50 ms·
Maybe not "everything". The crypto people have desperately tried to invent things they can claim are not securities. Post-FTX, and post SEC vs LBRY, that's not
by Animats 4y ago
Maybe not "everything". The crypto people have desperately tried to invent things they can claim are not securities. Post-FTX, and post SEC vs LBRY, that's not going to work.
The original theory behind NFTs was that they were "collectable art". But then they started looking a lot like securities, with collections, series, "floor prices", fractional ownership, secondary markets, and such. See [1] The US test for whether something is a security is use, not form. If there's a billion dollar market in trading buttons, it becomes a security.
There are NFTs representing land in virtual worlds. Most of the sellers sold land before actually getting the virtual world working. That's a clearly a speculative investment which depends upon on the promoters finishing the project. This is exactly like selling real land in a not yet built subdivision, which is a security offering in the US. See "Swampland in Florida" in Wikipedia. (Although China allows this; there are people stuck paying mortgages on unbuilt buildings, which is not going well.)
There's the DAO concept, where the token holders own the thing and can vote on running it. That looks a lot like a stock IPO in the early stages. In the later stages, when all tokens have been sold, there's an unexpected kicker. Owners of the DAO may be personally liable for its losses.[2] Not just for the amount they paid. A DAO is a partnership or unincorporated association, and debts pass through to the members.
[1] https://www.pymnts.com/nfts/2022/pymnts-nft-series-can-nfts-be-securities-the-sec-says-yes/ https://www.pymnts.com/nfts/2022/pymnts-nft-series-can-nfts-...
[2] https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/voter-beware-personal-liability-for-dao-7040503 https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/voter-beware-personal-liab...