3 ms·
Thought this was an Onion article at first... still difficult to believe that the South Koreans would let their economy get so close to the edge like that. EDI
by MichaelZuo 4y ago
Thought this was an Onion article at first... still difficult to believe that the South Koreans would let their economy get so close to the edge like that.
EDIT: Especially since "To prevent the credit market from seizing up completely, the South Korean government stepped in by providing a liquidity facility of more than 50 trillion won (about $35 billion). The Bank of Korea also injected 42.5 trillion won (about $31 billion) to stabilize the short-term bond market, and South Korea’s five largest banks also pledged to provide up to 95 trillion won (about $67 billion) in liquidity."
Wouldn't it have been easier to retract the policy of the local government, sack the local leaders, etc., to rollback the loss of trust?
Especially since S.K. is a unitary country and not federated so local governments have no sovereignty.
- bobthepanda 4y agoThat rolls back the lack of trust in that specific project but does not prevent contagion (“who’s next? Who else was doing this?”) Moves like this are supposed to be reassuring to the broader market. Punishment is something done after an error but does not guarantee that someone else also didn’t do this, and punishment doesn’t go back in time and undo actions. If you are not decisive enough the markets can quickly spiral into contagion, however rational that may be. (See: the prolonged cascading during the Euro crisis)
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoI dunno, I think that’d be a pretty good signal to the market that these kind of shenanigans aren’t gonna fly and won’t keep happening.
- bobthepanda 4y agoThe important thing to signal is not that, but that’s necessary to do later. The important thing to signal is that investments are safe, even if other investments might fall prey to the same issue. Doing just the former means that everyone is suspicious of everything they currently hold, and will be too spooked to invest even in new perfectly good ones until they get clarity on everything, causing the market to seize up. Justice and auditing takes time, but the need to refinance bonds is pretty much constant.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoIt probably wouldn't restore things back 100% to where they were before. But it probably would have restored a large amount of trust.
- bobthepanda 4y agoNothing magically restores total trust, but the important thing is that the ball needs to keep rolling, even if a bit slower.
- summerlight 4y agoNo, it's actually pretty dry compared to the real thing happened in the bond market. What it means is that no bond could be fully trusted in South Korea in the long term. Whenever political power shifted, some crazy politician can decide to default it and there's no system to stop them from doing such stuff. If you cannot trust government-issued bonds, you don't have the economical foundation at all. > Wouldn't it have been easier to retract the policy of the local government, sack the local leaders, etc., to rollback the loss of trust? That would help the situation, but the only solution here would be the systematic guarantee to punish such politicians but we don't have any hope for a foreseeable future since the governor is from the ruling party and was a prosecutor. South Korean prosecutors are the worst for this job, they're corrupted to the root and is a highly political entity but without being elected. I don't see any possibility of prosecuting the governor for abuse of power.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThanks for responding, I edited my comment afterwards as I did some digging and it does seem to have seriously damaged mutual trust in SK. Not exaggerated at all by FP, my first impression was incorrect.
- bobthepanda 4y agoAn important thing to keep in mind is that despite South Korea’s wealth, the sharp rise in its economy and relatively recent regime change means that its institutions are not battle-tested. This causes its markets to behave more similarly to developing markets, because the institutional trust is not there. It also does not help that historically it was one of the worse managed Asian Tiger economies. During the 1998 crisis it was the only East Asian economy to need an IMF bailout, and it has a very well publicized revolving door of pardons for chaebol CEOs convicted of things like bribery and fraud.
- yongjik 4y ago> the only solution here would be the systematic guarantee to punish such politicians ... Yeah I don't think it would work, even in principle. Being an idiot is not a crime, and you can't prosecute politicians for being grossly incompetent, unless they break the law. Besides, as you already pointed out, any such system would be abused by politicians and their supporters to "get back at" their opponents. I'm pretty sure many who voted for Yoon specifically did it to watch his predecessor Moon going to prison. (I guess they will have to keep waiting - you can like or hate Moon, but nobody made a convincing case of corruption.)
- downrightmike 4y agoThey should, the bad bankers getting punished helped Iceland bounce back quickly. But the SK Chaebols are really the problem. They have a house of cards built on centralized ownership through leveraged buyouts and collusion. If they don't take the Chaebols down and punish them too, the bankers will just keep going on doing what they. The government keeps pardoning the Chaebol leaders who run into the same problems regardless of their leader, father and son both have the same issues because it is systematic.
- wellareyousure 4y ago> But the SK Chaebols are really the problem. Where, in Asia, is something like this not a problem?
- somedude895 4y ago> Wouldn't it have been easier to retract the policy of the local government, sack the local leaders, etc., to rollback the loss of trust? That's what I thought too. Central government coming in to make it clear that local governments have to honor their word without exception.
- puchatek 4y agoMight be a trade-off between propping up trust in the bonds market and safeguarding trust in democracy.
- mint2 4y agoOnce the trust is broken, once the taboo action is taken, it doesn’t matter if the action is reversed. There are no redos with trust in matters like that.