4 ms·
Electrified marine transport is an interesting challenge, though there are a few options available. Notably, canal and river traffic can rely on electric tract
by dredmorbius 4y ago
Electrified marine transport is an interesting challenge, though there are a few options available.
Notably, canal and river traffic can rely on electric traction provided by onshore "mules".
That terminology is borrowed from the original practice of having mules haul barges along canals, and reveals the immense enhancement in efficiency of water-borne transport. A single mule might haul a cart weighing a tonne or so across level land (and far less climbing any sort of grade). The same mule could haul a barge on a flat and still canal carrying 20--40 tonnes of cargo or passengers.
For passengers, the comfort of canal travel (no jostles, bumps, or broken axles as with a coach) was an immense improvement. The effect of the Erie Canal, a four-foot-deep (1.2 m) ditch from the Hudson river to Lake Erie was immense in opening up the US interior in 1825. Further, canals and their locks mean that the work of lifting (or lowering) cargo is done by the "roadbed) (the river) itself. In the case of the Erie Canal, 172m (565 ft) of elevation gain in net.
- js2 4y agoThis is the origin of the term towpath: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Towpath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Towpath
- azepoi 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chain_boat_navigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chain_boat_navigation Not a new idea: Chevaux électriques, meaning "Electric horses" (electric towpath tractors, halage=tow). https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treideln#/media/Datei:Courchelettes_chevaux-electriques.jpg https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treideln#/media/Datei:Courchel... https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treidellokomotive https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treidellokomotive http://ronfleur.centerblog.net/6408563-halage-des-peniches-par-traction-electrique http://ronfleur.centerblog.net/6408563-halage-des-peniches-p... https://www.ronquieres.org/le-village-de-ronquieres/vieilles-photos-du-village/le-halage-des-bateaux/ https://www.ronquieres.org/le-village-de-ronquieres/vieilles... (last image bottom right) http://www.traitsensavoie.fr/spip.php?article308 http://www.traitsensavoie.fr/spip.php?article308 http://www.traitsensavoie.fr/IMG/jpg/cheval_electrique_bethune-2.jpg http://www.traitsensavoie.fr/IMG/jpg/cheval_electrique_bethu... http://papidema.fr/traction_vn_extra.php#chevaux-elec http://papidema.fr/traction_vn_extra.php#chevaux-elec
- dredmorbius 4y agoNot a new idea... FWIW: I wasn't claiming that.
- azepoi 4y agoFWIWI wasn't claiming the contrary juste expanding with something I thought interesting. Replies are also intended for everybody else on HN.
- dredmorbius 4y agoFair enough, and strongly agreed on the last.
- Forgeties79 4y agoNo need to “well actually…” someone just for discussing something interesting
- dredmorbius 4y ago"Yes, and ..." is a wonderful notion from the world of improv: <https://www.liveabout.com/yes-and-improv-game-2713213 https://www.liveabout.com/yes-and-improv-game-2713213> It contrasts with "no, but", most often, though also "well, actually", as you note. (This is of course a "yes, and ..." comment. ;-) And thank you.
- Forgeties79 4y agoI love this, never thought to apply it in that way. Thanks!
- azepoi 4y agoSo I think it's interesting we had these at the end of the 19th century. Battery electric automobiles were also invented really early. It doesn't mean it's a bad idea unless you have a bias for new things
- Someone 4y ago> That terminology is borrowed from the original practice of having mules haul barges along canals The Panama Canal has mechanical mules, but they are only used to keep ships on course, not to propel ships (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Canal_locks#Mules https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Canal_locks#Mules) Disadvantages of towing are that it requires a towpath alongside the water, that overtaking is difficult, and that making tight turns can be difficult (the puller always pulls the ship closer to the canal or river shore, requiring the use of the ship’s rudder to keep it on track. In tight turns, the pull direction is closer to orthogonal to the shore, requiring more rudder) Because of these, I think battery-powered ships with container-sized batteries that can easily be swapped may be a better solution.
- usrusr 4y agoIf you could supply the mules like electric trains are supplied, you might just as well replace the powerful mules with lightweight power pickup runners that the boats connect to with a cord. Boats would only need a few minutes of battery power for situations that aren't as easy as running straight along the canal.
- taneq 4y agoAt that stage, just have overhead power lines for the boats… might spoil the scenery a bit though.
- cjrp 4y agoExactly, chuck a pantograph on the boat and it’s job done!
- usrusr 4y agoThe difficulty I think is that there aren't many board purpose-built for canals: they are purpose-built for canals and rivers and many navigable rivers are to canals like oceans to the rivers, much wider and unpredictable environment. That also makes that "pickup runner" idea I posted much harder than I first thought, and pulling mules (modern as well as actual). Historical pictures of badge towing show astonishingly long lines, I believe that this is because rivers tend to have wide shallow waters between the part that is deep enough for navigation and the part that is dry enough for a tow-path. The good news is that multimodal boats should work just fine, might even be easy to make the electrified parts support enough autopilot to allow the time to be used below deck for engine maintenance and the like. Barge operation is mostly waiting anyways and getting rid of the last instances of unscheduled interactivity might be really easy (if it hasn't been achieved yet? Primary obstacle is that the market just isn't very big)
- joak 4y agoSmall fusion generators. TAE, helion energy and ZAP energy are 3 well founded companies (combined $1B+) aiming at building ~50MW generators based on non-tokamak fusion. The generators are small enough to fit on a truck and could easily power the biggest container ships.
- dredmorbius 4y agoIf you've got the ability to build fusion generators, you've got the ability to create carbon-neutral analogues of existing fuels. You've also got that ability without nuclear inputs, from conventional renewables (solar, wind, geothermal). Those fuels can be far cleaner than bunker fuel, and a diesel or kerosene analogue burning in a well-tuned ICE or turbine would have limited negative effects. The marine-propulsion pollutants of most significant concern, aside from (fossil) CO2 are particulate, NOx, and SOx emissions. All are far more prevalent with heavier fuels, and are concentrated largely along shipping lanes far out to sea, other than at ports. These tend to settle out / mitigate reasonably quickly, and I believe their long-term ecological impacts are fairly minimal. The problems with nuclear marine propulsion are many, not the least of which are the 100--200 shipwrecks logged every decade or so, though you can add to that risks of piracy or terrorism involving nuclear propulsion. Keep in mind that present commercial fleets are on the order of eight thousand vessels. We've had experience with only about four hundred nuclear-powered vessels, virtually all military ships, of which about 170 are presently operational. The exceptions are three demonstration commercial vessels, the Otto Hahn, Savannah, and Mutsu, all of which failed to prove feasible, and a handful of Soviet-era icebreakers, now operated by Russia. Fusion itself remains both technically and economically infeasable for any foreseeable future. <https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/3c52ll/shipping_and_safety_the_nuclear_option/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/3c52ll/shippin...>
- Schroedingersat 4y agoFor some of the pulsed fusion concepts like helion and zap, they're either very close to technical viability or to finding an unknown (at least by outsiders) deal breaker. I'm much more sceptical on the economic viability. If it's past the edge of possibility with known materials now, there's no reason to think your reactor would suddenly last decades because you made a series kf incremental improvements from needing 10x the energy in as out to sorta do it once to 0.95x
- lasc4r 4y agoI guess that helps explain how the ferry was only using 100 liters of fuel per day. Pretty high hanging fruit for electrification in that respect.