4 ms·
It is interesting to me that Subversion barely gets a mention. There should be a 7.5 which is along the lines of: cvs was great and all, but we couldn't versio
by latchkey 15y ago
It is interesting to me that Subversion barely gets a mention. There should be a 7.5 which is along the lines of:
cvs was great and all, but we couldn't version our directories, branching and merging was a mess, the wire protocol was hard to use, it had a ton of security holes and the storage format took up too much space. So, Subversion was created as a way to do a better cvs, without thinking about the larger intrinsic issues with the current state of version control. Thus, missing the whole 'distributed' boat and letting Linus eat our lunch.
Note: I worked at CollabNet during this time and watched a lot of the discussions around Subversion. I have great respect for the Subversion developers. Karl is an awesome and brilliant guy. It was a bubble, technology isn't anywhere where it is today and I think we were all misguided at that time. We all made a lot of mistakes.
- technomancy 15y agoThe article is about astonishment. Everything SVN did was fairly obvious.
- latchkey 15y agoHa! Definitely can't argue that point. ;-)
- kisielk 15y agoWith Subversion branching and merging was still a mess, at least everywhere I ever saw it used.
- latchkey 15y agoOh, it is a complete failure. I've switched to Git entirely as a result of it and will never use Subversion again if I can help it. I wrote a long'ish blog post detailing why it is a failure: http://lookfirst.com/2011/04/subversion-mistake.html http://lookfirst.com/2011/04/subversion-mistake.html