50 ms·
Nitpicking but >if we turned off all bitcoin miners today, bitcoin would go to zero instantly isn't true. You couldn't trade them normally with the miners off
by tim333 4y ago
Nitpicking but
>if we turned off all bitcoin miners today, bitcoin would go to zero instantly
isn't true. You couldn't trade them normally with the miners off but you could start mining up the day after - it only takes a couple of computers really.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- feet 4y agoTurning mining back on is entirely changing the parent's statement. "Well yea you could do that change to tank the value, but imagine if you just undid it huh???" The point was without mining entirely, there is no value
- Taniwha 4y agoBut there's only ever going to be a fixed number of bitcoin - does it all just stop working when it's all mined out?
- majewsky 4y agoOnce all bitcoins are mined, miners are supposed to fund themselves solely through transaction fees, as they partially already do today.
- feet 4y agoIirc miners get the gas fees
- Lerc 4y agoThe mining reward is not supposed to be the end state of the system. It is a subsidy, reducing over time, to get the system established. Once established, the idea is that transaction fees are used and the distributed nature of the network causes a natural competition to be the most efficient so miners can charge the lowest fees while making a profit.
- tim333 4y agoI guess it's a different scenario but if all the existing miners were turned off today, there is nothing to stop me running the open source bitcoin software on a spare computer myself the day after. I guess if you ban that for all time and all places bitcoin would be over.
- feet 4y agoMy impression of the intent of the statement was "disable mining altogether" not "turn off the existing physical mining rigs until someone turns one back on"
- HN_is_for_gemes 4y agoAnd if you turned off all the electricity in the world a lot of companies would go bankrupt. What's the point? It's not going to happen.
- arcticbull 4y ago> You couldn't trade them normally with the miners off but you could start mining up the day after. So if we turn off all the bitcoin miners, it wouldn't be possible to transact. All you could do is look at it, like a read-only excel sheet.
- mr_woozy 4y ago
- snapcaster 4y agoBut you understand why this hasn't happened yet right? if everyone else turned off their miners, I for one would be interested in money and turn one on