6 ms·
Title should be “US leaders passed legislation that allowed for limitless future tax free earnings if redeemed after age 59.5”. Propublica does good work, but
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
Title should be “US leaders passed legislation that allowed for limitless future tax free earnings if redeemed after age 59.5”.
Propublica does good work, but they reduce their credibility when they put out clickbait to induce rage at a single person playing by the rules. Guess it is easier to get people riled up against one “evil” person than the myriad representatives the populace voted for.
- jrochkind1 4y agoI mean, I agree, and think the law should be changed to have some limits, but I wouldn't have enough info to think the law should be changed if I didn't know specific details about how some individuals are using it. (Also, what this article only briefly touched upon but others get into more details of -- the way people like this get hundreds of MM in IRAs is by buying early stage stakes that aren't generally available to the public at "pennies per share". Banning these from IRAs would be one way to end this sort of thing).
- lotsofpulp 4y ago>the way people like this get hundreds of MM in IRAs is by buying early stage stakes that aren't generally available to the public at "pennies per share". Banning these from IRAs would be one way to end this sort of thing). They are pennies per share because they are huge gambles worth approximately nothing right now. Anyone can make their own LLC and contribute the max equity into their IRA right now. It just does not make sense for most since it will probably perform worse than buying SP500.
- jrochkind1 4y agoIf it's such a gamble, how do these already really wealthy people wind up with hundreds of millions in their IRAs? There was an article about how it's pretty typical for the mega wealthy. They would seem to have access to something others don't. Anyway I'd say turning $6000/year into hundreds of millions or billions tax-free is not the policy purpose of a Roth IRA.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI don’t think that’s right. Thiel acquired all this money in his Roth IRA by directing his venture investments through it. You need money to make venture investments, and he got the money in his Roth by putting tons of PayPal stock in there. Now the rule is that you can only contribute $6,000 a year to the account, less back then, but thiel put huge amounts of stock in. This all happened pretty much the day before they took millions in funding which would’ve made his stock too valuable to put in the Roth. Imo that is fraud. He knew the stock was worth more than the limit and he still put it in the account. But since the value wasn’t officially set until the next week it’s too much of a hassle to prove that he mispriced the stock to the irs. The government should still come after him for fraudulently misvaluing his company if the statute of limitations hasn’t expired. There is no chance Peter would’ve sold that stock to investors for whatever the Roth limit was.
- andsoitis 4y agoI think it can be effective to put a face, so to speak, to an issue to show it isn’t some abstract problem and to also show the degree to which it is a problem.
- djbebs 4y agoPeople keeping their things is not a problem.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThe wording the article uses is intended to cause outrage at specific people, instead of the badly worded rules and/or the motivations of the people who enacted the rules. > Yet, from the start, a small number of entrepreneurs, like Thiel, made an end run around the rules: Open a Roth with $2,000 or less. Get a sweetheart deal to buy a stake in a startup that has a good chance of one day exploding in value. Pay just fractions of a penny per share, a price low enough to buy huge numbers of shares. Watch as all the gains on that stock — no matter how giant — are shielded from taxes forever, as long as the IRA remains untouched until age 59 and a half. Then use the proceeds, still inside the Roth, to make other investments. I wonder how the author determined PayPal had a “good chance of exploding in value”? Can they predict the future? Or is it using hindsight to make things seem less risky than they were. Would you recommend a young person today to max out their Roth contribution with the equity of a startup they are working on? The article also does not mention any of the downsides of Roth accounts.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoThe author determined that because their was negotiating a venture deal when he put the stock in his ira. He knew it was worth many times more than he claimed because he was about to be given that valuation by investors.
- andsoitis 4y ago> The wording the article uses is intended to cause outrage at specific people, instead of the badly worded rules and/or the motivations of the people who enacted the rules. They also talk about the system, how it came to be, etc., for example: “About a decade after the creation of the Roth, Congress made it even easier to turn the accounts into mammoth tax shelters.” > Would you recommend a young person today to max out their Roth contribution with the equity of a startup they are working on? In some sense, one could view the detailed reporting as a guidebook for how anyone can do this too!
- z9znz 4y ago> myriad representatives the populace voted for Unfortunately there is not much "myriad" in the candidate choices. To even reach a level of opportunity to compete in an election means to already sell out to some special interests. It just costs too much money to run with any hope of getting elected. Both parties in the US cater to wealthy supporters, whether those supporters are actual humans, corporations as humans, or PACs. Those who want to protect their wealth spend a lot of money to ensure that all likely candidates will make or modify rules that benefit them. It is very reasonable for us to direct our ire toward the wealthy individuals who make very public efforts to affect policies (very selfishly). And with the recent tally of $880 million spent by billionaires on the recent midterm elections, it's even more clear where we should direct our attention.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> It is very reasonable for us to direct our ire toward the wealthy individuals who make very public efforts to affect policies (very selfishly) Sure, but how does that apply in this case? Roth account legislation was passed in 1997, and PayPal was started in Dec 1998.
- z9znz 4y agoIt doesn't really apply to TFA example, but that doesn't mean that there are not numerous (intentional) holes in the tax system which are designed to prevent wealthy people from having to give some back. There are so many ways to avoid paying taxes if you are wealthy, only a few of which have been publicized (Warren Buffett vs secretary, Mitt Romney and the Bain Capital leak, Panama Papers revelations, etc.) Regular people don't have those options; and a vastly greater percentage of their income (which is directly taxed already) goes into local taxes on gas, essentials, and any luxury purchases. When we see another reminder of how unfair these systems are, and we know that their design comes from the people who benefit from them (like Thiel), it is reasonable to direct our ire toward them. And finally, this doesn't even touch on the overt criminal tax avoidance that is well known to persist amongst this group. The Swiss bank leaks exposed some of these, and the US tax amnesty programs have further illustrated it. Even so, there's surely a lot more money hiding away that has not and never will be taxed.
- atonse 4y agoI hate Peter Thiel with a vengeance but had the same reaction as you. This article was a nothingburger. Alternate headline: “man wins lottery with Roth investments and has to pay no taxes” Unlike many tax shelters and other billionaire only toys, this Roth stuff is accessible to literally everyone. If I had put in $5k of Roth money every year into Apple stock I similarly would’ve minted money.
- vsareto 4y agoThere's two things I find worth considering as maybe-wrong: 1) non-public investment opportunities in combination with tax-free status 2) no sanity threshold to collect some taxes after your Roth balance becomes large enough 1 is maybe a violation of the spirit of what a Roth was designed to be used for. You should be able to invest (cash only would be dumb), but you shouldn't get tax free returns for every kind of investment you make. Public shares might be tax free, but using the Roth for venture capital or private investing seems a little wrong. 2 is just silly to me, and I blame lawmakers for that. No one needs $5b tax free, especially since you can't ever reach that with contribution limits.
- garyrichardson 4y agoIn Canada we have something called the "Tax Free Savings Account" which functions in a very similar manner. EXCEPT when the CRA started figuring out people were using it for private assets, like non-public company shares, they changed the rules.
- tootie 4y agoIt's one thing to say "a potential loophole exists" to "someone has successfully exploited the loophole on a massive scale already".
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAnd it is yet another thing to say “in 1999, someone gambled $2k worth of equity and got lucky it grew to be worth a few billion 22 years in the future.”
- graphpapa 4y agoI think it’s still worth being critical of individuals even if they follow all the rules. The super rich have the largest influence on society as a whole. They cast a vote on the status quo by endorsing anti-social policies with their actions. Just because something is legal doesn’t make it right. I’m not arguing any particular consequences etc. whatever. I also agree that ‘news’ which emphasises a misleading causality is not helpful. Nevertheless, the super rich ‘legally’ avoiding the proportional contribution to society nominally expected of them _because they can_ is still anti-social behaviour and however the laws came to be is irrelevant in my opinion. Democracy is so flawed especially at the individual policy level I consider the argument that ‘the populace voted for this’ conservative in the worst most nebulous way, defending the status quo for no reason other than it is the status quo. Of course policies that protect the super rich are beyond the normal reach of democracy because lobbying and donations are so prevalent. Do we approve of this behaviour in a normative sense? That seems like a more important thing to keep in mind than if individual’s playing of the game is technically above board. Or how the rules came about. To me the details of the case amount to details of a symptom and what is of more interest is the underlying condition which is revealed. FWIW I don’t know the details of the case I’m just trying to nudge the discourse in a direction I find more interesting.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Nevertheless, the super rich ‘legally’ avoiding the proportional contribution to society nominally expected of them _because they can_ is still anti-social behaviour and however the laws came to be is irrelevant in my opinion. Why do you put legally in quotes? Is it because you think there was zero downside risk to maxing out a Roth contribution with start up stock? The article conveniently leaves out all the possible downsides. Seems like the problem is wealth inequality, and going after people who follow the rules (that they had no part in influencing) is a waste of time, and reduced quality of discourse due to decrease in trust.
- graphpapa 4y agoI’m not saying anyone should go after them. They followed the rules, how do you go after someone who followed the rules? I’m just saying that it’s still okay to condemn (just as an act of casting judgement) rule following when it’s anti social and the question of what sort of society we would like to live in is the more prescient point to bare in mind. I put legally in quotes because I think legality is an unsound basis for reasoning about whether something is normatively okay or not okay.
- ramraj07 4y agoThey have identified that Blood Boy Man’s Roth alone is twice the size of his previously publicly estimated net worth. And through a tax loophole most normal people have no way of using. And clearly this wasn’t a deliberate loophole , it just got exploited into one. This seems like a good substantial article to me. I’m just curious if there are people here trying to indirectly undermine criticizing our “democracy is untenable” leader here, just like PG is shilling for Elon or Dave Chappelle is asking us to forgive Kanye. Keep moving the Overton window saying they al did nothing wrong it’s the system that’s broken, is that your message?
- lotsofpulp 4y ago>And through a tax loophole most normal people have no way of using. Source? As far as I know, everyone can contribute to a Roth retirement savings account. >And clearly this wasn’t a deliberate loophole , it just got exploited into one. Are you suggesting Thiel, in 1999, knew for a fact that his $2k worth of Paypal equity, would be worth far more in 2022? In which case, the fair market value of the equity would not have been $2k, and hence Thiel committed fraud?
- ramraj07 4y agoI really don’t understand why so many people here are so hell bent on supporting disgustingly rich people exploiting every loophole like this. Surely you see this is wrong on a moral level? No one asked here to jail him, just to close the loophole.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI also agree on implementing measures to reduce wealth inequality, such as higher marginal income/marginal sales/wealth/estate taxes. But I disagree on mischaracterizing someone’s actions to paint them in a bad light to advance a political cause.
- atdrummond 4y agoThe post you’re a replying to is referring to most Americans’ inability to participate in the very first funding rounds of nascent startups. The other part of the equation is the investment vehicle itself, which as you point out is available to all Americans below a certain income.