even worse... it can be hard to see that less-quantifiable perspective clearly. (for the record, I have some kids, but damn can I ever understand why people choose not to, even when they do want them)
- labrador 4y ago> start to run the numbers The problem is at a young age you don't know the important things to include in your formulas or how to value them. What's it going to cost to pay someone to make decisions for you when you start having trouble making them for yourself? It's going to cost a lot to set that up with someone trustworthy ahead of time. If you've done a halfway decent job of raising your kids they will do that for free and you don't even have to set it up. They will be watching you and making sure you are ok. They will do it because they love you, not because you are paying them.
- notadev 4y agoStop overthinking it. Settle down and have kids. I know no one else will give you this advice, because it’s generally bad advice, but seriously…just start trying to make the baby and let nature do it’s thing. If you wait for the perfect time, it may never arrive. Or when it does, you’ll regret having waited so long. Nothing in my life has been as worthwhile as raising my children. It’s not always easy, you have to work on resolving conflicts between siblings or you and your kids (teens amirite?) and you’ll have to think of more than just yourself in pretty much any decision you make, and everything has extra steps. It sounds like a pain, but I wish I could do it 4 more times! My mother had me at 16 and thankfully I survived. I’m in a better position but not by any means well off or able to stop working, but I am happy with my lot. I would definitely say make sure you are a functional adult and in a relationship with someone you are going to be forced to deal with for at least 18. Aside from that, let the adventure begin!
- notch656a 4y agoIt being "worth it" is not really a given though. I'm also a parent and although I fully execute my duty to the best of my abilities in the interest of the child I never found it to be particularly advantageous position to be in. You're basically on-call constantly for an often rote and laborious task and there is no guarantee you're going to enjoy it. If you do it well nobody (except if you're very luck the child) gives a fuck and if you fail or have remarkably bad luck you end up in prison. I doubt I'm the only one that just tries to enjoy it to the extent to keep my sanity, for the same reason I would try to keep smiling while in prison. My personal advice is if someone has an enjoyable life now and don't absolutely have to have children, stop and think hard about the fact you may turn a lifestyle you enjoy into a responsibility you can't back out of.
- Ancalagon 4y agoComing from someone who wants kids: IMO this is poor advice. Having kids is a monumental commitment, for mothers especially but fathers too. Your whole life will change and I know of too many people that regret having kids to be able to say this kind of advice is good.
- rapjr9 4y agoSo if the labor shortage is going to last for years, does that mean so will inflation?