2 ms·
Half of the text in the article feels like whining that someone followed the laws, in many cases (Roth conversions) paid their taxes early and then, in direct e
by sokoloff 4y ago
Half of the text in the article feels like whining that someone followed the laws, in many cases (Roth conversions) paid their taxes early and then, in direct exchange, got tax-free treatment on withdrawals.
Imagine a series of multiplications, one of them being 0.80 to the taxpayer and the other 0.20 to the government. Then a series of transactions multiplies that account value by a value less than 1 (for losing investments) or greater than 1 (for winning investments).
Multiplication is commutative. Whether the 0.20 to the government is paid at the start or the end, it seems fair to me. The fact that the government got their money early and did not invest it as well as the Roth account holder is not a tax policy concern in my view.
For every case where a taxpayer invested well and won big, there are thousands of people who made a Roth conversion, paying taxes at that moment, and made investments that went to zero. In those cases, the government got paid more taxes than they’d have gotten without the Roth conversion.