8 ms·
100s of Twitter employees leaving after Musk's 'extremely hardcore' work demands
- legerdemain 4y agoElon should follow Verizon's lead and sell Twitter to Automattic for $1M.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- whateveracct 4y agoPut Tumblr in charge of it. Quarantines Tumblr's existing culture.
- giantdude 4y ago[flagged]
- tamaharbor 4y ago_everyone_ loved Elon when he stuck to EVs, spaceX, solar panels, and boring companies.
- andrewflnr 4y agoYeah, that was when he was useful enough to outweigh his jackassery. And hey, maybe if he kills twitter, he'll still be doing humanity a service.
- lost_tourist 4y agopeople will just flee to other social media. Twitter dying changes nothing
- andrewflnr 4y agoN social networks with M/N people each are not remotely the same as a single network with M people.
- kccoder 4y agoThe submarine/rescue situation should've clued many more people into his capricious, reckless nature, but yet many persisted. This country has a serious problem with platforming and idolizing narcissists and non-violent psychopaths and it needs to stop. Sh*t-shows like this hopefully have a chance of showing everyone that these monsters don't deserve our adulation.
- giantdude 4y agoI hope that was _sarcasm_... This man is singlehandedly causing more polution, social unrest, and fraud than anyone I've seen in my lifetime. Each of his enterprises is bankrupt without government money and very creative accounting. His behavior is reprehensible and criminal. I can't believe he is not in prison.
- voxl 4y agoThe comment you're responding to is a prescription: what people ought to do. Yours is a description: what people in fact do. Yet, you phrased it in the same way, with the same emphasis. It might be a world view shifting shock to you. But I have always thought Elon was an asshole, from the very beginning of his self image marketing campaign.
- kccoder 4y agoAnd with any luck this charade will clue the previously clueless into this man's irrational, unstable nature, permanently removing the veneer of credibility and "coolness" that has been instrumental in his success thus far.
- helf 4y agoThe legions of neckbeards who worship him as a real life Stark will follow him to their graves.
- dang 4y agoPlease don't call names on HN and especially please don't do psychiatric name-calling. You may not owe billionaire CEOs who you feel are psychopathic better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- giantdude 4y agoPlease look up the definition of psychopathy. I can see that you are impressed by his wealth and title, but I owe this community a voice to balance yours.
- dang 4y agoTossing pejoratives like 'psychopath' around in information-free ways is a marker of a bad HN comment, regardless of who it is you're putting down—although the celebrity aspect makes it worse because it adds sensationalism. If you've read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, it should be obvious that this isn't in the intended spirit of the site. In fact, if that isn't obvious of your comment, of which comment would it be obvious? It's common for people to conclude that the mods secretly hold the opposing view to theirs*. I suppose the logic goes like this: (1) I can't possibly have broken the rules; (2) yet the moderator has scolded me; (3) why? there must be some other reason; (4) it must be that they disagree with me. The mistake is at step (1). The truth is, we don't care—we just want commenters to use the site as intended. * https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=mods%20against%20by%3Adang&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- labrador 4y agoKylie Robison (Tech reporter for @FortuneMagazine): What I’m hearing from Twitter employees; It looks like roughly 75% of the remaining 3,700ish Twitter employees have not opted to stay after the “hardcore” email. https://twitter.com/kyliebytes/status/1593391167718113280 https://twitter.com/kyliebytes/status/1593391167718113280
- toss1 4y agoThat brings it down to under 1000 employees So Elon paid $44B for a company now with 900-odd employees. For a 10-year ROI, that's $4.4B per year profit, or $440 million/per employee For contrast, Netflix has the highest revenue per employee at $2.63 million/person, and Apple is second at $2.38 million, and Alphabet & Meta next at $1.64, and eBay at $0.9 million per employee. So, he'll need to get 200x the profitability per employee, just to get a total profit equal to his investment in 10 years. To get a company valuation back to his purchase price, at a 20X multiple, he needs to make those employees as profitable per employee as Apple. In a business that has never been consistently profitable, has not much of a moat, and in which he'd panicked almost all of his advertisers, the primary customers. Good luck with that
- randomsearch 4y agoIf he needs more than 900 employees, he can just hire more. He is not fixed at "900 employees", so the premise of this argument is invalid.
- noelsusman 4y agoThere's a reason he tried to get out of this deal. He's going to lose billions of dollars on this, the only question at this point is how many billions.
- Zigurd 4y agoThis is an under-explored part of how we got here. Elon did not want to buy Twitter. He bought it only because he thought he could flip it and lose less than what settling would cost (plus what damage depositions would do). Right up to a few days before the deal closed, Elon was hoping he would not have to actually run Twitter. And that's the second part that is under-explored: Elon could not find a CEO. And he never will until he admits all of his and the coinvestors' equity stakes are now worth zero, and he takes a down round that reshapes the cap table and enables a sane incentive package for a CEO.
- chemmail 4y agoHundres as in with 2 whole zeros? out of almost 10k? WOW they gonna half hundreds less now!
- Ptchd 4y ago"Twitter had roughly 2,900 remaining employees before the deadline Thursday," That's still a lot of employees... Hopefully for Musk, they kept the better ones.
- evan_ 4y agosomeone on blind is saying there are fewer than 300 employees left
- MrMan 4y agoI doubt it come on. this is all fun but he can actually have reduced in force that much
- oarabbus_ 4y agoThe article states keeping employment was opt-in. As in, agree to working more than 9-5 and click the link below, if you do not, you are laid off.
- P_I_Staker 4y agoI agree, he can. ;) I think he just got on 300 signees; that's the number. So an enormous number I imagine are calling his bluff, but intend to let the checks to keep cashing. I would almost 100% do that if it was me. I guess I'd probably be gone by now.
- evan_ 4y agowhy not?
- seti0Cha 4y agoIs it my imagination or is it actually breaking down right now? I'm not seeing any new tweets! edit: no, still going, but maybe the notifications are slow. As an SRE, I somehow feel obliged to watch it break.
- partiallypro 4y agoIt's your imagination.
- shagie 4y agoThey're stuck. https://twitter.com/anothercohen/status/1593404311832338442 https://twitter.com/anothercohen/status/1593404311832338442 https://twitter.com/TweetOfSteiner/status/1593407559125311488 https://twitter.com/TweetOfSteiner/status/159340755912531148...
- fasthands9 4y agoThe first tweet you linked to is a parody account
- alx__ 4y agoPretty sure those are satire posts
- esalman 4y agoWhat I noticed is that after opening a thread the parent tweet is unavailable. It shows up once I go back. I'd attribute it to some kind of cache issue.
- partiallypro 4y agoI think there are going to be two levels of shock: 1) Never give people an ultimatum. It basically never works in your favor. That was such a dumb thing by Elon and his team. I don't think Elon expected the numbers to be so high. 2) Workers often overestimate their own worth within a company or how easily they can be replaced. It's likely that all the people leaving saying Twitter is going to majorly break soon won't be correct, as I doubt the core engineers are the ones posting Emojis in the Slack channels.
- mikkergp 4y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/nitashatiku/status/1593399704636620800 https://mobile.twitter.com/nitashatiku/status/15933997046366... !!! “I know of six critical systems (like ‘serving tweets’ levels of critical) which no longer have any engineers," "There is no longer even a skeleton crew manning the system. It will continue to coast until it runs into something, and then it will stop.” Could be fake, but assuming true, can Elon take it back? Is a webform like legally binding for severance? Elon did say he could run it with 150 engineers do even if 90% are gone, that leaves 700 thereabouts.
- partiallypro 4y agoI think right now emotions are flying high, so people are going to make grand statements (and of course the press, which now hates Musk, is very gung-ho to publish anything.) I'm sure some systems will fail, but as to if the general public will really notice much of it, I have doubts. I could be wrong, but I've seen employees make similar claims after being fired or leaving and generally most everything working out. Interviewing or getting information from people fired up after an event like that are generally not reliable, in my experience.
- mikkergp 4y agoYou’re absolutely right for any small group of people, but if 88 percent of employees are gone(and you’re right that’s a big if right now) I don’t think there’s a precedent for this?
- MrMan 4y agopeople love repeated ultimatums and firings !!!!
- WheelsAtLarge 4y agoI understand being tough but why cause the needless turmoil. There's a theory of management that advocates breaking it all down and then rebuilding it from the bottom but this is a very extreme application.
- lost_tourist 4y agoI truly hope all the top tier engineers who kept it going leave and it all goes bankrupt and Elon can have his tarnished brand lol. There are multiple other avenues on social media for the same functions as Twitter, maybe a little less conducive but they will do the job.
- zwkrt 4y agoYeah even at a company with as relatively stable a product as twitter, there are so many processes that go on internally that certainly need someone who knows how to operate them. Another commenter mentioned dead-man's switches, but you don't even need explicit switches, especially if an entire team leaves. There will be parts of twitters infra that no one even knows how to deploy, /even if/ it was fully automated. At this point I would be extremely surprised if the twitter infrastructure was anything other than a car with no brakes. It will be interesting to see what parts of it fail first.
- pram 4y agoEspecially considering they use a lot of stuff no one else uses, like Pelikan. They already fired the main dev, who knows if there's an ops team left. How do you even hire for that? It's hard enough finding people who can run Kafka lol
- sega_sai 4y agoI do know that many on HN are critical of twitter, but since the start of the war with Ukraine, twitter was an essential way to get fresh news/analysis of the situation. Therefore it's a pity that twitter is going down. And I do think it is happening.
- acdha 4y agoThat's my regret as well — there was clearly a very popular niche for breaking news and self-organization, although with some very challenging problems around authenticity which are hard to reconcile with such deep cuts.
- gretch 4y agoIs losing information on the war really a bad thing? I mean of course it is for people living in Ukraine who need updated information to survive. (But I would also hope they have govt sponsored alternatives) But I actually thought it was deeply disturbing how many ppl in unrelated places, like California, would wake up and look forward to getting a fresh voyeur look on the suffering of others. Ppl were spectating and commenting like it was the latest season of game of thrones. Most likely ppl did some unintentional desensitization to themselves unknowingly. Imo, not having such information is a net positive for society. Yes we should study war to not repeat historical mistakes. That’s completely different that what I saw a lot of Twitter coverage was tho
- justin66 4y agoThat "fresh voyeur look on the suffering of others" (odd framing) is why there is widespread, bipartisan political support for supporting Ukraine with munitions and money. People wouldn't make that choice if they did not know what is going on.
- gretch 4y agoI don’t think that’s true at all? Support was setup and had been streaming into to Ukraine for a long time before any confirmation of a war, much less images. I remember when trump was president and there was the dispute where he was holding back the regular defense aid that the US sends to Ukraine. The point being that hundreds of millions were approved and sent with 0 tweets about the war (literally didn’t happen yet)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- duped 4y agoIt's kind of that a billionaire can show up one day and ruin thousands of people's lives.
- kccoder 4y agoHis money provided the opportunity, but his personality flaws / mental health disorders provided the means.
- helf 4y agoBye, twitter.
- musesum 4y agoExtreme commitment makes sense if you believe in the mission. Such as saving the planet with EVs. Not sure what Twitter's altruistic mission is. Giving up family life to enable trolls may not seen like a good trade.
- throwaway23597 4y ago+1. Musk needs to offer a compelling vision for what this platform should be. As of now I primarily know Twitter as the home of cancel culture, whiny journalists, and idiotic flame wars. That's not something I would devote 80+ hours a week of my life to, not by a long shot.
- postingawayonhn 4y agoI think he has a serious gap in his understanding of the company culture. He has basically just assumed that many of the employees work there for the same reasons employees work at Tesla, SpaceX, etc.
- wilg 4y agoOr he just only wants to work with ones who do!
- randomsearch 4y ago_This_ is the real existential threat to Twitter. From the outside, before Musk bought it Twitter already looked like a stagnant company making short-term decisions to boost kpi's without a real mission. I'm just not sure Elon is the man to fix a business that isn't really going anywhere. It was pedestrian, maybe it was hard to see a vision in that space, and the company culture became one of "maintain". Even if he sells a vision of the "Everything App" like WeChat, is he going to find enough people at Twitter and enough new recruits to buy into that? Wouldn't you rather go put man on Mars or fight climate change? If he _does_ manage to turn Twitter into the Western WeChat, it will be one of the most remarkable events in tech history. That said, I'm not even sure we want him working on a social network rather than loftier goals, so perhaps it would be better for humanity if he fails fast here.
- cratermoon 4y agoTwitter will fall down over Thanksgiving.
- deskamess 4y agoI guess its time for IsTwitterDownYet.com . Makes you wonder what its architectural weak points are.
- trinovantes 4y agoThe world cup should be a good stress test for Twitter's automated systems
- cratermoon 4y agoOoof. I don't follow football, but yes, World Cup and Thanksgiving the same week.
- holografix 4y agoWho’s gonna say yes to “extreme hardcore” without “significant pay raise”? The momentarily desperate and the nihilistic. I imagine a proportion will say “sure” and do absolutely nothing until they finally get fired. While another group will say yes up to the very minute they find another job.
- randomsearch 4y ago> Who’s gonna say yes to “extreme hardcore” without “significant pay raise”? I can see one group of people: those who genuinely care about Twitter and have felt frustrated under previous management. But you have to wonder why they didn't already leave.
- jinonoel 4y agoMakes sense. I'm not sure there's a job I wouldn't leave for 3 months free money. Especially if I was confident of my talent and abilities as an ex-Twitter engineer.
- rayiner 4y agoI suspect this works at Tesla and SpaceX because working on rockets and EVs is intrinsically cool and motivating for nerds, in contrast to whatever kind of company Twitter is. But I don’t understand why everyone is so dour. Either Musk figured out how to fix Twitter, or we no longer have to deal with Twitter. Win win.
- deskamess 4y agoIf you are somewhat important at Twitter (part of keeping the lights on, not new features) you would do well to take the severance and look else where. If Elon comes knocking get a huge upfront non-refundable signing bonus and dictate 'softcore' terms for re-employment. Better if you can find out who else is being called back and then you can all sort of work together to get better terms (create a very high floor).
- user_named 4y agoMistake to make remaining employed optin with scary marketing copy above the button, instead of having the optin be for layoffs. Doesn't get UX, Musk.
- angrysword 4y agoWe all know Twitter is really bad product we are using. The obvious problem is the twitter culture. It is extreme difficult to fix a company culture. I believe what Elon did is the fastest way to fix twitter broken culture. I believe 200 engineers can run twitter far more better than now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throw_away__2 4y agoWhat’s missing in almost all of the discussion is that billionaires rarely buy media companies to maximise their profits. It’s down to maximise their power. As long as Twitter remains the social media portal for politicians, business leaders, media, journalists, and scientists, he controls the algorithm. He also gets to advertise at will to the most powerful people on the planet. His largest business risk is political. He needs the government support for spaceX and he might need them to mitigate Tesla class action liabilities. For 1/10th the market cap of Tesla he owns the ‘Town square’. Presumably he could pay off the debt if he wanted to, unless Tesla shares crater. Now that he owns Twitter, his biggest risk is pushback from employees. He needs and rewards loyalty, and so forcing people to opt-out and pledge allegiance early is also critical. The short, medium, or even long term economics of the Twitter business are not relevant and he’s using it as a smokescreen to hide the power play he’s making. Like Trump, he understands power and doesn’t concern himself with truth.
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoQuestion: What does 7500 employees do at Twitter? I cannot fathom what they do. Can someone help me with some general percent breakdown? How many are management, support, coders, testers, etc?
- skyde 4y agoHow many employees do you think Youtube has?
- joeevans1000 4y agoWas the button opt-in a legal workaround for something?