5 ms·
Peacetime CEO / Wartime CEO (2011)
- logicalmonster 4y agoNot to make everything about him, but this peacetime/wartime lens of viewing the world is interesting to think about in light of Elon Musk taking over Twitter. You can make a case that part of Twitter's big problem in the last decade or so is that their company has been operating in sort of a relaxed peacetime mode when they really needed to be operating in a wartime frame of mind due to their lack of profitability. Elon's real challenge might be successfully dragging a kicking and screaming company into a focused wartime frame.
- mikkergp 4y agoI think this is certainly true. But my understanding of Twitter - and this may be flawed - was that it was always a mission driven company over a profit driven one. Elon said he wanted to continue that tradition, but with the debt load Twitter is literally in an existential crisis. So this begs the question, can Twitter be successful being “twitter”? My guess is no, Musk can make a lot of money going after video or micropayments, or X or whatever (well this has yet to be seen, My gut says Twitter is in a worse position then anyone realizes when you combine all the factors, but some people work best backed into a corner, and he’s backed by investors with deep pockets) but the free speech public square open forum has to be a passion project. There’s too many constraints otherwise. Ship of Theseus adjacent, when does Twitter stop being “twitter”?
- mschuster91 4y ago> Ship of Theseus adjacent, when does Twitter stop being “twitter”? When the users that people are interested in - politicians, news organizations, certain brand accounts, celebrities - go away. The problem for Twitter is that politicians and celebrities don't really want to hang around on a platform where they have to deal with abusive content all the time.
- logicalmonster 4y ago> The problem for Twitter is that politicians and celebrities don't really want to hang around on a platform where they have to deal with abusive content all the time. Maybe. At a certain point, that's probably true, but are we close to that? Sometimes you have to look at what people do, not what they say. It costs a celebrity nothing to say nice things about seeking peace and love and opposing hatred and wanting to fight all of the "hate speech" and "cyber-bullying" they see. In fact, they gain social capital for saying these things, so if you're a celebrity, you're effectively "leaving money on the table" by not talking in a certain way about certain topics. But it costs a celebrity a lot to actually leave a platform where they have some world-shaping influence. My guess is that most celebrities would figuratively crawl through a field of broken glass to get their fix of attention and kudos from their supporters.
- mikkergp 4y ago> My guess is that most celebrities would figuratively crawl through a field of broken glass to get their fix of attention and kudos from their supporters. Yeah I think the network effects are stronger than anyone would like to admit. I think Twitter has a lot of challenges going forward and my analytical read of the situation says he’ll fail, but my gut says he’ll succeed, now it just remains to be seen — succeed at what?
- BryantD 4y agoA couple of months ago Elon posted some notes on usage that indicated that the users with huge followings were in fact going away. This was later confirmed by a leaked internal research document[1]. So yes; we are close to that and quite possibly are at that point already. It's not clear to me that any of the changes he's made so far are oriented towards reversing that flow. It's possible that he didn't actually care about that, I suppose. 1. https://www.reuters.com/technology/exclusive-where-did-tweeters-go-twitter-is-losing-its-most-active-users-internal-2022-10-25/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/exclusive-where-did-tweet...
- wollsmoth 4y agoI think Twitter can continue to operate and even be profitable. But without completely adding a new product offering it's hard for me to imagine it growing to be worth a lot more than what Elon paid for it.
- mikkergp 4y ago> I think Twitter can continue to operate and even be profitable Im curious to hear more on this, in my mind the biggest problem with adding a new product offering would be diluting the text based content which may drive people to more “entertaining / TikTok” content than text content, I think one reason Twitter works as the public square is _because_ text is low effort for celebs/politicians/journalists/etc. Hard to imagine journalists driving as much traffic to their articles over video, especially if you go the Instagram route of starting to prioritize video over classic format (text/images) Again twitter as public square, not Twitter as some yet to be defined TikTok rival)
- wollsmoth 4y agoI just think there's a limit to how far optimizing the code and cutting costs is going to get him. I heard twitter was making a push to be more worldwide in its reach which could maybe work I guess. As it is though I don't know how much more he can drive usage of this product. I don't have any real product ideas for them myself. But they either need to drive ad revenue or come up with a compelling paid option. Maybe they can build on tweetdeck and make that a premium $$ feature? Maybe they start charging for api access.
- rapsey 4y agoIt is more public now but Elon has always operated this way. A book about paypal: The Founders, describes their constant war to survive and he obviously thrives in that environment. Which is why the Elon Twitter doomsayers are not likely to be right in the end. He has a method and it is rough and certain type of employee that fits his operating style. Twitter culture just the complete opposite which is why there is such an internal war.
- sweetheart 4y agoA "wartime" business person is a hilarious idea. Gotta feel manly somehow, I guess!
- larsonnn 4y agoYes. A few billion dollars wartime CEO.
- croisillon 4y agoWar is a business
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- karaterobot 4y agoI cringe when I see businesses using the vernacular of war to describe really mundane, essentially riskless goals. One company I was at had a "war room" dedicated to... increasing MRR to the arbitrary goals they'd set that quarter. They put a sign on the door. Another CEO told us in an all hands that the company was on a "war footing" until we found product market fit, and he'd use phrases like "total war" all the time. Jesus Christ, we're nerds trying to make money for investors.
- afarrell 4y agoIt also can be actively harmful to accomplishing the mission. It removes the sense of proportion needed to wisely weigh tradeoffs. It suggests that people play out roles in the Drama Triangle (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovrVv_RlCMw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovrVv_RlCMw) instead of focusing on building things, solving problems, and helping each other learn.
- pm90 4y agoYes its very cringe and only appeals to a certain section of people. At a previous company I worked at, they took this even further, organizing themselves into "squads" (teams) which were part of "platoons" (orgs). Someone that interviewed pointed out that this was pretty aggressive/warlike terminology and wondered why they used it and they didn't really have a good answer.
- bcjordan 4y agoCould we add (2011) to the title? This is from before Ben's 2014 book "The Hard Thing About Hard Things" which popularized the concept. I was expecting the link to be e.g. a new essay from Ben / a recent analysis of the concept.
- andsoitis 4y agoDone. And thanks for motivating why you would find it useful. Makes sense to me.
- mmastrac 4y agoA wartime CEO doesn't usually start the wars.
- ShehryarShahid 4y ago[dead]
- luminouslow 4y agoCompanies often seem to employ terms related to armed conflict to heighten the sense of urgency and action. In reality noone working at a software company is "getting their asses shot off" or even "goes to war". Stop using silly terms like that in business. We are not here to murder people or commit genocide, using this vernacular diminishes and marginalizes the immense suffering of humans caught in an actual war for any reason. I get it, war seems "cool" from far away and action movies/games, but I can assure you it is not. edit: fix typos
- s1k3 4y agoThe analogy is apt because war is an existential threat for the nation. Similarly, competition is an existential threat to the business. I don’t think this is about war being cool so much as competition in the market place can kill your business just like an invading army can conquer your territory. It’s about then mindset that you should adopt. Do you suppose that it’s ok for a business to let’s it’s competitors take its clients and market share? No of course not. You have to fight to keep it and take theirs. If you are equally matched then you will likely find equilibrium in the market. If you aren’t then someone is going to get eaten.
- luminouslow 4y ago>it’s ok for a business to let’s it’s competitors take its clients and market share? I wonder when businesses are OK with that? Seems like something you would like to avoid always, not just when "at war" (whatever that means - did someone declare war on you?)
- andsoitis 4y ago> using this vernacular diminishes and marginalizes the immense suffering of humans caught in an actual war for any reason. I don’t know that anyone (or at least a sizeable number of people) in an actual war views it this way. What is the causal link in your mind? Should we also ban the phrase “I’m starving”? What about “I’m sick and tired…”? Upping the intensity factor, what about “the underdog annihilated the #1 ranked player”?
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- AlwaysRock 4y agoGod I hate this essay. Every time the economy goes south people repost it. I've had ceos send it to me in the past. If you are running mega corp then sure. This all very well may be true. But for just about anyone else its insane to not plan for bad years. Save in the good years and build a war chest so instead of having 3 incredible years where you're going to Cabo for corporate retreats and you all get 250% bonuses and then 1 year where you layoff 15% of your staff... Just have 4 fine years where you are profitable.
- vaidhy 4y agoI recently came across Aswath Damodaran's youtube and I like his characterization of CEOs compatible with company maturity better. A visionary CEO is a wrong fit for a mature, stable-state company.
- f0e4c2f7 4y agoReid Hoffman extends this idea in an interesting way by talking about how you need different types of teams depending on what stage the company is at. One team to storm the beach, another team to capture the city, and another team to hold and police the city after. In both the case of the teams and "wartime" vs "peacetime" leaders I don't think one is better than another, just different skillets for different situations.
- alexpotato 4y agoI've sometimes heard it called the "Pioneers, Settlers and Town Planners" due to this article: https://medium.com/org-hacking/pioneers-settlers-town-planners-wardley-9dcd3709cde7 https://medium.com/org-hacking/pioneers-settlers-town-planne... Basically, different people are best suited to different stages of the organizations growth. I can see how that might also apply to the CEO in crisis vs not-crisis mode.
- f0e4c2f7 4y agoI like this analogy even better, thanks for sharing.
- bell-cot 4y agoReal Wartime CEO's say things like: "Any employee whose home was destroyed by the Russian Army may live in the office for free."
- mewse-hn 4y agoPeacetime CEO does not raise her voice. Wartime CEO rarely speaks in a normal tone. Utter crap. Business people trying to compare themselves to the godfather movies to excuse their asshole behavior. Lessons from the school of Steve Jobs Worship.
- lee101 4y agoFalse dichotomy.... After being at many successful and unsuccessful companies there's definitely different vibe, on one side you as an individual are allowed creative freedom to design+deliver a large project... on the other theres a lot of fear blame, time sunk into these "core" projects eg going mobile or video First or changing Clouds or cost cutting.. they often turn out to be illconsidered wastes of time, the pretence for war is a poor excuse for this lizard brain/ groupthink/ just doing what said manager likes to do