4 ms·
I'm sorry, but this is a silly article. Yes, key changes went away in US pop music at some point a few decades ago. But the idea that this has to do either wi
by crazygringo 4y ago
I'm sorry, but this is a silly article.
Yes, key changes went away in US pop music at some point a few decades ago.
But the idea that this has to do either with hip-hop or with digital music production is frankly ludicrous, and the author presents zero causal evidence here except that all three things happened very roughly around the same time. And the proposed explanations make zero sense.
The real answer is simply that the shifting the key up in a dramatic energy-raising fashion just went out of style, like a thousand other things in music. As the author themself notes, they're "heavy-handed" and "trite". I could add corny, old-fashioned, and overly earnest to that list.
Everything in music gets overdone and then fades away to make room for the next new thing. There's no more reason needed for this than people just got tired of the old thing -- which they always will.
Claiming it's because of hip-hop or digital music is just strange.
- adamc 4y agoI don't think it's just a fashion thing. There is a real outcome of this: the music is simpler and less interesting. Modulation isn't the only missing ingredient, though. Quantization and click tracks and pitch-correction and sampling have all combined to reduce the variation in songs. Part of it is driven by the need to make production cheaper (since music is less profitable now), so it's hard to say if it will come back.
- hammock 4y agoPitch correction is harder to do live, if there are key changes, since you can set your auto tuner to a specific key Also, key changes present some increased difficulty (not insurmountable of course) in live performance on certain instruments like guitars. And the fact is (at least frontman) music artists are getting less talented at their instruments on average
- ghostpepper 4y agoHaving never performed live I'm just guessing, but theoretically changing keys on autotune should be as simple as pressing a single button at the correct point in the song, no? Conceivably it could even be programmed in with everything else
- hammock 4y agoYes it is programmed for, e.g. Taylor Swift shows. For us regular guys there's a separate autotune box for each voice and it's sometimes not as simple as pressing one button.
- crazygringo 4y ago> the music is simpler and less interesting If you listen to top 40 only, then maybe. (Although a lot of top-40 music back in the 70's was pretty bad too. We only continue to listen to the cream of the crop from back then, not the average radio station song.) But if you're listening to top 40 music these days, well that's your fault. Outside of it, there's never been more complexity and variety and interest and genre-mixing in the history of music than today. You're not stuck with the radio, you've got Spotify and the stuff you can find outside of the mainstream is amazing.
- blue039 4y agoI don't think it's that strange. Perhaps calling out those two in particular might seem a little vindictive but I'd say modern music in general. Modern music is watered down and simple. The drums are all 4x4, the chords are all the same, the progressions are predictable, etc. I'm not talking about just a genre using a particular set of chords, I am talking about literally being able to predict the next note using only 10 seconds of audio. Moreover, there is so much tooling around making absolutely talentless hacks sound good (auto-tune, quantization, very clever filtering) it's hard to actually know if someone is even real sometimes. More than ever I've also noticed modern music videos are simply advertisements for luxury brands. I just think the new generation lacks the sophistication to enjoy good music. Every generation since the invention of arguably the highest most supreme form of musical arrangement, orchestral arrangement, has resulted in slowly stripping away any sort of intellectual endeavor listening music had held. There's a reason classic rock is called classic rock and stuff made in the 90s onward doesn't qualify. It was probably the last period of time where music actually required talent rather than a ghost writer and an advertising deal. This isn't just my age speaking. I suspect in 50 years people will still remember Zeppelin, but no one will remember Jay-Z.
- msla 4y ago> There's a reason classic rock is called classic rock and stuff made in the 90s onward doesn't qualify. Of course rock made in the 1990s is classic rock now. That's how it works: Music made when the target demographic was in its teens and young adulthood is classic, and the music from the era when the currently dying generation was young gets aged out. When was the last time you heard Dion and the Belmonts on terrestrial radio? How about Frankie Lymon and the Teenagers? That's music. That's how all this works. Soon enough, Jay-Z will be in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. I mean, if Jelly Roll Morton (look him up, kiddo) can make it, they obviously abandoned the "Rock and Roll" part of their name long ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Rock_and_Roll_Hall_of_Fame_inductees https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Rock_and_Roll_Hall_of_...
- msla 4y agoI must correct myself: Jelly Roll Morton is in the "Early Influences" section of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Jay-Z, on the other hand, is in the main category.
- DontchaKnowit 4y agoAlso, key changes are actually pretty common in hip hop. Its a really really common technique to shift everything down a half step at some point in the song or to do a tape slowdown effect which pitches everything down. Not technically a "key change" but effectively the same thing.
- Kreutzer 4y agoYes, those 'lifting' key changes in MJ's songs may seem gratuitous, but key changes were used more subtlety by, for instance, Beatles to enrich the music with expressiveness even at the expense of musical common sense. And if anything, pop music today is just too uniform.
- jdontillman 4y agoI don't think you can separate music, or any art form for that matter, from the artist's craft, skill, expressiveness, resources, and materials. --- Digital isn't inherently bad, but... If the ENTIRETY of your music production is done on a DAW (Digital Audio Workstation) app, with its available tools and plugins, that's gonna have an effect. And I think that's what we're seeing. If today's music producers used the DAW only for recording, and stayed away for composing, arranging, and becoming proficient at playing instruments, things would be much better.
- crazygringo 4y agoSure using a DAW has an effect, mainly in providing more tools, but the idea that one of its effects is no more key changes makes... just utterly no sense. DAW's handle key changes just fine, they don't do a single thing to make them more difficult or lead you to forget about them. It makes as much sense as saying the popularity of young-adult novels is due to authors using word processors instead of writing by hand. The two have nothing to do with each other.
- jdontillman 4y ago"More tools" is not necessarily a good thing. Music, as any art form, thrives on limitations. And without complaint. "The Blues" is a very limited form, yet it has provided about a century of wonderful creative music. If I'm writing a string quartet, I don't complain that a particular note can't be sung by a gospel choir instead of a cello. Just as a painter doesn't complain about the canvas being 2 dimensional. Of course DAW's can handle key changes. The issue is that working full time in a DAW environment seems to have a tendency to displace a number of important musical sensibilities.
- crazygringo 4y ago> Music, as any art form, thrives on limitations. Music, as any art form, thrives on new possibilities.
- 4y ago