4 ms·
The energy efficiency is so unbelievably terrible it’s a very poor option for balancing the grid even if it wasn’t also more expensive than batteries. People t
by Retric 4y ago
The energy efficiency is so unbelievably terrible it’s a very poor option for balancing the grid even if it wasn’t also more expensive than batteries.
People talk about hydrogen for transportation because you can refuel quickly, using expensive fuels is already the norm, and it’s much lighter than batteries. But, it’s so expensive, inefficient, and difficult to store that there needs to be vast technical progresses before it’s viable. Hydrogen would be fairly viable if it was 1/4 as expensive, fuel cells cost 1/4th as much, and the energy density was 4x as high by volume. At which point we could start scaling producing, but batteries are viable today and we are already scaling production.
- jansan 4y agoFor large projects Hydrogren will probably be attached to nitrogen to produce ammonium. Technology to handle ammonum has been availble for about 100 years now, and while it has its drawbacks (it is toxic), using ammomium solves a lot of issues.
- rapsey 4y ago70%-80% electrolysis efficiency is unbelievably terrible? There are many factors such as cost, time to market and availability. Batteries require lots of mining of materials and have a limited lifespan.
- sauwan 4y agoElectrolysis only half of the round trip.
- scythe 4y agoFuel cell efficiency is worse than electrolysis efficiency, about 50%. Even the worst batteries beat that.
- rapsey 4y agoHow about cost and availability.
- funcDropShadow 4y agoHow many cycles do those batteries work with that efficiency? How environmentally friendly is mining Lithium in China and transporting it around the globe? How much CO₂ does the transport of those minerals/batteries produce? How do we get rid of old batteries? One huge advantage of producing hydrogen or methane out of thin air with excess energy from truly renewable energy sources is, that we don't have to procure and transport source materials, and that it can be stored.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoProducing and distributing hydrogen requires significant infrastructure that releases vastly more CO2 than moving lithium around for EV’s. I think you got blinded by thinking of hydrogen as green but it doesn’t magically show up. Also, moving lithium around releases negligible CO2, an EV battery only needs 15 pounds of lithium and lasts 25 years. You can work out the exact number based on specific origin and destinations but it’s on the order of driving an ICE 1 to 10 miles. Which shouldn’t be surprising because boats are very efficient, lithium is light, and cars weigh a lot.
- WorldMaker 4y agoLithium in China? What does that matter? Lithium comes from a lot of places. The largest Lithium exporter in the world today is Australia. Multiple South American countries are also towards the top of the list. A lot of lithium "mining" is digging up desert salt deposits or skimming salt brines from salt lakes. Some of that still isn't "perfectly" environmentally friendly, but compared to extracting most any other sort of mineral it is one of the environmentally friendliest we extract. Lithium is the third element on the periodic table and the third most common element in the universe. Admittedly a lot of the planet's Lithium is in compounds/salts that sometimes need to be chemically broken down and that has more environmental impacts than the mining processes. So there is that, admittedly. But a lot of it is electrolytic just like the "advantageous" hydrogen processes people seem to love. Lithium is not a rare or heavy mineral. It's the next fatter cousin of Hydrogen. > How do we get rid of old batteries? Recycling. Plenty of companies have already answered this question. Lithium is highly reclaimable from all existing Lithium-based battery formulations.
- jcampbell1 4y agoBatteries are >95% efficient round trip. Hydrogen is: 70% Gibbs Free Energy Efficiency, 70% electrolysis efficiency, 50% fuel cell efficiency, 93% compression efficiency = 23% round trip efficiency.
- Retric 4y agoFuel cells are only useful for automotive applications, on the grid you want combined cycle gas turbines which are cheaper and more efficient. That still only gets round trip efficiency to about 25%.
- kergonath 4y ago> on the grid you want combined cycle gas turbines which are cheaper and more efficient You don’t want gas turbines anywhere near the grid. It is a terrible strategic choice besides the obvious ecological effect.
- Retric 4y agoYou are thinking of natural gas fueled turbines, you can also burn hydrogen in gas turbines. If that hydrogen was produced domestically via electrolysis using clean sources there isn’t any strategic issues. Also, from a strategic perspective burning domestic natural gas and burning natural gas from a different country are very different things. Europe becoming dependent on Russian natural gas was stupid, but America burning it’s domestic natural gas is mostly just an environmental issue.
- _hypx 4y agoA fuel cell is a battery. It has the same fundamental efficiency as any other battery. Of course, this is not how it works in the real world, but people who cite "efficiency" are usually greatly exaggerating how it works. Most batteries cannot reach 95% efficiency, especially if they need to store energy for long periods of time. Round trip efficiency of hydrogen will beat any ICE doing the same thing, and with heat recapture will basically match a li-ion battery. In situations where li-ion is poorly suited, such as cold weather or long-term storage, hydrogen will often be more efficient.
- sdenton4 4y agoWait till you hear about the efficiency of petrochemicals... "In other words, even when the engine is operating at its point of maximum thermal efficiency, of the total heat energy released by the gasoline consumed, about 65-80% of total power is emitted as heat without being turned into useful work, i.e. turning the crankshaft." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engine_efficiency#:~:text=in%20more%20drag.-,Gasoline%20(petrol)%20engines,used%20to%20power%20a%20car https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engine_efficiency#:~:text=in....
- whatshisface 4y agoHydrocarbons would also be a bad alternative to batteries for grid energy storage.
- PaulHoule 4y agoDispatchable energy sources already compete with grid storage, in fact they have been dominant for the last 100 years.
- gambiting 4y agoSure, but producing 1kWh worth of petrol doesn't require 1kWh of energy. Producing 1kWh worth of hydrogen through electrolysis always requires more than 1kWh of energy, it's just pure physics. Even if the process was 100% efficient through magic, it's still a stupid thing to rely on for producing hydrogen.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jameshart 4y ago> producing 1kWh worth of petrol doesn't require 1kWh of energy … so long as you don’t count the 1kWh of photosynthesis that was done by a bunch of ancient plankton to rip CO2 molecules apart and build hydrocarbons instead.
- 4y ago
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoYeah, the key to any practical use of hydrogen is a massive massive infrastructure buildout. Fundamentally, a hydrogen infrastructure is competing with the power grid, which has a century of investment and already exists. It competes with battery technology/economics, which is in roughly a 10% year on year improvement curve, a curve that will have to flatten at some point but has been doing 10% for better than a decade and with 140 wh/kg sodium ion / 200 wh/kg LFP / emerging solid state + lithium sulfur techs will probably continue. So if hydrogen is claiming: - IF we resolve the research barriers and core engineering to a basic state - IF we invest billions/trillions in infrastructure - IF that is built in 10 years (which would be a miraculous human achievement) ... THEN we ... might ... in theory ... be price competitive with the current day grid + batteries. OK, what about a world where batteries are half or a third of the cost in 10 years, which is what the long term trends suggest with year-on-year improvements? All the nuclear and hydrogen stories are being hyped hard over the last couple years, because those behind those technologies aren't stupid and see the curves in alternative energy and storage and EVs: economic armageddon at an industry wide level for the nuclear, oil/gas, and others. The coal industry was a preview for their industries. They know it's a losing battle, but like other fading industries, the execs hold on tooth and nail to get their bonuses/retirement/payouts. The organizations have real economic inertia, and investing in things that slow down the transition allows the companies to make more money longer. At least the economics of wind/solar/batteries are working so strongly in favor of a transition. Otherwise write the requiem for the human race.
- oceanplexian 4y agoThe power grid will never be able to compete with hydrogen (or other liquid fuels). The laws of physics simply aren't on the side of using the electric grid for fueling. Imagine a truck stop where you can have 10-15 semi trucks filling up 300 gallon tanks every 5 minutes. We're talking megawatt-hours of energy to every roadside fuel station. And there are in excess of 10 million semi-trucks and over 40,000 truck stops in the USA. This isn't even getting into more demanding applications, like aviation, where the energy demands are an order of magnitude greater (The electrical equivalent of fueling a single Boeing 747 with 65,000 gallons of JET-A in under an hour is ludicrous) Unless you build hundreds of nuclear reactors, invent superconducting power lines, come up with battery technology that's 100 years in the future, or tell everyone that the 21st century is cancelled, this is all impossible for the grid. At least on paper, hydrogen can solve this problem if we can figure out how to generate, store and transport it properly.
- Manuel_D 4y agoBatteries don't have acceptable energy density for use in aircraft and transoceanic shipping. It's not that hydrogen is better than batteries for a sedan. It's that you'll never, ever fly across the Pacific in a battery powered airliner.
- freeone3000 4y agoAs if we'll ever have a transatlantic voyage in a craft held aloft by hydrogen
- Manuel_D 4y agoIt's been built before: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-155 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tupolev_Tu-155 Ships have even less of an issue with storing hydrogen since mass is less of an issue (building lightweight enclosures for liquid hydrogen is a challenge).
- nanomonkey 4y agoI assume this is a joke as the LZ127 and Hindenburg made hundreds of trans Atlantic trips.
- Night_Thastus 4y ago*With current battery technology We have no idea what batteries may be possible in the future. It may be a decade or a hundred years, but one day that may very well be possible.
- Manuel_D 4y agoA battery powered plane is possible in the same vein that a fusion powered plane is possible - it's not at all possible with current technology and anything in the foreseeable future.
- WorldMaker 4y agoThere are battery electric "regional commuter" two-seater planes on sale today. There's a 9-seater prototype that has completed short hop test flights [1]. Right now almost all of that is short-hop, but the excitement in that growing industry is that may disrupt the economics of even long range jet flights before long. (Not just "foreseeable future" but "sooner than you think".) (The efficiencies of battery electric for planes is apparently really interesting: that battery motor full torque access apparently a game changer for some types of flight dynamics. Or so I've heard.) [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/largest-electric-plane-yet-completed-its-first-flight-it-s-n1221401 https://www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/largest-electri...
- pfdietz 4y agoThe efficiency argument is a huge canard for the applications for which hydrogen makes sense. The "cost of inefficiency" is proportional to the number of charge-discharge cycles. For annual seasonal leveling, the cost is very small compared to diurnal storage. Hydrogen critics also say "just overbuild the renewables instead". Apparently, dropping excess power on the floor giving an efficiency of its use of ZERO is to be preferred to making hydrogen with it at efficiency great than zero.
- Retric 4y agoBeing 25% efficient means you need massive surplus to offset any kind of seasonal deficits, but by building those massive surpluses you reduce those same seasonal deficits. On top of this you don’t want a grid that breaks down due to unusual weather or really any predictable issues so you want to build in excess production, and again that safety net further reduces seasonal deficits. Hydrogen might work as a kind of black swan protection, but storing hydrogen for very long periods isn’t cheap or easy. Hydrogen embrittlement is a problem. At best it might fit the edge case that current reserve natural gas power plants do. But, that’s such a tiny percentage of annual demand we could just use natural gas without significant global warming concerns. I am fine with a 99.95% green grid, at that point many other issues need to be addressed.
- pfdietz 4y agoStoring hydrogen underground for long periods is actually shockingly cheap. It's the same technology used for storing natural gas underground. The cost is as little as $1/kWh of storage capacity. This is already proven technology, so no whining about embrittlement please. Yes, it fits edge cases -- but it has an outsized effect on the cost of a 100% renewable grid. Trying to cover black swan events with batteries or overprovisioning would be much more expensive. Optimizing baseload output in Germany using historical weather data and 2030 estimated cost figures for PV, wind, batteries and hydrogen, including hydrogen cuts the cost of the system in half.
- Retric 4y ago
- leobg 4y agoTalking here about stationary storage only (not transportation, for which I agree that hydrogen is a stupid idea.): Isn’t efficiency kind of irrelevant when the energy you are storing - i.e. that of the sun - is essentially free? You would need to do a comparison across many different strategies. For instance, compare against the cost of energy per kilowatt hour in winter from fossil fuels (ideally also factoring in the costs to the environment). And compare against solar energy, collected in summer, stored using different mediums. Against batteries, hydrogen, in spite of all the conversions and the compression needed, would be dirt cheap.
- Retric 4y agoNothing is free, still need significant infrastructure to produce hydrogen at scale. It’s not like hydrogen is the only thing that wants cheap electricity and building infrastructure that’s very rarely used get’s expensive in the same way batteries sitting around for most of the year unused is expensive, so let’s assuming you can capture 1/2 of a surplus. If the surplus is 24% for 3 months and you can capture 1/8th of it that’s only 3% for 3 months which is quite a bit of energy but is only useful if the deficit is actually 3% and nobody want’s to build a grid that close to failure simply because weather can make a larger difference than 3%. Which means you don’t get to used your equipment to generate electricity every year. Don’t get me wrong hydrogen works in preparation for black swan events, but seasonal demand is much better dealt with by saving hydroelectric power for much of the year.