6 ms·
I think it's a bit weird to compare TikTok to traditional social media like Facebook, Instagram, and Snapchat. Those older platforms were about your social net
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I think it's a bit weird to compare TikTok to traditional social media like Facebook, Instagram, and Snapchat.
Those older platforms were about your social networks (friends and friends of friends) - or at least they were before they started to ape TikTik.
For me, the much closer comparison to TikTok is YouTube, and I feel that TikTok is really just a mobile-optimized YouTube.
- user_named 4y agoYes, tiktok is not a social platform. It is an entertainment platform where the content is user generated.
- KevinBenSmith 4y agoI agree. That’s a great way of putting it.
- fsckboy 4y agouser generated content, like the way youtube used to be
- philwelch 4y agoIt’ll happen to TikTok too, if it hasn’t already.
- themitigating 4y agoYoutube content is generated by its users
- tromp 4y agoI listen to my favorite music on youtube all day. None of that is user generated I would say.
- 8note 4y agoAren't there TikTok houses, for people who dedicate their career to making tiktocks? That's the same as the established YouTube creators
- nostromo 4y agoIt’s social media vs social networks. Facebook, SnapChat and Instagram are social networks. YouTube, TikTok, and Reddit are social media.
- dolmen 4y agoI see Instagram as social media, not social network. I have no IRL links to any of the accounts I'm following on Insta. I'm interested only in seing beautiful pictures (and not awful "reels").
- Ekaros 4y agoIsn't Instagram also social media? Or why do I keep hearing influencers being there? Isn't that one of the features of social media?
- zoover2020 4y agoPotato vs. Potato
- MiguelX413 4y agoInstagram can be used without seeing any influencers, it allows you to stick to the content your interested in. In my case, I'm able to just see Evangelion memes from accounts I follow and the occasional ad.
- kbenson 4y agoThat's just the "following" section of TikTok, which only shows content of those you follow.
- user_named 4y agoTiktok is not social media at all. It's an entertainment platform.
- culturestate 4y ago> Tiktok is not social media at all. It's an entertainment platform. Plenty of social interaction happens in TikTok comments and DMs. If Instagram is social media, so is TikTok.
- kqcso 4y agoI think the main similarity between TikTok and traditional social media is the "keeping up with the Joneses" aspect. Once you've bought in, you see how amazing these peoples' lives are and you want your life to be that great too. IMO it's all an illusion, but it's not much different from seeing a friend, family member, co-worker. or a prominent business-person/celebrity being more successful than you. The interesting (scary?) thing about TikTok is that it hyper-compresses that environment into a few seconds, then constantly bombards you with it via a neverending flow of videos. It's like keeping up with the Joneses on amphetamines.
- kredd 4y agoWeird part about it, it really depends. The last time I checked, my TikTok feed was just full of funny small videos filmed by random people doing stupid trends outside. Nothing about their lives exactly attracts me. However, the fact that a lot of people see these videos, and I reshare it with my friends and laugh at it together is what can make it remarkable. Obviously, it heavily depends. I’ve looked at my friends’ feeds and it’s exactly what you’ve described.
- carl_dr 4y agoThis is the actual great thing about TikTok. My experience of TikTok seems very different to the majority of the commenters here, it’s like we’re on different platforms. Obviously we all like different things, and there is enough content to fill everyone’s feeds with it.
- kbenson 4y agoYeah, the one thing people familiar with TikTok seen to agree on and be impressed by is its ability to cater the content it serves to your desires. That's actually what got me to try it out. There were multiple cases where I heard that, so downloaded it and spent some time on it. After you've used it a few hours, you start really getting mostly the stuff you like. You just have to be very careful not to engage with stuff you don't want to see. Scroll away as soon as you've determined it's not for you, as they'll notice if you watch things to the end. I made a conscious decision that I didn't want to engage in content where people were complaining about the behavior of other people and scrolled past as soon as I identified things as such, and I stopped getting them within a few days. My TikTok is all fun/funny stuff.
- sekai 4y agoExactly TikTok is just Vine with longer videos, no one was calling Vine a social network.
- nearmuse 4y agoPeople are seeing the young YouTube in TikTok. For monetization reasons, YouTube shifted to longer and better produced videos, and the quirky and raw content the OP is praising TikTok for has become less prominent, although it is definitely still there.
- roenxi 4y agoThere is an interesting argument here against the idea that YouTube, Facebook, etc are monopolies despite their impressive market share. The moment they try to extract value from their users, they have to shrink their own mote - a competitor can copy the older version of the platform that extracted less money. They don't actually have much choice in how they run their products.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoSo if a dictator's hold on power is weak, is it not a dictatorship? Imagine there have been 2 coups over 15 years, yet both produced a winner-takes-nearly-all outcome. Not sure it matters much if you're at the bottom and have to bow to one for a while then the other.
- roenxi 4y agoPut it this way; your comment could be a veiled description of US politics. The typical democracy simulates a coup every 2-5 years in a winner-takes-all contest. If if you're at the bottom and have to bow to one party for a while then the other. Indeed, the description is so apt that everyone ritualistically accuses their political opponents of actually fomenting a coup (powered by Russia/China/Israel/Bill Gates/mobilising dead people/gerrymandering/the electoral college being illegitimate/whatever). So yes, I do actually believe that. If the hold on power is weak enough it doesn't count as a dictatorship.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoThe difference is an effective balance of power between branches of a government. Dictators have unchecked power (at least in practice) until they're deposed. Similarly many of today's tech giants are difficult to escape, especially as network effects drive toward centralization of power.
- baxtr 4y agoThere was a pretty interesting article about this recently, called "The end of social media". Social Media is becoming more and more like TikTok, where you don't see your friends content so much but rather upvoted content. https://mignano.medium.com/the-end-of-social-media-a88ffed21f86 https://mignano.medium.com/the-end-of-social-media-a88ffed21...
- indigochill 4y agoAs someone who's rapidly moving over to Activity Pub platforms, this was still an interesting read. Over there, it's just like social networking used to be: a strictly chronological feed of posts from people you choose to follow and nothing else. Sure, it's not always the most engaging content (my Facebook feed is still more "sticky"), but engagement is decidedly not the point over there.
- chemmail 4y agoTik Tok is youtube for people with ADD. I listened to some Mr Beast videos and checked out some of his videos on youtube. OMG its like freakin cuts every 10 seconds, feels like my mind going to explode. I finally figured they cut it like a Tik Tok video for the ADD.
- willsmith72 4y agoYes, and the scary part is even for people without ADHD, it's completely killing their attention spans, which is then triggering them to go and get themselves diagnosed. Producing ADHD meds is going to be a lucrative business
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- H8crilA 4y agoOne of the greatest marketing moves of all time is coming up with the name "Adderall". It's just amphetamine! Well, a slightly different stereoisomer mix, but just amphetamine nonetheless. Sounds a million times better though, especially if your kid is about to take it.
- chownie 4y agoYouTubers have been doing gratuitous jump cuts since like 2011, go look at some Fred videos. It's nothing to do with TikTok nor ADD, they use the jump cuts to mask recording mistakes or to cut out pauses.
- steve1977 4y ago> they use jump cuts to mask recording mistakes or to cut out pauses Both of which of course have a lot to do with reduced attention span.
- KaoruAoiShiho 4y agoPauses and mistakes objectively add negative value to videos it's a good thing that it's removed.
- powerapple 4y agoI think it is TV, you turn it on, after a few second, you have your entertainment. YouTube still needs searching and subscribing, TikTok doesn't need any of those. I compare TikTok to MTV.