4 ms·
Actually, their experience is pretty pleasant and the product works very well after they have rebuilt their apps. They don’t need to be jealous. Their relative
by bayindirh 4y ago
Actually, their experience is pretty pleasant and the product works very well after they have rebuilt their apps.
They don’t need to be jealous. Their relative utilitarian take on the matter is what makes them so unique and powerful in the market.
Yes, I love markdown, and Evernote just provides a slightly more powerful, WYSIWYG version of it. I neither want “everything and the kitchen sink” vision of Notion, and desktop centric view of Obsidian.
Ulysses and Bear are Apple first systems, and while I use Apple mobile devices, my ecosystem is much more varied, and Evernote accommodates all, with feature parity.
They are good and understated. Hope that I won’t need to move out after that acquisition.
- throwaway675309 4y agoA "Relative utilitarian take" is not how it would describe a product that tried to incorporate an entire chat app into it. They had a relatively good product around v5X series and I left because they just started to fragment and add more and more non-notetaking related things at the expense of the entire product stability and core functionality.
- bayindirh 4y agoThey tried to be “everything and the kitchen sink for the enterprise”, and failed, not because of the features they added, but feature disparity between platforms, and some reliability problems. I was doing my Ph.D. when they debuted chat, and it was useful. Similarly, I miss their presentation mode for the notes. It was extremely useful, and the output was very pretty, too. However, after the CEO change and rebuild, they really found themselves. I’m a pro subscriber, and the value they add into my life is immeasurable.
- rurp 4y ago> Their relative utilitarian take on the matter is what makes them so unique and powerful in the market. Man this was not my experience at all. Granted I dropped Evernote quite a while ago, but for years they kept adding a kitchen sink of features that I didn't care about, while regressing at the basics like syncing and merging text notes across multiple devices. They were maybe first company I experienced that blew up a really solid app I liked after raising a truck load of VC money and trying to take over the world.
- johnmw 4y agoI hope you are taking notes, Dropbox.
- bayindirh 4y agoI’m talking about their current iteration and roadmap so far. Previous iteration had its fair share of issues, I concur.
- codalan 4y agoThe previous issues were bad enough for me to drop Evernote as a paying customer. I would get notes that would not sync correctly, forcing me to resolve it by hand. Even after doing that, it would still have sync conflicts. This was core functionality that just didn't work. During this time, they were busy jamming in features I definitely didn't want or need. Every release would be a slower, buggier version of its previous incarnation. It was during this time frame that a lot of people jumped ship. The app was so bloated and buggy by that point that even OneNote seemed like a viable option. It didn't help that Evernote made it as difficult as possible to get your notes out of their system. It took several download attempts to successfully get my archive out of there. It might have also been due to the large number of people leaving their platform. The handwriting was on the wall when they started selling knick-knacks on their website. Things like Evernote branded Moleskine notepads and dress socks. It's like they completely abandoned their core competency and went off in some left-field marketing direction. It's a real shame, too, because Evernote was an amazing app when it first came out. I'm giving org-mode a spin these days on my desktop. Need to figure out if there's a way to sync/view it on my Android device, but I'm getting kind of tired of dealing with all the different, proprietary SaaS note taking services that go to shit after a few years. At least with Emacs and org-mode, that's one less thing to deal with.
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoI really, really want to know what kind of person sees a pair of socks with a productivity app logo on them and thinks "I need these in my life."
- ace2358 4y agoThanks for sharing your take. I dropped Evernote years and years ago. Like iPad 2 long ago. I feel like they were some of the early subscription services and probably copped a lot of my rage about it. I still hate subscription fees. I would prefer to pay for my storage (or host my own) and have apps use my cloud backend. Every app running cloud server to sync all sorts of things has become too much for me. I still rock 1Password 7 and use iCloud sync. I’d pay for the app but it’s free. I pay for iCloud storage. Anyway I might give there new apps a look.
- bayindirh 4y agoI'm also generally on the same boat with you. I'd rather pay for the infrastructure and deploy my own tools on top of that, however with the features some applications provide, it becomes either impossible to replace them, or the time required for maintaining them becomes too much for my life. People say "Installing your own servers is cool, why don't you do that?". I do that, but for small things. At work, I have a fleet of servers, and managing them is enough. After being able to play with cutting edge stuff, renting a VPS from DO and putting stuff on top of it is neither fun, nor satisfying. Instead, I diligently select and use services, and offload maintenance of such systems to the provider. Of course I take my backups and take my precautions, but I don't want to manage every service I use. I personally don't like subscription services mostly, but some subscriptions provide real services which I see worthy, and I happily pay for them. Evernote is one of them.
- malermeister 4y ago> Ulysses and Bear are Apple first systems, and while I use Apple mobile devices, my ecosystem is much more varied, and Evernote accommodates all, with feature parity. I think you can add Craft to that list. Too bad, they all look nice, but I've completely left the Apple ecosystem. If they don't have Android and Linux desktop apps, they don't really compete for the same market
- zaptheimpaler 4y agoYes, I thought I was going nuts after seeing all the negative comments about Evernote here. Personally, I started using Evernote seriously only a month ago after several years, and recently trying pretty much everything else (notion, obsidian, joplin, workflowy and 10s more..). So I don't have any of the baggage from whatever mistakes they made years ago. It's been awesome. Very wide featureset like more than just markdown, web clipping, auto scanning & OCR, sketching support on iPad, tags and fully cross platform. I found every other application to fall short somewhere and just be too opinionated. Evernote is solid and powerful enough to support almost every usecase I have but not opinionated.
- pqs 4y agoI wonder if this backslash is based on reality or not. I mean, what is gonna happen? Maybe these guys are able to solve the technical problems that Evernote has been having. Maybe the product, which now works well on desktop, but slow on mobile, improves and they just sustain it without increasing prices. But it may also happen that they try to squeeze every penny from Evernote before dumping it into the trash. Who knows!
- bayindirh 4y agoI think many people have burnt by the old Evernote. I've also almost stopped using them, and their new apps saved me as a customer. Since many of the people who despised of Evernote never tried their new apps, and doesn't know what changed and how it works now. It's still not perfect, and based on Electron, yet it's leaps and bounds better when compared to yesteryear, and it really works well for my case. I think we need to see where it's going to go. As I said elsewhere, I don't want to abandon them when thinking how I use them, and hope that they don't do some drastic changes. I'm considering as this hasn't happened, until the new changes start to rollout.
- pqs 4y agoYour position is wise. I'll do the same, but with one difference. I'll stop using Tasks. I love it, but tasks are not exportable by tools like Yarle. So, to avoid the lock in I will switch to Microsoft ToDo for tasks and I will continue to use Evernote for the rest.
- wyclif 4y agoYou know what, though? I've had a better experience with Obsidian because it's desktop centric. Trying hard not to be anecdotal, but I can't think of anybody I know that uses a note taking app that enjoys taking notes on a mobile device.
- bayindirh 4y ago> Trying hard not to be anecdotal, but I can't think of anybody I know that uses a note taking app that enjoys taking notes on a mobile device. And having this view is OK and valid. On the other hand, I tend to use Evernote a lot on my mobile device, mostly in read-only mode. I keep a lot of technical documents and cheat sheets I've written and sometimes need them while only having my mobile device with me, and it saves a lot of time. I also scan hand-written notes for later digitizing them, and Evernote OCRs them at the background, saving me time in the process. It's definitely a horses for courses issue, and if Obsidian works for you, go ahead, use it with its full potential.