3 ms·
> Just use wireguard. It really isn't that hard. In many situations it's not just hard, it's outright impossible. For example, how would you connect two Raspb
by lxgr 4y ago
> Just use wireguard. It really isn't that hard.
In many situations it's not just hard, it's outright impossible.
For example, how would you connect two Raspberry Pis between two CG-NATted internet connections using Wireguard, without resorting to setting up a publicly reachable VPN server?
If you have a public and at least semi-stable IPv4 address and control your firewall/NAT, great. But unfortunately less and less people do, these days.
- candiddevmike 4y agoUse IPv6?
- lxgr 4y agoNot an option, as long as I regularly need to access my devices from IPv4-only networks. Have you tried using IPv6 on a hotel wi-fi, in-flight, or a corporate guest network?
- antx 4y agoTailscale actually has a great write-up on the subject [0] TLDR; Ideally, IPv6. Otherwise, NAT traversal techniques such as STUN, or hole-punching. [0]: https://tailscale.com/blog/how-nat-traversal-works/ https://tailscale.com/blog/how-nat-traversal-works/
- lxgr 4y ago> Ideally, IPv6. Yes, if you have it everywhere you want to host services and everywhere you want to access these services, that's great. Realistically, I think it's going to be decades until an IPv6-only service is feasible. > Otherwise, NAT traversal techniques such as STUN, or hole-punching. Neither of which Wireguard supports out of the box. To be clear, it absolutely shouldn't – it's a different concern, and the appeal of Wireguard is specifically that it isn't trying to do everything and the kitchen sink. So, is there an easy-to-use NAT traversal orchestration service for Wireguard out there that isn't Tailscale?