5 ms·
What’s the real reason you can’t go faster than the speed of light?
- johndoe0815 4y agoAn intriguingly clean and simple explanation - but my knowledge about the Theory of Relativity is not really up to speed to know if this is physically sound. What this article does not explain, however, is why we cannot travel back in time...
- vlovich123 4y agoPeople who actually understand this should definitely correct me. My understanding of the analogy is that your velocity through time would have to cross the 0 point (i.e. positive flow through time, 0, negative flow through time). However, 0 is when you're traveling at the speed of light through space and not traveling at all through time. I'm assuming there's either no energy left in the time direction to push you or something about the 4d geometry makes it impossible because a negative time direction would require somehow inverting all the space in the universe (crossing some infinite asymptote) and that's not physically possible.
- throw7 4y agoOne thing that helped me along is also the explanation that between two points in space, a straight line is the shortest distance. Take a different path and it will always be longer. Now, a straight line between two points in spacetime is the... longest time, which, at least to me, is counter intuitive. (note: i'm far from an expert in relativity)
- yucky 4y agoMy admittedly ignorant take on it is that time moves in one direction, just at varying speed depending on how quickly you move. Much in the same way that distance travelled is always positive, regardless of direction. Traveling back in time would be like traveling a negative distance.
- ml_more 4y agoWeirdly, it seems that the equations for time work in either direction. Questions of causality aside it might be possible to get something to move backwards in time. Probably not anything living though. Or rather not anything you’d like to keep living.
- jfengel 4y agoYou are correct. The equations do work in either direction. Special relativity does not, in itself, forbid you going backwards in time. But it does tell you what would be involved in going backwards in time that way. They involve things like imaginary mass and imaginary energy -- things that pop out of factor sqrt(1-v^2/c^2) when v>c. As far as we can tell, imaginary mass and imaginary energy are nonphysical. Relativity doesn't say it has to be that way, but nobody has ever seen them and they don't seem to exist. There are hints of it in the Standard Model, which define mass and energy in terms of even powers of real numbers. Again, that doesn't prove that other things can't exist, only that we've never seen them, and would expect the universe to look very different if they did exist. It might have something to do with the configuration of the universe at very early times, the low-entropy state that is the reason that the universe is interesting (and, in particular, capable of having us in it). But that is an open question. Meanwhile, special relativity is sufficient to rule out time travel unless you want to make some assumptions that mass and energy are very different from anything we've ever seen them do.
- thinkmcfly 4y agoI'm not a physicist so someone please correct me if I'm wrong. There is no 'past' to return to if you could reverse the arrow of time. I don't think the universe has frames like a video that you can rewind to. Interactions are probabilistic with time going forwards and they would still be probabilistic were time inverted. Source: I listen to podcasts
- BizarroLand 4y agoThe most likely answer is that the past doesn't exist. We're probably riding a "wave" of spacetime and if we are then the rest of the universe is as well. If that is the case, when a moment passes it ceases to exist in the same way that a ripple in a puddle of water does. If you wanted to go backwards in time, you would have to take the whole universe with you.
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agoI wonder if fortune telling is real. Not the tarot kind but using the power of the mind to travel across spacetime and seeing visions is.
- thinkmcfly 4y agoI'd be curious to see the equations that would describe these mechanisms
- jjtheblunt 4y agoMaybe fortune tellers' insight is that it's as real as you believe it to be?
- pencilguin 4y agoNothing in physics forbids information moving backward in time, provided it has no effect on whether the event communicated will happen after it arrives. So, information about an earthquake or asteroid strike, or even a plane crash if you don't prevent it, is fine. You can choose not to get on the plane, based on the information. But if you did stop the plane taking off, what physical event would there be to communicate? That is not to say information does routinely go back, or does just because somebody wants for it to. The universe appears not generally to care what people want. But if any does go back, and organic systems could pick it up, it would be adaptively advantageous to be receptive to it. Again, just because it could happen, in principle, doesn't mean it does. It would depend on some biological structure being just incidentally sensitive to the signal, and then refined by selection. It would be a Rube Goldberg sort of process, but study of parasite lifecycles will cure you of skepticism as to nature's tolerance for dodgy complexity and marginal usefulness.
- dadjoker 4y agoOne time, right in the middle of a job interview, I took out a book and started reading. The guy said, "What the hell are you doing?" I said, "Let me ask you one question; if you were in a vehicle, and you were traveling at the speed of light, and then, you turned your lights on, would they do anything?" He said, "I don't know." I said, "Forget it then, I don't want to work for you." - Steven Wright
- BoGoToTo 4y agoIsn't the correct answer here that you could never be travelling at the speed of light to begin with?
- pkolaczk 4y agoNice explanation. I don't get the problem with traveling to stars though. If I could move at the speed of light through space, then I'd be not moving through time, which means the time to travel anywhere, as measured by me would be exactly zero. So I conclude I could reach the center of our galaxy. Is it correct reasoning? However, the ones that would stay on the Earth would never see me arrive at my destination, as they would have to wait those millions of years. Is it correct? But then another thing I don't understand in this model is the twin paradox. If I returned back to Earth what would be the Earth time and my local time? Would that agree? Or would I arrive millions years in the future?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ml_more 4y agoThink of it from the earth frame of reference. They watch you travel for a million years there and a million years back. When you arrive two million years have passed in the earth frame of reference. You were traveling at some large fraction of the speed of light so from your frame of reference you traveled for a year there and a year back. You age 2 years Earth ages 2 Million years
- hotpotamus 4y ago> I don't get the problem with traveling to stars though. If I could move at the speed of light through space Well, to be a stickler for the laws of physics, you can't move through space at the speed of light. In principal, you can get moving pretty quick though, but what if there's a space pebble between you and those stars? If you're going at half the speed of light, the collision force would be in the atomic bomb range. So that's a potential problem.
- vc8f6vVV 4y agoIf a large pebble (or a large piece of space junk) collides with ISS at 16 km/s ISS will be destroyed. That doesn't prevent ISS for being where it is though.
- vc8f6vVV 4y ago> When Einstein’s theory was pushed harder, what was revealed was that every object travels through spacetime at a single speed — the speed of light. Nope, don't push it that hard. Four-velocity is a nice mathematical abstraction, but has nothing to do with "speed" and "travels" as we know them.