7 ms·
The fall of Sam Bankman-Fried is crypto’s Enron moment
- bigmattystyles 4y agoQuestion: Will SBF still be a millionaire many times over after this?
- friedman23 4y agoHe will likely end up in jail. If he's not in jail by the end of this there is just serious corruption.
- grensley 4y agoThe corporate structure surrounding FTX is so complex, and given that Elizabeth Holmes is still walking free, I would guess it will be a long long time before anyone involved here sees a jail cell.
- incompleteCode 4y agoElizabeth Holmes defrauded investors. SBF gambled with customer deposits. I’d say the stakes are higher. Edit: fixed formatting.
- a_bonobo 4y agoPlus, Holmes was judged to be guilty, the sentencing will be this week: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/nov/14/theranos-elizabeth-holmes-sentencing-fraud https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/nov/14/theranos-...
- grensley 4y agoI'm just saying that it's been 7 years since the fraud went public
- carterschonwald 4y agoYeah. The SEC was created to protect the general public. Not “sophisticated investors ” (aka those who care afford to lose money)
- jimhi 4y agoHolmes made up device was in a few Walgreens giving people made up medical test results. I disagree the stakes are higher here.
- markdown 4y agoHe's a citizen of the most corrupt country in the world and the (only?) one that legalised that corruption and gave it a different name. He was the biggest donor to the governing party. He'll be fine.
- nwiswell 4y ago> He lives in USA This is incorrect, he's an actual physical resident of the Bahamas, where FTX is also domiciled.
- markdown 4y agoThanks, fixed.
- ALittleLight 4y agoMost corrupt country in the world? By what measure?
- markdown 4y agoIt's legal in your country to pay huge sums of money to your politicians in order to buy influence. Ergo the laws of the country and the actions of the government are for sale to the highest bidder. In most other countries, this would land people in jail, but in the US it's so utterly brazen that you can find the details online. See https://www.opensecrets.org/ https://www.opensecrets.org/ Don't forget that the very phrase "Banana Republic" is a result of US corporations that had bought the US govt and gotten them to oust governments in 3rd world countries for the benefit of those US corporations.
- ALittleLight 4y agoTransparency International maintains a global corruption index - the US ranks 27th in terms of "least corrupt" which is within the top quintile. Many other countries rank worse. For example, Fiji is rated 45th on the index. You can absolutely use money to influence politicians in the US, but that's likely true of wherever you live too. New Zealand is a very not-corrupt country according to the corruption index, but I seem to recall Peter Thiel had no trouble purchasing citizenship in contravention of their laws - I'm sure money had nothing to do with that though.
- mikeyouse 4y agoNo, there's no world in which he is. Fraud on this level will see massive forfeiture as directed by the SEC and DOJ and then civil suits will clean up anything left afterward he's released from prison.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qaq 4y agoone thing crypto is pretty decent for is hiding a bunch of money from authorities
- devmunchies 4y ago> No, there's no world in which he is Sure there is. The scenario where he escape with a suitcase of gold to a country without extradition. Or another scenario would be if he had serious blackmail on several key govt officials.
- BurningFrog 4y agoYou need nothing that heavy. Many printed out bitcoins fit in an envelope.
- friend_and_foe 4y agoPrinted out bitcoins?
- tarsinge 4y agoYes having bitcoins is just having a private key. In 12 or 24 words format a wallet can even be memorized if needed. The blockchain is the global ledger of how much money there is on corresponding public keys.
- friend_and_foe 4y agoWhen you're hitting at that level you can't hide, not anymore. Maybe in the 70s. Countries without extradition aren't usually the kinds of places you want to go these days, and people there are bound to know who you are and shake you down when you're a globally known rich guy.
- memish 4y agoHe's still posting on Twitter as though this is going to blow over. I don't get it. Is there a chance nothing is going to happen? What kind of advice is he getting? "I’m meeting in-person with regulators and working with the teams to do what we can for customers." https://twitter.com/SBF_FTX/status/1592604699693580289 https://twitter.com/SBF_FTX/status/1592604699693580289 "So what can I try to do? Raise liquidity, make customers whole, and restart." https://twitter.com/SBF_FTX/status/1592710177152995328 https://twitter.com/SBF_FTX/status/1592710177152995328
- marshmallowmad 4y agoHe seems to be deep into denial. I can’t imagine what’s going on in his mind right now.
- frozenport 4y ago"these drugs made me dumb"
- braingenious 4y agoI’d probably just up my dosage if I were in his position. This looks like a terrible moment to sober up.
- marshmallowmad 4y agoIt appears that he may have upped his dosage. And him acting like he can recover is from the drugs. To act like this after clearly committing crimes visible by tens of millions of people, and just getting torn apart for it online. I wish I was this confident!
- braingenious 4y ago> I wish I was this confident! I’m over a decade sober, but fyi this is available to you if you just buy some meth or bath salts!
- noobermin 4y agoThis article is a good succinct summary of events, especially for someone like me who isn't keyed into the "who's who" of the crypto world.
- bhawks 4y agoI'd caution that the author of the article isn't too keyed into crypto either. > A friend who is deeply involved in this industry told me of the clashing egos. “CZ helped SBF create FTX, let him grow it, and then when it got too big, he destroyed it.” The situation was entirely the creation of FTX - CZ just amplified the alarm that was already ringing when Alameda's balance sheet issues came to light. Tl/Dr; SBF ran both an exchange and a hedge fund as allegedly separate companies. His hedge fund made several highly speculative investments during the crypto bull run. They then started bailing out companies in the summer when the tera/Luna stable coin crashed. Along this time falling crypto prices were causing Alameda to get margin called. Eventually SBF took user funds from the exchange to meet the hedge funds margin calls. At that point it became a zombie company. Depending on what you read SBF had less than a billion dollars of assets to 10 billion of liabilities. The scope of SBF's fraud is being actively uncovered by the community as we speak. It'll be a while before we know the full picture. Painting this as crypto bro trader war trivializes it and reduces SBF's responsibility. SBF built a house of cards on top of fraud and eventually some wind knocked it down. The responsibility lies with him and his leadership team.
- paxys 4y agoI don't remember New York Times doing a glowing feature on Enron and its leadership after it had collapsed.
- breck 4y agoSo many people are kicking SBF now that he's on the ground and it's disgusting. Anyone who was talking shit about him in private but now is going public with it isn't smart you are a pussy. I've never met the guy but I used FTX this month and it was solid. I'm hoping they pull through. We need more last mile providers. Instant crypto banking is >> than the molasses fiat banking we currently have. (Obviously if you were talking shit about him publicly before the fall then I respect that and please carry on)
- thrown_22 4y agoI was kicking him when he wasn't on the ground too.
- breck 4y agoI respect that. Kick away.
- pseudo0 4y agoHaven't they effectively admitted to stealing billions of dollars of FTX exchange customer funds to try and prevent Alameda from going under? Alameda blowing up would be one thing, its investors knew they were making a risky bet, but FTX exchange users appear to have been just straight-up robbed.
- breck 4y agoI've been able to make withdrawals from FTX just fine, but haven't logged in in a few days.
- pseudo0 4y agoWell their assets were frozen on Nov 10 by the Bahamas' securities regulator, so I hope you withdrew any money that you needed. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-11-10/ftx-com-assets-frozen-by-bahamas-securities-regulator https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-11-10/ftx-com-a...
- 4y ago
- _hypx 4y agoProbably not, as Enron was a real company and its collapse led to massive job losses. Crypto is just speculators losing money. More like Tulipomania, maybe Madoff if it can be proven that it was intentional.
- smabie 4y agoI mean crypto has thousands of employees too? Also enron was also just speculators losing money
- _hypx 4y agoAccording to the wiki page, FTX only has 300 employees.
- fourstar 4y agoCue the luddites in 3… 2… ah there you are!
- recursive 4y agoYou can't cue something that precedes the cue.
- bogwog 4y agoAFAIK, this wasn't a situation were people gambled and lost, it was just straight up fraud. FTX misled customers (not investors) into thinking their deposits were safe, when in fact they were being used for gambling (because of course they were).
- JimmyRuska 4y agoPretty unfair to CZ. FTX was using FTT as an infinite money glitch. Why would CZ hold a coin that has a strong likelihood of going to 0? https://dirtybubblemedia.substack.com/p/is-alameda-research-insolvent https://dirtybubblemedia.substack.com/p/is-alameda-research-... The balance sheet showed billions of dollars in assets for coins that had tens of millions in liquidity. There's an 8 billion dollar hole in the balance sheet. It's pretty clear they used customer deposits to pay back lenders. Why would CZ buy a company that's nearly an Enron level fraud, and due for a criminal investigation. https://www.visualcapitalist.com/ftx-leaked-balance-sheet-visualized/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/ftx-leaked-balance-sheet-vi... SBF describes coins like a ponzi with no shame https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C6nAxiym9oc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C6nAxiym9oc This was Alameda CEO https://www.youtube.com/shorts/qvURq4jaUcA https://www.youtube.com/shorts/qvURq4jaUcA https://twitter.com/carolinecapital/status/1379036346300305408 https://twitter.com/carolinecapital/status/13790363463003054... Meanwhile, after 1 - 2bn in customer funds are missing. Everyone is asking Sam to say what happened. Sam proceeds to troll by writing the words "What happened" one letter at a time, with an Elizabeth Holmes-like legal disclaimer that he's not going to recall any of the details.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoAgreed. If anything he protected Binance customers from exposure to this dumpster fire.
- gruez 4y ago>This was Alameda CEO https://www.youtube.com/shorts/qvURq4jaUcA https://www.youtube.com/shorts/qvURq4jaUcA >https://twitter.com/carolinecapital/status/13790363463003054 https://twitter.com/carolinecapital/status/13790363463003054... I have to admit the tweet is pure cringe, but I can't see anything wrong with the youtube. Most of the answers seem reasonable if you don't try to interpret in the worst possible light and factor in that there's zero context provided.
- notch656a 4y agoThese people are supposed to be some kind of geniuses but everything that comes out of their mouth is contentless drivel. Caroline says at best she's using elementary school math. The articulation SBF provided of how the system works was literally something like 'A box you put coins into and take money out of' which he then explained to be a ponzi scheme in everything but name. How on earth did these kids come to be in charge of such massive amount of capital? The whole thing defies logic.
- odysseus 4y agoI wonder if any of the politicians who took his crypto money are going to give any of it back. Looks like a few are, but some are remaining silent: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/democrats-took-his-shady-crypto-money-will-they-keep-it/ar-AA147TZO https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/democrats-took-his-s...
- kolbe 4y ago> Rep. Ruben Gallego (D-AZ) said he spent money given to him by Bankman-Fried to drive turnout for Andrea Salinas, a Latina running for Congress in Oregon—whom Bankman-Fried spent millions to defeat during the district’s Democratic primary. > “So, I think I’ve paid it back,” Gallego said. I don't think he has the same definition of "paid it back" as most people do.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoI don’t understand the pressure to give bad people their money back. What’s it supposed to accomplish? I’m not sure it should even be legal to send money to SBF. It’s seeming more and more likely that he’s head of a criminal conspiracy.
- dottrap 4y agoIf the money was stolen, it was never SBF's to give. The law does have provisions that can force the clawback of stolen funds. But because we're talking about politicians here, I don't think anybody believes the law will be enforced equally to them.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoIt's supposed to prove that you're better than they are. It's not supposed to accomplish anything other than that.
- pkaye 4y agoLooks like some of the politicians are re-gift the donations to charity. https://fortune.com/crypto/2022/11/15/politicians-sam-bankman-fried-donations-ftx-charity/ https://fortune.com/crypto/2022/11/15/politicians-sam-bankma...
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI don't understand crypto (didn't understand derivatives either). I have worried that my ignorance will cost me in investing — that people smarter than me are going to make bank while I'm derp-derping with my index funds. Reading as others, apparently as ignorant as me, ask questions about crypto, etc. the in-crowd seem to get it, seem to understand it. I find that generally the case with anything monetary/financial though: the people that do this complex stuff seem to understand it but seem unable to explain it in a way that someone as simple as me can understand. In order to play the crypto game you have to learn this absurd set of rules. And there's something about crypto though where the proponents almost revel in other's ignorance. I've had a hard time deciding whether the proponents really understand it (and all of its nuances) or if pretending you understand it in fact part of the game.
- dmak 4y agoWhat's your question about crypto?
- JKCalhoun 4y agoQuestions arise all the time when reading about crypto. I sadly don't have a list. Just reading the thread here though reminded me of one: is crypto traceable by the feds or not? I've seen people very confidently declare both.
- dmak 4y agoYou can follow transactions on the blockchain, but the question is if you can tie that wallet to an identity. If the last wallet belongs to a CEX then it's likely they know the identity of the owner due to KYC regulations. Tornado Cash previously broke that trail using asset pools, but that has been sanctioned now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- idunno246 4y agothe ledger is public, so every transaction is traceable. maybe you create a wallet/entity thats not clearly linked to a person. you could probably claim its not traceable with a wallet address alone, you can see its transactions but have no idea who it is. at some point in the future or past you interact with the real world, like say sell crypto and withdraw USD, or start by buying crypto with USD. at that point they link that entity with a person(exchanges generally have to follow Know Your Customer rules), and can trace the transactions to the person through the public ledger.
- holistio 4y agoIt's not nice making fun of people's names, but ever since this blew up I can't help but call him Cryptoman-Fraud.
- progrus 4y agoThis is way bigger than Enron. You’ll see.
- Cupertino95014 4y agoLet's imagine Bernie Madoff telling the feds, "Hey, I know how to invest. Let me make everyone whole again." Instead, we had this: https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-recovering-madoff-money/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-recovering-madoff-mo... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recovery_of_funds_from_the_Madoff_investment_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recovery_of_funds_from_the_Mad... So some future Irving Picard will have the task of getting people some of their money back. I wouldn't want that job.
- colechristensen 4y agoIt really isn’t, crypto has mini enron moments on a regular basis. Any real bank losing $100M of customer funds (or much more) isn’t the least bit surprising. Happens all the time. Sure more people are noticing over time but it’s not done happening.
- bnjemian 4y agoCan't say I care too much about FTX's woes. Nonetheless, this article has some janky moments. The author cites an unnamed friend "who is deeply involved in [the crypto] industry" when saying CZ played a master stroke against SBF. Get a real source or at least demonstrate that your "friend" has an opinion worth 2 cents. Maybe CZ did outplay SBF, but aside from the optics it doesn't seem anywhere that salacious. As was summed up earlier today in an NPR segment on this story "airlines don't compete on safety." In other words, it is in the interest of every exchange that the exchange industry is on the whole viewed as being comprised of trustworthy actors. Crashing FTX doesn't seem an optimal move given the already precarious state of the crypto industry these days. Speaking of optics, the author also made a nonsensical analogy "more opaque than a dog with glaucoma" when describing the inner workings of FTX. Quite certain they meant cataracts – the clouding of the lens of the eye – not glaucoma, which is damage to the optic nerve.
- skinnymuch 4y agoCZ could have gotten paid $1B or whatever many FTT they owned for $22/coin. That would have still weakened FTX and Alameda a ton. Them having to pay out so much of that money would have put them closer to the tipping point and gaining over a billion for CZ. Obviously removing a top competitor that’s doing straight up robbery is something that should always be done. We are talking about awful actions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- VectorLock 4y agoReally in this case CZ put a bullet in him as sure as he was holding a real gun. The need to build "trust" by not absolutely ruining one of his competitors didn't factor in here, because there is no need.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe collapse of Binance will be the Enron moment. By magnitude, Tether is a much bigger "fractional reserve" (Ponzi) scheme than FTX.
- williamstein 4y agoAre you confusing Bitfinex and Binance?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoNo. Binance is a huge exchange and is tied to Tether, which is an open scam. Bitfinex is a comparatively small player.
- scaredginger 4y agoHow many Enron moments is crypto going to have?
- friend_and_foe 4y agoAnd Enron was the Enron moment of what industry exactly? These comparisons make for good clickbait, but in reality they're meaningless. The truth is, these sorts of things happen in cryptocurrency every bear market, and in more mature markets as well but just to a less extreme degree. The only reason it feels huge in cryptocurrency is because the news has been covering it non stop, celebrities were endorsing things and commercials were on TV. In reality the magnitude of this collapse, logarithmically, is smaller than all previous bitcoin and related market collapses. In absolute terms it's big, and it is a big deal just like any financial happenings are a big deal, but itst being made bigger than it is because there's money to be made manipulating emotions.
- ly3xqhl8g9 4y agoEnron was the Elf Aquitaine [1] compounding moment of the energy industry. It's not comparison, it's a chain reaction, fraud begets fraud. [1] Happened in 1994: 'the biggest fraud inquiry in Europe since the Second World War... Elf became a private bank for executives who spent £200 million on political favours, mistresses, jewellery, fine art, villas and apartments', £200 million, how quaint https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elf_Aquitaine#Fraud_scandal_(1994) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elf_Aquitaine#Fraud_scandal_(1...
- Animats 4y ago"There followed a jujitsu move by which the Binance chief created a market run on FTX." There seems to be an attempt to sell a narrative which blames Binance for this. That's bogus. We know now that FTX was so looted and so broke it was doomed. The only question was what would pop the bubble. This is straight theft of customer assets, like Madoff. As with Madoff, once there was a downturn, it all came apart.
- _ubs3 4y ago> The whole thing is quite messy – much like the whole crypto ecosystem, which is supposed to be open and transparent but is more opaque than a dog with glaucoma. Centralized exchanges are NOT crypto. They often don't even use crypto - just fabricated records in their databases with no crypto backing whatsoever, like FTX.