5 ms·
You're obviously right that processed foods are far worse, but the study the article cites[0] doesn't say what the article says it does, not at all. The article
by lolinder 4y ago
You're obviously right that processed foods are far worse, but the study the article cites[0] doesn't say what the article says it does, not at all. The article deliberately misconstrues the phrase "weak evidence" to mean that the authors are attacking the past studies, when in fact they're just saying more research needs to be done. Here's the opening paragraph of the Discussion section:
> We evaluated the relationship between unprocessed red meat consumption and six selected disease outcomes following implementation of a meta-analytic approach. We found that unprocessed red meat intake had weak evidence of an association with increased risk of colorectal cancer, breast cancer, IHD and type 2 diabetes and no evidence of an association with ischemic stroke and hemorrhagic stroke. In other words, given all the data available on red meat intake and risk of a subsequent outcome, we estimate that consuming unprocessed red meat across an average range of exposure levels increases the risk of subsequent colorectal cancer, breast cancer, IHD and type 2 diabetes at least slightly compared to eating no red meat (by at least 6%, 3%, 1% and 1%, respectively).
[0] Full text here: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01968-z#Sec2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01968-z#Sec2
- notSupplied 4y agoSadly, news articles always grossly exaggerate research results. "We found weak evidence of ..." becomes "New study ABSOLUTELY DESTROYS the myth that..."
- themitigating 4y ago"The new study is climbing the ropes, oh my God what is he going to do, ohh he just jumped on the old studies, oh the humanity "
- cogman10 4y ago> You're obviously right that processed foods are far worse I see this claim semi frequently online. So I'll just ask. What is meant by "processed"? What does it mean to be "worse" (Worse than meat? Regular foods?) What is meant by "whole foods"? And finally, what's the evidence for these assertions? Is black tea a processed food? How about coffee grounds? When does something cross the rubric of processed vs unprocessed? To me, it's not obvious that "processed is bad" particularly because I don't know what "processed" means. As a side, how do fortified foods fit in with processed foods? Iodine in salt, for example, has been a huge public health success. Goiters have practically been eliminated as a result.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThe claim about processed foods has usually become very much accepted because of the failure to correlate any other aspect of food convincingly with the obesity epidemic. That is, there are populations much less obese than others eating all variants of macronutrient distributions (high fat, high carbohydrate, high meat, etc - you can find a low obesity population eating like that somewhere in the world). Processed foods are more or less the only remaining food-based explanation.
- cogman10 4y agoThis seems a bit like a non-sequitur to my comment. Even if I accept that "Processed foods are more or less the only remaining food-based explanation." My questions really boil down to "what are processed foods" and "What's the evidence they are bad"?
- CadmiumYellow 4y agoIt's quite hard to study this stuff but here's an example: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7946062/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7946062/ The study includes an appendix with photos of all the meals - it's very interesting! The evidence suggests that various qualities of ultra-processed foods drive overconsumption. There is also speculation that the calories in ultra-processed foods are more bioavailable than those in less processed foods because ultra-processed foods are easier to digest due to their low fiber content, though I don't have any evidence for than on hand (will update if I find it).
- cogman10 4y agoI agree, that was an interesting read. Definitely send more studies if you find them. This one seems to suggest the main problem with ultraprocessed foods is they are easier to over eat (they taste better? Are less filling?) but it doesn't really show that they are necessarily bad. Seems to jive with how food works for me. I've been counting calories as of late and it's definitely easy to down a bag of doritos or drink a bottle of soda
- renewiltord 4y agoWeak evidence of a risk increase from 4.3% to 4.6% of colorectal cancer? Okay, if that's where we end on red meat's cancer risk, I think I'll take it.
- pessimizer 4y ago> by at least 6%, 3%, 1% and 1% But this is very, very weak evidence. edit: of course I have to assume something about the structure of the data to say it's very weak evidence. It may be very strong evidence of a very weak effect. ----- edit 2: Also, how is this, the last "takeaway," listed in bold, large font directly beneath the headline, some sort of exaggeration or mischaracterization? > They only found weak evidence that unprocessed red meat consumption is linked to colorectal cancer, breast cancer, type 2 diabetes, and ischemic heart disease, and no link at all between eating red meat and stroke.
- noptd 4y ago>just saying more research needs to be done Right, because the results of the previous studies amount to evidence that is too weak to conclude that red meat is inherently unhealthy to consume. I'm not sure how your comment contradicts this.
- lolinder 4y ago"Weak evidence" is a term of art, not a pejorative. The original article frames this study as an attack on prior studies and vindication of red meat. My point is that this is extremely dishonest, and the authors of the study do not intend to convey that at all. They instead say that the evidence is there, but it's not yet strong enough for them to recommend any policy actions. > The available evidence suggests that eating no unprocessed red meat may minimize the risk of disease incidence and mortality compared to consuming any, but there is insufficient evidence to make stronger or more conclusive recommendations. More rigorous, well-powered research is needed to better understand and quantify the relationship between unprocessed red meat intake and chronic disease.