3 ms·
You can't make it hard. People have been trying that for ages and all that happened was that people got really good at cracking the protections. It only takes
by Natsu 15y ago
You can't make it hard. People have been trying that for ages and all that happened was that people got really good at cracking the protections. It only takes one "smart cow" to open the barn door for the rest. The situation is not symmetric. The attackers have an overwhelming advantage: the defense must be perfect while the attackers of a protection scheme need just one flaw. That's so massively unfair that we have never yet seen it succeed for very long. And even then, most of the things that weren't cracked were ignored because there were easier ways to get the content. Which is, of course, an observation you were quite correct to point out.
You can't take away the enabling, either, any more than you can turn back the hands of time. Information is information. If I can transmit a message to you, then I can do so whether or not it's copyrighted. I can just encrypt it to block out any middlemen who would otherwise censor it. I can route it through third parties. I can use steganography to hide it. It's not fair, but it is. Like much of life, it's evolve or die.
Even if we ramp the controls and enforcement to police state levels, one look at China's Great Firewall shows that it leaks like a sieve. What you say has been tried already. For my entire life. It has yet to succeed. I don't believe it ever will.