3 ms·
I don't know about this one, but there's been at least a couple projects mentioned on HN in the last year or so that I suspected were probably more valuable to
by neilv 4y ago
I don't know about this one, but there's been at least a couple projects mentioned on HN in the last year or so that I suspected were probably more valuable to non-US intel efforts than they were to their ostensible users.
(And one of them appeared to oops while juggling a sockpuppet account on HN to help promote -- which was a little suspicious because that tactic seemed incongruent with the goal they claimed. I suppose, with that project, the non-US intel value could've been intentional. It's much easier to imagine a lot of people being motivated to follow Area 51, just out of curiosity and the mystique, and not seeing any harm in it.)
Which prompts the thought: with all sorts of geopolitical tensions going on right now -- as much as we Internet-age techies can be global citizens who extend fellowship (through HN, open source, research communities, companies, etc.) -- maybe we should try to be aware when actions we are considering doing would stray into delicate global balances that we don't understand. We don't know enough to know everything to avoid, but maybe sometimes we can guess, so it seems worth the occasional thought.
- sneak 4y agoRather than handwavey “geopolitical tensions” excuses, I have decided to universally condemn the US’s escalating and heavyhanded assault on the free exercise of journalism in all cases, from Assange to this and anything in between. If I’m paying for it with my tax money, I should be able to read reporting on what it’s being spent on. This goes doubly so for people doing reporting who have no obligation whatsoever to keep US government secrets. Security through obscurity is not a sound enough principle that resources should be expended and freedoms curtailed to attempt to preserve it.
- sfe22 4y agoSlight correction there, you are not “paying with your tax money” thus expecting something from it. Paying to buy something assumes you willingly committed to the deal and had the option to back out. You did not have such an option so you may not expect or demand something in return for it.
- sneak 4y agoI am always justified in expecting and demanding basic human rights to peaceful free expression and reporting, for myself and others. I’m not (here) saying the USG has a duty to disclose, just that they have a duty to not raid and otherwise persecute journalists. (I also separately think they have a duty to disclose precisely what the tax money is being spent on, but that is a different discussion.)
- sfe22 4y agoSounds like another wish to me. Good to have wishes but the world unfortunately doesn’t run on wishes
- rantingdemon 4y agoWhile I get where you are coming from, realistically speaking we do have to accept the "extortion" that comes with having a governing body. I am happy to hand over my tax Rands (Dollars), provided me and my fellow citizens can benefit from it. The point here is that is in most cases a "de facto" contract between a citizen and his/her government. As this is a contract, the citizen has rights to oversight on how his/her money is being spent.
- sfe22 4y agoThanks for being understanding. Now like I also mentioned below, there is no true contract in reality. Since you need to have leverage to get your reward. The people don’t have much power in this de-facto contract that you mentioned, thus demanding things from the entity that has all the power sounds childish to me.
- antihero 4y ago> maybe we should try to be aware when actions we are considering doing would stray into delicate global balances that we don't understand If they are that fragile they’re hugely susceptible to bad actors and we’re fucked anyway.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- postalrat 4y agoShut down HN, Reddit, etc for the security of the American people!
- neilv 4y agoHere's a hypothetical example of an occasion on which we should ask ourselves whether we want to get into something, closer to home, without involving geopolitics. (And I'm not speaking of this Area 51 thing, but the more general question prompted by some projects.) Let's say some new social networking startup wants to appeal to teens by being edgy/counterculture, and doing automated crowdsourced real-time tracking of local police, as one of the features of their app. (Because casually affecting a hint of teen revolutionary operator, with power over authorities, is easier and more appealing than producing videos of eating laundry detergent.) If people at that startup stopped to consider unintended effects of that, when used by people they don't want to help (burglars, violent criminals, etc.), I think they'd modify or abandon the idea, before very bad things happened.