4 ms·
Yeah, a chemical cycle involving vaporizing and decomposing sulfuric acid at 850 C is totally credible. Yes, let's avoid turbines and instead make our equipmen
by pfdietz 4y ago
Yeah, a chemical cycle involving vaporizing and decomposing sulfuric acid at 850 C is totally credible. Yes, let's avoid turbines and instead make our equipment out of ... tantalum? /s
The maximum thermodynamic efficiency of this cycle is 50% (and likely will be lower). This is not much better than making electricity with the reactor and driving electrolysers. And when the levelized cost of energy from renewables is very low (especially for the surplus energy that could be fed into electrolysers as needed) it's hard to see how this scheme competes. Yes, it doesn't have turbines, but it does have all sorts of high temperature chemical reactors that must survive corrosive conditions.
- nickpinkston 4y agoI think the point is that we should try a lot of different approaches, as there may be good fits that aren't possible to do via electricity - ie is electro smelting iron > using hydrogen? Unsure we really know what that looks like at scale yet. Either way there's an unproven process step with lots of efficiency questions for plants at scale, and I'm impressed to see Japan seriously trying something totally different.
- anotherbadlogin 4y ago
- scythe 4y ago>The maximum thermodynamic efficiency of this cycle is 50% (and likely will be lower). This is not much better than making electricity with the reactor and driving electrolysers. The numbers I've found elsewhere dispute this. The World Nuclear Association puts the thermal -> electric conversion efficiency of nuclear plants at around 35% (current) to 40% (best) [1]. A similar but far less corrosive copper-chlorine process is being developed in Canada with preliminary analyses claiming as much as double the efficiency of electrolysis [2]. The maximum thermodynamic efficiency may also be exceeded if waste heat can be converted to electricity simultaneously. With that said, tests of the sulfur-iodine process continue to find that corrosion and damage to the (chemical) reactor components remains limiting, with 20% efficiency lost in H2SO4 splitting over just four days [3]. H2SO4 at 900 C is much more corrosive than HCl at 500 C. 1: https://world-nuclear.org/our-association/publications/technical-positions/cooling-of-power-plants.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/our-association/publications/techn... 2: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360319922043555 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036031992... 3: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364032117309231 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S136403211...
- pfdietz 4y agoBeing twice the efficiency of electrolysis with nuclear is not enough, because the levelized cost of electricity ratio between nuclear and renewables is more than 2 (and even more so the ratio between nuclear and surplus renewable output.)
- scythe 4y agoLooking at the solar generation LCoE alone, you're correct. The numbers I found for battery LCoE are all over the place, which makes it hard to judge. Assuming $100/kWh and a cycle life of 1000 (close to existing batteries), battery LCoE is high enough to justify nuclear-to-hydrogen. With longer cycle life, which has gone up to 10,000 cycles at lab-scale, that number comes down substantially. Assuming technology improvements, of course, would also have to be applied to nuclear. I was originally interested in thermochemical hydrogen for a solar concentrator source, but a lot of current research seems to focus on nuclear because the thermal energy input is more stable, with an outlook towards solar as the technology is worked out.
- pfdietz 4y agoA life cycle of 1000 is very short, and I don't think it's reasonable to expect that for currently installed batteries. I understand current utility scale batteries are shooting for an eight year lifespan (3000 cycles) with the hope of getting to 10-15 years (but data is lacking to justify that.) Longer cycle life should be proved by the time any nuclear thermochemical hydrogen system could be up and running.
- jandrese 4y agoAssuming a daily charge/discharge a 1000 cycle battery needs to be replaced every 3 years. That would suggest that the majority of installers that guarantee the batteries for 10-15 years are going to lose their shirt on warranty replacements.
- 4y ago