4 ms·
Emissions from 15 of the biggest meat and dairy companies
- docmechanic 4y agoFascinating graphic and more inspiration to stay as meat-free as possible.
- doener 4y agoOn this topic: Plant-based meat by far the best climate investment, report finds https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jul/07/plant-based-meat-by-far-the-best-climate-investment-report-finds https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jul/07/plant-ba...
- docmechanic 4y agoGreat article. This bit blew me away: "investment in improving and scaling up the production of meat and dairy alternatives resulted in ... 11 times more than zero-emission cars.
- themihai 4y agoI think the solution is rather feeding the cows with specific nutrition(i.e seaweed) + powering the whole supply chain with green energy. People won't give up on meat.It's just too tasty.
- doener 4y agoThis would not solve the methane problem. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/nov/15/methane-emissions-meat-dairy-companies?ref=upstract.com https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/nov/15/methane-...
- randomdata 4y agoAnd giving up on meat wouldn't solve the nitrous oxide problem, which is mostly created in the process of growing plants for food. If you are going to let perfect be the enemy of good you're going to end up hungry.
- wyre 4y agoRelying on meat isn’t going to solve the nitrous oxide problem either.
- themihai 4y ago>> Red Seaweed Cuts Methane In Cows By More Than Half. I'm sure we can do better if we invest more.
- jordanmoconnor 4y ago
- yodon 4y agoTrolling is not generally popular here the way it is on other sites.
- randomdata 4y agoMeat and dairy production is a product of oil, so how is the accounting done here? Is the emissions from the diesel burned in a tractor used to grow and harvest the hay for the cattle beast on the oil company or on the meat companies? Perhaps is it counted twice?
- doener 4y agoI think oil plays a very minor role in the footprint of meat: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/nov/15/methane-emissions-meat-dairy-companies?ref=upstract.com https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/nov/15/methane-...
- randomdata 4y agoI see nothing in the article that explains how the accounting is done. What is the relevance? Do you profit from the ads contained within?
- bigyikes 4y ago>So why aren't these companies being held accountable for fuelling the climate crisis? Probably because food is non-negotiable and most people are not willing to switch to a plant-based diet. At least with energy production, there are comparable alternatives to fossil fuels: solar, wind, and nuclear. With food, there is simply not a comparable alternative to meat. The solution is a compelling meat substitute.
- doener 4y ago>With food, there is simply not a comparable alternative to meat. For the fillet mignon of top gastronomy maybe not (although I can recommend everyone to try Juicy Marbles: https://www.cnet.com/home/juicy-marbles-review/ https://www.cnet.com/home/juicy-marbles-review/). For the burger, which are eaten quickly in between? Definitely. And that is definitely the very largest part of meat consumption worldwide. I don't think most people would even notice if the burger patty, bursting with sauce, was replaced by Beyond Meat or Impossible Meat.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoEh, I don't think most people's diet consists of hamburgers. Or rather, I sure hope it doesn't.
- snapplebobapple 4y agoI tried the beyond meat offerings by the various burger joints when they came out and I can tell you that if you think the above is true you need to eat some more meat to refresh your memory (not to mention the brain fog and gassy belly I got from some of those offerings).
- teilo 4y agoBecause for the most part, meat is carbon neutral. Meat is not and has never been the problem. Look at it from the standpoint of the carbon cycle. For example, where does the carbon in the methane originate? It is carbon that originated in plant matter consumed by cattle. It originates in the atmosphere, and goes back to the atmosphere. We do not feed petroleum or coal to cows. So net-carbon increase from cattle production is very minimal. Going after foot production is insane.
- ohCh6zos 4y agoThere seems to be a huge overlap between people pushing abstinence from meat on the grounds it is better for the planet and people who a prior believe meat consumption to be immoral. It would be wise to have a healthy skepticism if a beef and dairy association said there was no impact, so it seems it would be equally wise to apply skepticism to ethically minded vegans saying it is not fine.
- goethes_kind 4y agoNominally meat production emits more CO2, but one also has to take in account the nutrition of the food. 1kg of beef vs 1kg of rice. Not exactly the same. The CO2 footprint of a plant-based diet is lower. However, that is not the only aspect of this discussion. All the studies on the subject that I read seem to indicate that eliminating animal protein always leads to deficiencies and lack of growth in children. All the studies on the health benefits of veganism only seem to apply to obese people eating junk food. But one does not need to go full vegan. Reducing meat consumption to the bare minimum and maybe selectively eating animal products that are less harmful to the climate, it arguable a better strategy.
- igetspam 4y ago"Always," you say? It "always" leads to deficiencies and lack of growth? Shoot. Don't tell my kid, who at five is half her mom's height and is in track to be taller than I am. I eat the occasional meat and ate more when I was younger. My kid is a vegetarian, like her mother. Maybe check the hyperbole a bit. People who only eat plants do just fine. People who don't put thought into what they eat, do badly, no matter the diet. Your average American probably has a significant glut of protein and carbs and days and everything else and they probably significantly overestimate the amount of protein they need (discuss it with athletes who have professionals planning their intake). We glamorize protein for some reason but look around you. People are fat. Arguably it would be better if most people probably went vegetarian.
- goethes_kind 4y agoAll the studies that I have read indicate that protein quality is important and children on strict vegan diets do worse on multiple growth metrics. As a layman on the subject I cannot really give you professional advice, but in my very best estimation is does seem to me, that a healthy diet that includes animal protein is a more cautious approach to one which totally excludes it, assuming the health of the child is being prioritized.
- stefantalpalaru 4y ago
- wyre 4y agoThe actual report: https://www.iatp.org/emissions-impossible-methane-edition https://www.iatp.org/emissions-impossible-methane-edition
- melling 4y agoI can identify 20% of global carbon emissions in 8500 coal power plants. Only 8500 plants need to be replaced and we can reduce 20% of emissions. Hey I’ve got a stupid idea. Let’s tell everyone to stop eating meat, replace a billion gas powered cars, drive less and stop flying Let’s rinse and repeat and have this discussion every day for the next decade, just like we have done for the past 2 decades
- karmakurtisaani 4y agoThe problem is that many of those coal plants are in China. How are you going to close coal plants in China? However, influencing your meat and dairy consumption is trivial compared to the above.
- melling 4y agoThe US debt is $32 trillion. Maybe you could pay a few extra dollars in taxes to help bring it down. Seriously, do the math. Doing things that make zero difference doesn’t help. It’s like the drunk looking for his keys under the street light
- karmakurtisaani 4y agoDoes the US debt threaten to end the life on earth? Then I'll happily join the movement that aims to bring it down by private action. I know individual action on it's own is not terribly effective. The game plan I see here is that we keep public focus on how bad meat eating is for the environment, and hopefully reach a critical mass in public opinion so that one day it is politically acceptable to reduce the dairy industry subsidies. It takes time, but it is a feasible idea.
- matrix_overload 4y agoThe skill we desperately need to teach to the public is prioritization. It only takes 3 steps: 1. Identify what measurable effect you want to achieve (e.g. reduce emissions by X% within Y years). 2. Look for multiple ways to do it. 3. Pick the combination with the best cost/effect ratio. Until this is taught in schools on par with math or basic history, we are extremely prone to manipulation. Whoever owns the media will cover one solution that benefits them, declare it as a religious virtue and fill their pockets off pushing the crowd to adopt it. If may never solve the actual problem, but the public lacking those skills will never notice and will never question the narrative.
- snapplebobapple 4y agoMost of these reports are basically scams. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGG-A80Tl5g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGG-A80Tl5g
- oifjsidjf 4y agoBig fake plant food companies pushing this really hard since they see massive $$$ in replacing meat. Meat was one market that fake food companies couldn't touch until now when they're trying to feed us those nutritional laboratory grown monstrosities.
- bell-cot 4y agoObvious fix: break up the biggest meat & dairy companies into a huge number of smaller companies, cutting the "emissions from 15 of the biggest" value by ~100x. (Or, maybe it'd be better to focus on metrics which aren't so easily gamed?)
- kderbyma 4y agoI would advise people to start an aquarium. it will teach them many things about emissions....and pollution.. perhaps....this article could learn a thing.