7 ms·
Can a universal basic income help address homelessness?
- pavlov 4y agoGiving housing to the homeless is a good way to address homelessness. Finland has had substantial success with the Housing First model: https://ysaatio.fi/en/housing-first-finland https://ysaatio.fi/en/housing-first-finland
- easytiger 4y agoI love when people use microscopic countries with very particular demographics as examples.
- feet 4y agoI love when people point to demographics as a primary reason for differences between countries
- chiefalchemist 4y agoWhile I see the gist of your point (and agree), the tone is counter-productive. Next time try: Small sample. Small country. Far different social and governmental norms. It might not translate here. But it's not going to hurt to try either. Our options, sadly, seem to be limited.
- gus_massa 4y agoFinland has a population of 5.5 millions, it's not a microscopic country. If it were a USA state, it would be #23, between Minnesota and South Carolina.
- onion2k 4y agoFinland has a population of 5.5m people. It's the 115th largest by population.
- themitigating 4y agoWhat aspect of the demographics makes it a bad example to use?
- suggestion 4y agoThe fact that's it's a tiny, monocultured, de facto ethnostate with near universal shared values, ethics, and history.
- alexb_ 4y agoHow do you think it being a "de facto ethnostate" changes things? Please be specific.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoDifferent people, values, principles, ethics, concerns; all of which echo in life choices. Finland is going to have a fraction of the gangs, drug problem, and corruption as the United States by virtue of its size, geography, and choices that people who live there will make. You can't even compare Finland with LA or NYC, forget the whole United States. It is pointless to do so. If you want to examine a specific example, ask yourself how many Chicago-style street gangs exist in Finland.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- themitigating 4y agoThere is less crime in finland. Why? You said "Different people, values, principles, ethics, concerns; all of which echo in life choices" Isn't crime mostly connected to economic situations? Doesn't Finland have more social services than the US. Doesn't UBI help people who might otherwise turn to crime
- suggestion 4y ago
- throwaway13337 4y agoI agree that things can be different with different cultures but it's important to say why specifically this is the reason for this issue. I don't believe it is. We can give a counter example of Salt Lake City, Utah which this npr report claims to have reduced homelessness substantially with the same model. I admit that they do have a different philosophy but maybe the west coast philosophies on homelessness aren't really working out. Utah is culturally different but maybe not so different that they can't learn from them. https://www.npr.org/2015/12/10/459100751/utah-reduced-chronic-homelessness-by-91-percent-heres-how https://www.npr.org/2015/12/10/459100751/utah-reduced-chroni...
- Ekaros 4y agoThen break up these larger countries to smaller ones? Sounds like obvious solution. If larger countries are such massive failures. Should they exist? As clearly being smaller works better.
- hgfdhgfdhd 4y agoJapan is massive. You don't need to break up larger countries to solve the homeless problem.
- easytiger 4y agoSize is not the only facet
- mritchie712 4y agoThe % of the population that's homeless would be more relevant then the size of the country (esp since Finland is over 1M people).
- hourago 4y ago> ...very particular demographics as examples. All the west has similar demographics (age, gender, ...) . So, what do you mean by this?
- Asmod4n 4y agoGermany does it too, but only in a few cities.
- phpisthebest 4y agoHousing First works for the economically homeless. Which is only a fraction (and the most temporary) demographic of the homelessness in the US. Housing First does not work for the mentally ill, drug addicted, or other causes of homelessness
- pavlov 4y agoFinland has world-leading rates of alcoholism and suicide. The homeless in Finland are mostly not economically displaced.
- phpisthebest 4y ago>>>alcoholism and suicide Neither one of this is what most people think of when it is stated "drug addicted and mentally ill" alcoholism and suicide are strongly correlated with depression, a mental illness for sure but we as a society has largely separated depression off on to a separate category as it is wide (and over) diagnosed condition Similarly alcoholism while a drug is often referred to as alcoholism not drug addiction So in the context of Homelessness in the US mental illness would be referencing things like BiPolar Disorder,schefrania, and other more pronounced and outwardly presenting disorders. Drug Addiction would be Heroin, Crack, etc. All of which present anti-social and often violent manifestations far different than depression
- hourago 4y ago> Housing First does not work for the mentally ill, drug addicted, or other causes of homelessness It works. It solves their homelessness then there are other measures for other problems. And not all drug addicted or mentally ill people are homeless.
- RobertRoberts 4y agoVulnerable women and children are likely to avoid housing where mentally ill or high men would be because they _can_ (not saying all) be violent, aggressive and simply scary. (screaming is a common thing I've witnessed) It simply does not work as universal idea. People need to feel safe in their homes.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoWhy are we comparing a homogeneous country of 5MM people to a non-homogeneous country of 360MM?
- hourago 4y agoDivide the 360MM country in subdivisions of 5MM and problem fixed. Why more people makes this solution stop working? And what do you mean by non-homogeneous? It is not like all Finnish people is the same, they are not clones.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoAnd if my Grandmother wanted to be a car, we'd bolt wheels to her ankles. 92% of the population of Finland are ethnically homogeneous. That manifests as shared values, goals, and choices. You won't have that in the United States by breaking her up into 72 countries. Frankly, such a suggestion is foolish on its face.
- hgfdhgfdhd 4y agoJapan has 125MM. Their homeless rates are among the lowest in the world. They don't give homeless free housing.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoAnother homogenous country (98%)
- hgfdhgfdhd 4y agoJapan doesn't give housing to the homeless and they don't have a homeless problem.
- pmoriarty 4y agoJapan has a massive suicide problem, though... also lots of hikikomori who probably would be homeless or dead if not for the support of their families.
- hgjjghjghjhgg 4y agoJapan has a lower suicide rate than the USA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_r...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- balderdash 4y agoIt feels as if we need to subdivide homelessness by root cause (in my mind there are three, hard times, mental health, and substance abuse), universal basic income is not going to address substance abuse and mental health in my mind… but could be a boon to someone living out of their car who’s hit upon some hard times…
- likecarter 4y agoI agree - the problem is varied, and the solution needs to be nuanced.
- nmoadev 4y agoThe article says that targeted responses are still also required and compliment UBI.With UBI, someone receiving addiction treatment could also actually stabilize their living situation as well as their mental health.
- black_13 4y ago
- savanaly 4y agoIt seems clear to me that there are folks that don't have mental health problems but rather very different preferences. Some folks you just can't tell not to keep moving around, and they also dislike working, at least in the types of work available, and would rather beg and scavenge. I'm not sure that scenario falls under any of the three categories, and not sure how to help it either. I think the line is also quite blurry between folks like this and those on hard times and with mental health problems, but there are folks on the other side who we shouldn't forget about or force into a system they don't want to be in.
- themitigating 4y agoThis is the most eloquent summary of "bums are lazy". I propose it's highly unlikely that a person who is living on streets is doing so simply because they are lazy. Imagine freezing in the winter or sweating in the summer. How about worrying where you'll find food, staying safe from unstable people or maybe even well off people who attack/kill the homeless. Your claim is that this is a choice out of a laziness and not a mental disorder and/or an inability to get a job due to reasons outside of their control. What's also interesting is that if you claim it's their choice then not helping doesn't make you look bad.
- throwboi123 4y agoEveryone should learn basic economy
- onion2k 4y agoMost studies suggest UBI would reduce the amount of money spent on other types of welfare and therefore could actually lower taxes.
- phpisthebest 4y agoUBI should replace all other money spent on welfare it should be an either or... not an also add We either have UBI, or we have social welfare. Pick 1
- Ekaros 4y agoProbably not all, but vast majority things. Your average, averagely healthy non-disabled person shouldn't need or receive or need more than UBI. There are always some that need extra support, but they are absolute minority.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoBut, for example, in the US something like 70%+ of the total Federal budget is already spent on programs for the poor (Medicaid, EITC, SNAP, school lunches), the elderly/retired/disabled (Social Security, Medicare, government pensions) and debt service. Unless UBI proposes to take funding away from those who are already poor or already retired then where exactly is the money coming from?
- jonhohle 4y agoIf you replace all social welfare programs, you get around $3T/year, or $500/month for everyone (universal). That $500 now needs to cover all medical expenses, housing, and food for the subset of people who used to exclusively receive those benefits. That includes completely eliminating social security, which currently averages $2.5K/month. Meanwhile, the vast majority of people receiving income (the universal part), would have a portion of their income previously provided by wages replaced with money that used to be used for social services for those that either needed them (based on the current definition of need) or had “paid in” with the expectation of income at old age. Who is benefiting from this?
- lbriner 4y agoIt would seem obvious that it obviously will help somewhat. However, depending on the variables, it is always a question of how much it will help and at what cost. Small-scale targetted projects have been shown to work probably because of the care involved, the targetted group of people and perhaps a society where people want to not be a burden. However, if you have a smaller homelss population with massive mental-health problems, lack of money for high quality oversight and predatory people, you could equally end up with more drugs deaths but less people on the street. In the UK, there are a significant number of people labelled as homeless who have accomodation and sometimes benefits but lacking the difficult support teams required to help the vulnerable or distressed to stay away from people who will happily sell them alcohol or drugs.
- jkepler 4y agoDoes anyone have a non-paywalled link to the journal article, rather than just a news story about it?
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoThere are underlying reasons why the homeless individual is living on the streets. Mental illness, drug addiction, and other issues would need to be addressed, otherwise, you'll just have a homeless person with a government atm card.
- hourago 4y agoEconomic hardness causes people to fall easier into drug addiction and makes mental illness to go untreated. Give everybody an economic chance and most derived problems would be drastically reduced.
- FartyMcFarter 4y agoI still haven't seen how UBI can be funded realistically. Taking the US as an example, where would you find the extra trillions needed every year?
- hourago 4y ago> where would you find the extra trillions needed every year? From where does that number come? Will not the increased productivity of the population make up for any possible cost? It seems that the USA has found a lot of trillions from to subsidize from oil and tech companies to wage war. Why are that costs more important than a real investment in the citizens of the USA?
- FartyMcFarter 4y ago> From where does that number come? The US has 258 million adults. If you give everyone $1000 a month that's $3.1 trillion a year. > wage war The whole budget for the department of defense is about $700 billion a year. > Will not the increased productivity of the population make up for any possible cost? I don't know, but it doesn't seem like a given that UBI would increase productivity to that extent (or that it increases productivity at all).
- simonsarris 4y ago> Will not the increased productivity of the population make up for any possible cost? Almost every cash transfer program ever studied showed it a work disincentive, not a productivity boost. Some study results compilation: https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2019/basic_income_reduces_employment.html https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2019/basic_income_reduces...
- jamil7 4y agoI think most proponents would say it replaces existing forms of welfare, some pitch it as being cheaper since one can remove a lot of overhead by having everyone be eligible.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y ago
- Khelavaster 4y agoWhat if universal homes and basic maintainence and utilities were provided?
- jkepler 4y ago2nd paragraph of the article states, "Employment insecurity and the rising cost of living are also taking a toll and expanding the profile of those at risk of homelessness. " Yet, UBI would drive prices up more, as its simple monetary creation. Rising costs are part of the problem, let's not use UBI to make them rise faster. (Unless of course one were to simultaneously destroy the same amount if money as the UBI from someone else's savings. But that amounts to theft---unmasking the real morality of UBI. And I've never heard UBI proponents argue that we should steal from the rich to fund it.)
- viknesh 4y agoWhat? Have you not heard of progessive income taxes? If you're in the US, medicaid, food stamps... your comment makes no sense if your only complaint is UBI.
- savingsPossible 4y agoWe should take money from the rich to fund it. I would not say steal because I do not consider taxation to be stealing. We absolutely should not increase the money suply
- jonhohle 4y agoSay UBI is $10k a year. In the US that would add about $4T to required tax revenue. That’s double what’s currently collected each year. That wouldn’t even be enough to qualify as basic.
- dagw 4y agoUBI would replace other programs, like social security and food stamps so it's not as bad as you make it out. Also you can use the tax code to claw back some or all of that UBI from higher income individuals, again lowering the total necessary revenue.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y ago
- dementis 4y agoCalifornia recently started a Universal Basic Income Program (UBI) but, it is too early to tell if it will actually help reduce homelessness or instead cause a concentration of the US homeless population to migrate to California. https://www.cdss.ca.gov/inforesources/guaranteed-basic-income-projects https://www.cdss.ca.gov/inforesources/guaranteed-basic-incom... This article is from July[2022] and it has a more global review of UBI type programs that have been tried in the past or are currently in progress(Kenya for example). https://www.moneycrashers.com/pros-and-cons-universal-basic-income/ https://www.moneycrashers.com/pros-and-cons-universal-basic-...
- scarmig 4y agoCalifornia is trialing a guaranteed basic income, which is very different from a UBI. The latter is universal, while a GBI is conditional. Conditional money grants gated on income invariably create high marginal tax rates, as a dollar can result in no net increase in take home income.
- londons_explore 4y agoI don't think any analysis can answer the question in the title without an actual experiment... Pick a small town and deploy UBI, and see what happens.
- snidane 4y agoNumber one thing UBI does is to provide options. No longer you'll hear employers say "if you don't like it here, go somewhere else", when the 'else' part is another abusive company like that, going homeless or committing suicide. Under UBI the option of laying flat and not dying is a valid option. As a result, either a lot of people go laying flat, or working conditions improve, because smart employers will want to attract this huge dormant working force. The number one thing UBI doesn't handle well is rent inflation. You hand out $1000 dollars per person monthly, expect rents to go up by about $1000 monthly as landlords realise there is all this extra disposable income in peoples' hand right now. However, this is just an exaggerated effect of monopolies sucking out all aggregate disposable income out of economy that is already happening. Monopolies by definition don't have price down pressures, so they always price expand to capture anything people might have extra. Since landlording is the biggest aggregate monopoly in the world, landlords capture any disposable workers' income. No matter if they get a raise from their boss, the landlord always takes it away. The only solution is an antimonopoly measure that actually works. Anti-trust bureaus always end up corrupt and can't be relied on. Systematic rule based antimonopoly taxes seem to be the only current viable option. One such being the famous land value tax (LVT), which captures extra pricing on rents - enabling workers to actually keep their hardly earned income raises. Since UBI won't work without curbing monopoly price expansion, and landlords' rents are the biggest aggregate monopoly out there, there won't be any UBI without LVT.
- easytiger 4y agoSo your solution to the inherent inexorable failure of the concept of UBI is to simply modify the economic fabric of every country on earth? Do you think that sounds like a viable plan?
- snidane 4y agoFortunately, getting LVT effective is just a change of a rate how much you charge for exclusive land use. The legal framework is already set up for it in many countries, so no exchtra change needed, let alone changing the 'economic fabric'. Land based taxes were used as the primary tax mechanisn in the past, going back to ancient times, for their simplicity. The point with LVT and UBI is that you need LVT to make UBI not blow up. But once you have LVT in place you'd realise there is actually no need for UBI, because the original underlying problem - worker's disposable income being sucked away by monopolies - is suddenly gone. Under LVT the government sucks away the money from landlords, not landlords sucking it away from workers. The government can then decide to give it back to people (originally called a citizens' dividend) or reinvest into infrastructure.
- easytiger 4y agoI'll stick UBI in the same Venn diagram of childishly ill thought out ideas as algorithmic stablecoins
- trabant00 4y agoI don't know if the article does a good job of representing the paper, but if does there are very few and quite weak arguments that in no way explain how UBI will solve homelessness. They are "less stigma" - ok, but that's little, and "more efficient bureaucracy"- that remains to be proven, but again, not very much. So many questions remain: will UBI create more inflation negating the received money? What else would happen to the economy? How much money should it be considering renting is a big part of normal income? Will the rents go up? And so on.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoA UBI is a disasterous interference in the market and will yield a net zero result. In the same way the push to raise the minimum wage was negated by the rise of inflation, the market is simply not going to leave a UBI on the table. That's money to be taken. If the rent of an apartment is $500, and the government gives a person a UBI of $500, then it is logical and legal for that apartment to now rent for $1,000. What benefit has been gained? Zero. What if the apartment then went to $1,500? The UBI is still useless. Cars, food, household goods, clothing, you name it, will see an increase in price to account for the additional income in the market. We're back to square one and wasted a tremendous amount of money in the process, and destabilized the economy. A UBI is a horrible idea.
- scarmig 4y ago> If the rent of an apartment is $500, and the government gives a person a UBI of $500, then it is logical and legal for that apartment to now rent for $1,000. What benefit has been gained? Zero. What if the apartment then went to $1,500? The UBI is still useless. If the rent of an apartment is $500, and the government doesn't give a UBI, then it is logical and legal for that apartment to now rent for $1,000. Obviously landlords always can and want to raise rents, but market competition keeps them from raising prices arbitrarily. Rents would increase, but not by the full value of the grant, unless you have some pretty funny ideas about the inelasticities involved. What would happen is an aggregate shift in consumption and investments away from luxuries to necessities, as richer people have money that would compete for luxuries taxed and redirected toward poorer people who would then spend it on necessities they were forgoing for financial reasons. More money chasing inferior goods, less money chasing superior goods. (This is all assuming that the new spending is fiscally neutral i.e. funded by taxes.)
- jonhohle 4y agoRead through comments where the math is being done. Even the most basic UBI (say $500/month) would immediately become the most expensive item in the federal budget. At $1k/month it’s higher than the top three combined, which currently are nearly half the budget. Are you proposing a 80-90% increase in tax revenues (the federal budget is currently ≈50% higher than collected taxes)?
- rcarr 4y agoUniversal basic income is not the answer for obvious inflationary reasons. The solution is universal basic services. Anyone who finds themselves homeless should be given access to the following to allow them to survive in a dignified way and help them move to a self sufficient life if they choose: - A shipping container home on a dedicated facility with access to electricity, heating, water and the internet. - Mental health counselling on site. - Fitness facilities on site using cheap but effective equipment such as sandbags, sand kettlebells and weighted rucksacks. Fitness classes and organised rucks should be scheduled throughout the day for anyone to join if they wish. - Basic generic clothing if needed plus one generic formal outfit if needed for job interviews. - A free educational course. - A laptop, for educational courses and for basic entertainment. - A mobile phone. - A 50cc moped or electric bicycle to allow wider access to job opportunities. - Basic food: a Soylent like shake for breakfast, a plant based lunch and communal dinners. - A free bank account and debit card with no overdraft available. Throwing money at the problem is not going to fix it. In order to help these people rebuild financially, we need to help them heal mentally and physically then give them both the skills and means (transport, clothes) they need to find employment. They need to be allowed to heal and move at their own pace. You can try to nudge them in the right direction but ultimately it is their choice. If some of them just want to see out the rest of their days at the facility you have to be ok with that. I believe the majority will want to heal, gain skills, find employment, save up and transition back into the economy.
- incomingpain 4y ago>Homelessness is an increasing problem across the developed world, and existing policy responses are failing to make an impact. It is the government policies which cause homelessness. X = number of homes constructed in 2022. Y = number of new people in country in 2022. You have to increase X by more than Y. If you want to bring 500,000 new people to the country, there has to be that much more construction. But new building is hard as ever. Carbon tax adds huge cost to concrete. Concrete plants can't operate anymore, imported concrete is exempt. Not to mention construction worker shortage; https://www.statcan.gc.ca/en/subjects-start/labour_/labour-shortage-trends-canada https://www.statcan.gc.ca/en/subjects-start/labour_/labour-s... You can't even build more even if government wasn't in the way. Nobody wants to do the work. Therefore we have a consequence of homelessness increasing. What will UBI do? UBI won't build more homes. Nobody going to receive a cheque for $2000/year and say, "I'm going to go work in the cold, building homes." No it's the opposite, those cold construction workers can stop wearing their reflective clothing. Maybe take this $2000 to start a new business. You'll have less homes being built the next year. Homelessness will increase.