3 ms·
> Also observe that music without melody can be found everywhere, from rap to Steve Reich Steve Reich would dispute this, with gusto. You can only possibly mak
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
> Also observe that music without melody can be found everywhere, from rap to Steve Reich
Steve Reich would dispute this, with gusto. You can only possibly make the claim that he ever composed non-melodic sound in his earliest years (e.g. "Come Out"), but even then he was fascinated by the implicit melodic signatures of otherwise non-melodic music (realized later in a piece like Different Trains, where he explicitly has instruments play the melody of spoken words).
- omnicognate 4y agoI didn't say he only made non-melodic music. I don't see on what basis he or anyone would describe Clapping Music (which I recently saw performed at a school concert, hence it being on my mind), for example, as melodic.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoFair enough, though Clapping Music is AFAIR the exception that proves the rule.