3 ms·
> If AGI has even a 1% chance of happening this century and those donations reduce the risk of it going wrong and killing everyone by 1% that's still money very
by bnralt 4y ago
> If AGI has even a 1% chance of happening this century and those donations reduce the risk of it going wrong and killing everyone by 1% that's still money very well spent.
"If killer GMOs have even a 1% chance of happening this century and donations to Greenpeace reduce the risk of them killing everyone by 1% that's still money well spent." Would you find that argument compelling? My guess is that most people would find the "even 1%" much too high for both cases. And that's with technology we could, theoretically, do bad things with today if we really wanted to for some reason, not some far off technology we might not get to for centuries.
The made up statistics "rationalists" like to use are pretty similar to certain sales techniques you see from less reputable quarters. For instance, multi-level marketing companies - "You probably know, what, 100 people at least? And if even a small amount of them, say 5%, sign up, they get a small amount of their friends - ~5% - to sign up, and they get a small amount of their friends to sign up - well, soon you have 125 people you're getting money from while you're hardly doing any work!" The sleight of hand is pretending that a percentage is small, because in most cases a percentage of that size is considered small, when in this particular case it's orders of magnitude larger than reality.
- concordDance 4y ago> Would you find that argument compelling? Of course not. The people who are donating to AI risk are those who have spent a lot of time thinking about it, reading about it and investigating it. If someone spent a bunch of time reading about GMO risk and decided it was a serious concern and that Greenpeace was the solution then I'd think them perfectly reasonable to donate to Greenpeace. And if I knew them to be intelligent and reasonable people I might even be willing to give then some time to convince me that I should also donate to Green peace
- melagonster 4y agohere. killer GMOs is a choice, isn't a probably future.