7 ms·
Pakistan's lost city of 40k people
- JetAlone 4y agoSurely it was not officially called Mohenjo-Daro (Mound of the dead men) by its residents, in its heyday?
- klyrs 4y ago> While ancient writings often reveal the secrets of civilisations, this has not been the case with Mohenjo-daro, whose inhabitants used what's known as the Indus Valley Script. "It was a pictographic language with more than 400 signs. It is still not decoded," said my guide Solangi. Unless a written record of its name can be found and deciphered, that name will probably endure.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoThe Article mentions it was on trade routes all over Central Asia. Its name must be mentioned in other languages in other ancient cities. Egypt, Mesopotamia, etc would have mentioned this place by name.
- erklik 4y ago> Unless a written record of its name can be found and deciphered, that name will probably endure. I think this still stands. Even if it has been mentioned, we'll have to find it and decipher. I would argue considering how famous it is in the nation, it'll be real hard to change the name even if the original is found.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThere are Mesopotamian records that refer to various parallel states. But it's not easy to prove that a particular name refers to a particular area. (If I'm remembering correctly, we do suspect a particular group mentioned in Mesopotamian records of being Harappan. It's still impossible to prove; you'd want a lot more evidence than "we think it was these guys" before renaming the culture. There is also no particular reason to believe that the Sumerian word for Harappans was related to the Harappan word for themselves.) EDIT: found it - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meluhha https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meluhha
- derefr 4y agoThere are often cases where we know a dead civilization exists in the archaeological record in a particular place, but with no surviving texts buried there documenting the place's name; and we know that references to a place that sound like they're talking about that dead civilization, exist in other civilizations' surviving contemporaneous texts; but we can't be sure the references are talking about the particular place/civilization that we've found archaeological records of. One good example: is the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_of_Punt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_of_Punt the same civilization as / continuous with the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_of_Aksum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_of_Aksum ? There's a lot of "circumstantial evidence" for that conclusion, but nothing definitive.
- quadrifoliate 4y agoThe article focuses a bit too much on the city and not enough on the civilization that it was a part of. I guess the fact that it's in the Lost Civilizations series is an indicator? Anyway, for those not in the know – the city at Mohenjodaro is part of the rather extensive Indus Valley/Harappan Civilization that was contemporary with the Egyptian and Mesopotamian civilizations (~3000BC onwards). The reasons for its decline aren't particularly well understood. The script [2] of the IVC is as-yet undeciphered as well. ---------------------------------------- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_Valley_Civilisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_Valley_Civilisation [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_script https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_script
- peoplefromibiza 4y ago> The reasons for its decline aren't particularly well understood. another victim of the bronze age collapse that we can't explain fully.
- ganarajpr 4y agoI have heard that it was a victim of the 200 year famine that hit most parts of the world during 2000-1900 BCE timeframe. At the same time, the mega river that streamed through central India dried up completely adding insult to injury. This MAY be the cause of the collapse of civilization. As far as I have seen, this is the best plausible explanation for the collapse - so far.
- kristopolous 4y agoThat's a lovely script. Really quite mysterious. Reminds me of graph theory and topology. I wonder if you can do some kind of weird frequency distribution analysis to classify what the extent specimens may be referring to. I mean given some old civilization, is there a guassian like distribution of say X% documents being financial, Y% religious and so on? And if there is, can you somehow classify these samples into camps and then maybe get to some confidence interval that one pile is likely say, political statements such as laws. If you can get say a commerce/accounting pile, your known plaintext is pretty constrained. There's probably some bookkeeping and itemization and maybe some mathematics. Especially if there's addition or subtraction on there. It may not look anything like how we do it: could be concentric circles or something wild but arithmetic is generally the same. X + Y >= (X or Y) - even in systems where they just use a term "many", some really basic rules will still hold For the religion you have feasts, calendars, holy days, etc. Maybe there's domain specific characters given this approach
- willwinger 4y agoAs an ancient civilization with an undeciphered script, Indus Valley Civ. is mired in controversy and claims Religion wise though article claims an Egyptian link which is new to me, it has some clear Hindu associations like the Pasupathinath seal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pashupati_seal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pashupati_seal Script wise the contention and claim also comes from Tamil and Sanskrit. TED talk on this below https://youtu.be/kwYxHPXIaao https://youtu.be/kwYxHPXIaao
- 19f191ty 4y agoPashupati is much, much older than modern concept of Hinduism. Many cultures around the time had a "Master of Animals" motif depicted l in their cultural artifact https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master_of_Animals https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master_of_Animals You could call Rudra/Shiva as modern versions of that motif. But calling the figure in Pashupati seal as depecting a Hindu deity is probably not correct. IVC was pre-vedic after all. No doubt later cultures adopted IVC deities into their own pantheon. But IVC religion was likely very far from what we recognize as Hinduism. And probably closer to religions in Mesopotamia at the time. Egypt does seem further culturally than Mesopotamia to me though. So I find the Egyptian connection a bit tenuous as well.
- random314 4y agoIn particular pashupati is not mentioned in rgveda
- naruvimama 4y ago
- bergenty 4y agoHinduism is Vedic + IVC + other indigenous belief systems
- dhruval 4y agoNot sure why this is getting downvoted. This is called the “Hindu synthesis”.
- manjuds1 4y ago
- ojbyrne 4y agoWikipedia also refers to a Buddhist stupa on the site: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohenjo-daro https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohenjo-daro People lived there after the Indus Valley Civilization.
- quadrifoliate 4y agoThe substance of the criticism is correct, but I would recommend that you point out the problem as one of incompetence in journalism rather than counterproductive insults about IQs. Initially, I thought that you were referring to this comment, which (correctly) said that the discoverer thought it was a Buddhist stupa. > It wasn't until 1922 that R D Banerji, an ASI officer, believed he saw a buried stupa, a mound-like structure where Buddhists typically meditate. But no, the author themselves also (incorrectly) calls it a stupa in the first paragraph too. > An ancient Buddhist stupa towered over the time-worn streets, with a large communal pool complete with a wide staircase below. This is ridiculous. You'd think that they understood that the initial discoverer was wrong, and that this was a civilization long predating the existence of Buddhism.
- ojbyrne 4y agoExcept there is a Buddhist stupa at the site. https://www.harappa.com/blog/buddhist-stupa-mohenjo-daro https://www.harappa.com/blog/buddhist-stupa-mohenjo-daro
- selimthegrim 4y agoHow is it Shiva if IVC predated Aryan migration?
- naruvimama 4y ago
- vishnugupta 4y agoI got interested in Indus Valley Civilisation (IVC) while following a rabbit hole of trying to understand the population admixture of Indians. It is a truly fascinating civilisation. Here are some titbits that I found really interesting. At it peak it was a spread over a truly gigantic geographical space. However the city architectures followed nearly same blue print. Which points to the existence of some kind of central planning. It is known as a faceless civilisation because there wasn't an obviously kingly figure. No royal burials, no palaces, no extravagant houses etc., Of course there were rich and poor people but overall it seemed to be an egalitarian culture. Most houses are more or less uniformly well built. The cities were divided into two sections; one part showing signs of more wealth than the other, suggesting ruling class of some sort. But again, it wasn't as if there was a king or as such. There is no sign of war, destruction or violence. No weapons, no signs of burning/pillage etc., They traded with contemporary civilisations, predominantly with Mesopotamia. Here's a good video but that's not easy find https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_s5EDxuL0Vs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_s5EDxuL0Vs
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rcshubhadeep 4y agoMr. Danino had written a wonderful book on this subject. Called "The Lost River". I suggest it as much as I can. I got interested in Indus Valley by reading this.
- bergenty 4y agoGet the book by David Reich from 2018. He basically has solved the question of Indian genetic origins. In a nutshell, IVC is original inhabitants of India + Iranian pastoralists, today called dravidians. Aryans came in to this mix about 2000 years later.
- ganarajpr 4y agoThat is no longer the view of even David Reich. Lets not conflate what is a fact and what is a theory. Aryans came in 2000 years later is not a fact but a theory and there are multiple holes in that theory. So, lets not flaunt that dubious theory when its not even substantiated with proofs.
- pachico 4y agoAm I the only one that when an article is about something I want to know more, I quickly drop it and go to Wikipedia instead?
- JetAlone 4y agoI ended up on a long wiki walk reading all sorts of things about Pakistan, but only after I gave the article itself a once over.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- omeysalvi 4y agoAll Indian students below the age of 13 have heard of Mohenjo-Daro. I don't remember what year's textbooks it was in for us but the author assertion that it is a place that "most people have never heard of" has almost a billion rebuttals.
- magnetomax 4y agoI still remember during my school days, the cover of history textbook was with Indus script on it.
- erklik 4y agoAdd the almost 225 million or so Pakistanis too. About 1.5 billion people I'd say.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Arnavion 4y agoYeah, Indian history education literally starts at the Harappan civilization. It's not possible to not know about it.
- googlryas 4y agoNeed to add 3 billion more to that number to falsify the claim.
- rrwo 4y agoIf most of the roughly 7-billion other people on the planet have never heard of it, then yes, most people have never heard of it.
- baybal2 4y ago
- macrolime 4y agoI find it interesting that the cities of the Indus Valley Civilization had sewage systems and most of the houses had toilets. This knowledge seems to have gotten lost with the decline of their civilization. Some time the Indus Valley Civilization disappeared, some of their cities got reinhabited by other peoples, but they didn't use the sewage system and apparently didn't figure out what it was.
- paganel 4y agoThe same happened with the Romans where I live, in present-day Romania and the former province of Dacia. Back when they were here, around 100-200 AD, they used to have villas with heated floors. Once they left for good, in the late 200s - early 300s, no-one around these parts of the world had houses with heated floors for at least 1500 years. I'd say that in the early 1700s a local ruler was the first one who had such a system installed in its Bucharest court, meaning the first one after the Romans.
- sankalp22 4y ago
- shever73 4y agoI'm confused by the dating in the article. It refers to an ancient Buddhist stupa towering over the streets, but later says the city was abandoned by 1700 BCE. This would be over 1,000 years before the founding of Buddhism. Or am I missing something?
- rushikesh98 4y ago> 1922 that R D Banerji, an ASI officer, believed he saw a buried stupa, a mound-like structure where Buddhists typically meditate. This led to large-scale excavations –... The officer initially believed it to be a Buddhist stupa. Excavation revealed the true historicity. A platform is easy to be mistaken with a stupa, without more context.
- quadrifoliate 4y agoApparently there is a later built Buddhist stupa on the same site [1]. Props to 'ojbyrne for pointing this out to me in a discussion. ---------------------------------------- [1] https://www.harappa.com/blog/buddhist-stupa-mohenjo-daro https://www.harappa.com/blog/buddhist-stupa-mohenjo-daro
- ivanhoe 4y agoIs Mohenjo-daro really something that most of people never heard of? I admittedly forgot most of the details about it, but I remember it being mentioned in my history classes in the primary school (in 80s Yugoslavia)...
- npsomaratna 4y agoYup, learned this at school too, along with the other ancient centers of civilization.
- nottorp 4y agoI definitely knew about it in Romania's pre iron curtain fall days. Maybe not from a school manual but from TV documentaries.
- OmegaPG 4y agoThe correct title should be - Ancient India's lost city of 40k people
- mtmail 4y agoThe place is in today's Pakistan. The ancient culture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_Valley_Civilisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_Valley_Civilisation was present in what is today Pakistan and India.
- erklik 4y agoWhy? It's in Pakistan. The modern country of India didn't exist back then, and nor is the city even located in modern day India.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mapandey 4y ago+1
- infaloda 4y agoIndia. Not pakistan.
- j245 4y agoNo. It’s in Pakistan. Double check your map.
- sikkiladho 4y agoIt's Pakistan. I literally live 2 kilometers away from it . I can walk there.
- viksit 4y agoEvery Indian history textbook has had detailed overviews of the indus valley civilization ever since my parents were in school. (they’re in their late 60s). I think entire generations of Indians (and presumably Pakistanis) know of this city / civilization. Hardly “lost”, if lost means people haven’t heard of it.
- j245 4y ago“Lost” can also mean - no longer exists. If someone says.. we lost 10 men in that battle, it doesn’t mean we never knew who they were.
- bobosha 4y agoThe IVC is a vast civilization that at its peak was much larger in area & population than Egyptian, Mesopotamian. Mohenjodaro - modern day Pakistan - is one of the major sites, but there are plenty others: Lothal, Dholavira etc. The Mergarh civilization was even more ancient than IVC. This is one of the greatest mysteries in human history. Cracking the IVC "script", historian aren't even sure it's a script, would be key to solving this puzzle.
- anaxag0ras 4y agoA bronze age civilization had brick houses and but I wonder why until a few decades ago, south Asian villages still mostly had mud houses. Given such a long time, one would expect brick houses even in remote villages.
- bakul 4y agoIf you are in the Gujarat state, India, you can go visit Lothal (part of the same Indus Valley Civilization) and look at the fascinating seals in its museum. It is under 100Km from Ahmedabad. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lothal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lothal https://www.harappa.com/blog/discovery-lothal https://www.harappa.com/blog/discovery-lothal