6 ms·
What do others here think about casual use of the word "crazy" in a work setting. For instance, "that's a crazy idea" or "they're crazy to think ...."
by andsoitis 4y ago
What do others here think about casual use of the word "crazy" in a work setting. For instance, "that's a crazy idea" or "they're crazy to think ...."
- alexb_ 4y agoI think it's crazy that we spend time thinking about minor bs like this instead of spending that effort trying to solve actual problems. This type of stuff is great for people who want to feel like they have made a positive change without actually having accomplished anything of value.
- jamesrcole 4y agoI think it’s worse than that. It makes people have to police their own thought about what they’re going to say, to avoid stumbling over one of the linguistic trip wires. I think that’s antithetical to creative thought.
- whythre 4y agoIt also gives power to bad actors who can take advantage of such ‘linguistic tripwires’ to invalidate or abuse others.
- scubbo 4y agoCounterpoint - mindfully reviewing and examining your thoughts and speech is an effective way to improve clarity and to identify unexamined (and perhaps unfounded) assumptions.
- poszlem 4y agoCool, as long as it's your thoughts and not mine. I have no problem with other people policing their own speech and thoughts. My problem starts when they start to enforce what they found on other people.
- scubbo 4y agoDo you recognize that there is a distinction between enforcement, and being told "using this particular form of speech is harmful to certain people - if you continue choosing to use it, you are choosing to present yourself as someone who values your own speech over someone else's comfort, and will be judged accordingly"? If so, then we're in broad agreement (though we may disagree about where the line between social judgement and enforcement lies)
- andsoitis 4y agoI was with you earlier in the thread when you wrote "effective way to improve clarity and to identify unexamined (and perhaps unfounded) assumptions". With you on that because that is ultimately a selfish motivation - one wants one's ideas to be understood, one wants to influence, one wants to be correct ("check assumptions"). But this: > using this particular form of speech is harmful to certain people ... are a few bridges too far in my mind. Who are these certain people? What do they think, not you? For instance, I'm gay, and homophobic slurs happen all the time in my life, whether coded or overt. But they don't harm me in any reasonable sense of the word. I mean, should we not distinguish between physical harm, mental abuse, and discomfort with words? To put a fine point on it, equating "discomfort" and "harm" is flawed.
- scubbo 4y ago> To put a fine point on it, equating "discomfort" and "harm" is flawed. That's fair! Negative impacts certainly exist on a continuum! I felt like "harm" was a reasonable synonym for "negatively impact", but you're right that it carries a stronger connotation than "mildly inconvenience"; and it also has a more direct connotation than "perpetuate negative stereotypes in listeners" (using homophobic slurs has negative impact _even if no homosexual people are around to hear them_, because it emboldens homophobes and normalizes homophobia) So let me loosen my original statement to "using this particular form of speech will negatively impact (whether directly or indirectly) certain people, ...etc.". And please do notice that I didn't describe the outcome as "then you are a bad person"! It's reasonable and justifiable to pick a point on that spectrum and say "you know what - negative impacts that are weaker than this just really don't matter to me. There's a certain level of tip-toeing around that just isn't worth it for the miniscule risk". Hell, I do it too. There's a tiny chance that my use of "hell" as a casual interjection might offend a religious reader - but in my determination, that offence is less important to me than that particular form of speech. There are probably a ton of other words or phrases I use for which I've made a similar (conscious or unconscious) determination. My point is - speech has an impact. Indeed, if it didn't, it would be pointless. The point of speech is to communicate. Communication distributes ideas, concepts, thoughts from one brain to others. Those ideas will not just be the ones that are directly communicated in the speech, but also "meta-ideas" communicated by the form of speech. Meta-communication, more often than not, is about the speaker rather than just the content. If I hear someone teaching a complicated topic, I will assume (rightly or wrongly!) something about their level of intelligence and knowledge. If I hear someone speaking clearly and convincingly, I will assume that they've taken the time to prepare and research - and vice versa. If I hear someone using an obscure word, I'll assume they have an interest in vocabulary (and/or are involved in the field in which that term is common). If I hear someone using a well-known slur, I'll assume that they have made the deliberate choice to do so in the knowledge that it _is_ a slur. It's a form of social signalling. So, y'know - if you believe that forms of speech that do cause "discomfort" are acceptable, and ones that cause "harm" are not (based on your own determination of the likelihood of those impacts, hopefully informed by the people who are actually impacted), _that's justifiable_. I'm not saying that words should be banned. I'm asking for a recognition that the use of a word - _any_ word - is a signal; that some signals are more distinct than others; and that that signal will be interpreted by listeners as reflecting something about the speaker's value system. That's not policing - it's a recognition of personal choice.
- Barrin92 4y agobeing precise in your language is of great value, both when it comes to thinking and communicating. Per Wittgenstein, "the limits of my language mean the limits of my world". If you're a software developer you should be familiar with how important syntactic precision is. Someone who runs around the office and complains about everything being 'so crazy' is genuinely not articulating anything meaningful but just ranting. And it's quite amazing how many people can't tell the difference between a rant and a productive argument. Perceiving this as 'policing' is just an excuse to not putting an effort into what you think and say.
- alexb_ 4y agoOkay, but sometimes things are so crazy.
- DonHopkins 4y agoCrazy Eddie really was criminally insane!!! 80s Commercial | Crazy Eddie | 1985 | 1986 | 1987 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ml6S2yiuSWE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ml6S2yiuSWE The Biggest Retail Fraud In American History - Masterminds - Crazy Eddie - Eddie Antar Documentary https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ws9PGROHZzg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ws9PGROHZzg
- raxxorraxor 4y ago"limits of my language mean the limits of my world". The arguments to replace certain words would do the opposite though. On the other hand, sometimes expression is not too important to transport a point.
- sithadmin 4y agoAside from the communicative value, there's a socio-political angle to it as well. Speaking in nebulous terms like calling things 'crazy' without sufficient elaboration is a great way to alienate people as a new-to-the-org resource or as an embedded outsider (e.g. consultant).
- eckza 4y ago`git pull origin main`
- khazhoux 4y ago> I think it's crazy that we spend time thinking about minor bs like this instead of spending that effort trying to solve actual problems. False dichotomy. We all (you included) already spend plenty of time thinking about "minor bs". A discussion about language will probably use up less time in your week than you spent deciding what to get for lunch. Personally I don't have any problem with the word "crazy"... but I don't mind thinking about it for a minute.
- orangepurple 4y agoContemplating this is bikeshedding
- idlewords 4y agoBikeshedding needs to go on the HN list of terms to avoid
- mc32 4y agoI have no issue with it. My only caveat is I would refrain from using it around someone who is "unstable". I don't look forward to prescriptive definitions, grammars and usage. I will use those for technical writing and use "style guides" but not for casual communication and conversation.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI think it's not great, especially because psychosis, bipolar, personality disorders, etc. collectively make up enough of the population that almost certainly one is speaking it in the company of people who would be called "crazy". But also it's in way more ubiquitous use than "retarded" so its a far bigger hill to climb and probably not worth the teeth-pulling until we can at least stop with OCD, ADHD-squirrel, and other jokes first.
- ebiester 4y agoRegardless of "wokism," it might stop meaning from being transmitted to those who do find the term problematic. Absurd or ridiculous both capture the same meaning without losing precision. And at this point, we can look at it more as a function of deprecated terminology - people don't listen to you and think you're a bad person if you use said terminology, they just think you're old. However, to be clear, this is off-topic for the article at hand.
- yamtaddle 4y agoWorrying about something as mild as "crazy" is really, really niche. Maybe that'll change, but for 99% or more of the not-terminally-online crowd, nobody thinks a thing of it today. Even more so outside the US. I, for one, am overall skeptical that being very concerned about people using any term relating to a human malady or misfortune figuratively is a trend that will continue to flourish even to the extent that it has so far.
- croisillon 4y agoi've seen "a crazy idea" replaced by "a wild idea" and i think it's elegant
- kubanczyk 4y agoIn all seriousness, it makes me stop and think what would the hunter-gatherers say.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoIf that is a challange to you, you might be directly affected? Although English isn't my native tongue and I learned it on the internet. I might be resilient...
- LAC-Tech 4y agoI think I'm tired of constantly worrying if what I say naturally is becoming yet another "thing I can't say among my betters without them looking down on me". Is there a list I can subscribe to?
- khazhoux 4y agoI don't have any problem with the word per se (it doesn't evoke any connection with mental health, if that's where you're going with it). But... it's a dumb and unnecessary word, in the contexts you mention. When I'm at a meeting and someone says "I'm going to propose a crazy idea" I always think "Just get on with it, man, no need to tamp down expectations."
- bvirb 4y agoI can certainly see why someone with a history of being called crazy for whatever reason might be hurt when someone at works casually calls them "crazy" for something, even if they understand it was meant differently in that context. I think once you know something might accidentally upset someone it's up to you to decide whether you want to take that chance. I try to avoid taking that chance where possible, I really don't like the idea of accidentally hurting someone. I can also see why people are upset about their language being policed. I imagine every generation feels this way as society changes around them. I'm sure there are lots of examples of probably silly things we've policed ourselves out of saying that probably didn't amount to much, but I'm also happy we mostly don't use the pervasive casual racism of the 50's, or the pervasive casual homophobia of when I was kid.
- poszlem 4y agoIt's the same as with other words, including the some of the "x-words" (the n-word, c-word, f-word, p-word, and whatever else Americans came up with). They should all be possible to write and utter as long as they are not written and uttered as a slur. Saying that "something is crazy" doesn't really victimize anybody. Intention should matter much more than it currently does. I really hope we are at the point where the pendulum swings back to the place where people understand that again.