7 ms·
If SOPA passes, can lots of people call the financial companies, ad companies and others doing business with the RIAA, MPAA, and so forth, and "allege" that the
by EGreg 15y ago
If SOPA passes, can lots of people call the financial companies, ad companies and others doing business with the RIAA, MPAA, and so forth, and "allege" that they are "facilitating" copyright and trademark infringement. According to the SOPA law as it is now, they will have to be shut down.
At the very least it will tie up the system
Or it might actually show these guys what kind of monster they have brought about ... kind of like Sarcozy's household being disconnected from the internet
http://torrentfreak.com/french-presidents-residence-busted-for-bittorrent-piracy-111215/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter http://torrentfreak.com/french-presidents-residence-busted-f...
http://www.futureofcopyright.com/home/blog-post/2011/10/04/german-politician-violates-own-two-strikes-out-bill.html http://www.futureofcopyright.com/home/blog-post/2011/10/04/g...
But it's OK when THEY do it, right?
However, if there are only foreign sites (registrar is abroad), then I doubt any major sites are hosted there, besides
http://bit.ly http://bit.ly
http://t.co http://t.co
http://youtu.be http://youtu.be
http://goo.gl http://goo.gl
Correct me if I'm wrong, but under the current SOPA, only FOREIGN SITES can have their financials cut off, right? I thought the Operation In Our Sites is able to already seize domain names registered locally. So it seems to me that the SOPA simply adds provisions to censor sites registered abroad, in American DNS only, because their registrar is beyond US jurisdiction.
For example Russians use vkontakte.ru to listen to any song. What would SOPA do about this?
However, YouTube contains lots of uploaded songs and the US government could have seized their domain for a long time already, but didn't.
So I think the threat is more to the purity and security of the worldwide DNS system, as well as to the costs of the ISPs, than it is to social networking sites. At least, I hope. Does SOPA override the DMCA for locally-registered sites, or did Operation In Our Sites just give carte blanche to the government to take out sites?
- msquared 15y ago> However, YouTube contains lots of uploaded songs and the US government could have seized their domain for a long time already, but didn't. Correct me if I'm wrong here, but isn't this what the DMCA safe harbor protection is for? They can't just pull their domain if they are responding in a timely manner to reasonable DMCA takedown requests. Or am I missing a point you're making? Entirely possible. It's 4:55. I'm burnt out.
- EGreg 15y agoI think the point is that they are looking to give greater remedies than DMCA. You would now be able to complain about a website to those doing business with it, and they are supposed to stop doing business with it. If it's foreign, anyway.