3 ms·
Gensler (SEC chair) prepared remarks, 2022[1]: The Supreme Court’s 1946 Howey Test, which was about orange groves, says that an investment contract exists when
by Animats 4y ago
Gensler (SEC chair) prepared remarks, 2022[1]:
The Supreme Court’s 1946 Howey Test, which was about orange groves, says that an investment contract exists when there is the investment of money in a common enterprise with a reasonable expectation of profits to be derived from the efforts of others.
My predecessor Jay Clayton said it, and I will reiterate it: Without prejudging any one token, most crypto tokens are investment contracts under the Howey Test. Even before the Howey test, in the first several years of our federal securities laws, some entrepreneurs were notified that they had to register their offerings of chinchillas, whiskey warehouse receipts, oyster beds, and live silver foxes as securities offerings, as “the purported sale of the…property was merely camouflage and not the substance of the transaction.”
Today, many entrepreneurs are raising money from the public by selling crypto tokens, with the expectation that the managers will build an ecosystem where the token is useful and which will draw more users to the project.
Thus, it is important that we work to get crypto tokens that are securities to be registered with the SEC. Issuers of crypto tokens that are securities must register their offers and sales of these assets with the SEC and comply with our disclosure requirements, or meet an exemption. Issuers of all kinds across a variety of markets successfully register and provide disclosures every day. If there are, in fact, forms or disclosure with which crypto assets truly cannot comply, our staff is here to discuss and evaluate those concerns. Any token that is a security must play by the same market integrity rulebook as other securities under our laws.
That's pretty clear. If there's an issuer raising money with it, it's a security.
Note the line “the purported sale of the…property was merely camouflage and not the substance of the transaction.” That covers much of the NFT market.
[1] https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/gensler-remarks-crypto-markets-040422 https://www.sec.gov/news/speech/gensler-remarks-crypto-marke...
- dogman144 4y agoYa, I’ve been following the Howey Test and SECs read on it since ‘17 when it really started to surface with ICOs. You copy/pasted the types of speeches I’m referring to. “everything in crypto with a live issuer behind it is probably a security.”… This claim is still a massive overstatement from a regulation-informed perspective. Everything in crypto extends beyond “much of the NFT” market. In ‘18, SEC chairman says ETH and BTC aren’t securities. Pre-merge, eth wasn’t a security to Gensler. Post-merge, it was. So then what about the many ETH-clones that didn’t do PoS and stuck with PoW/not-a-security ETH design. Also, “eth might be a security” came up in Sept ‘22. SEC and the chairman have changed minds in significant ways within that time period many times over since ‘09 and the whitepaper. It’s nowhere near cut and dry as you’re making it to be, but I won’t devolve into an argument about it and instead say there’s more info to this than your views indicate you’ve researched.
- Animats 4y agoMaybe not "everything". The crypto people have desperately tried to invent things they can claim are not securities. Post-FTX, and post SEC vs LBRY, that's not going to work. The original theory behind NFTs was that they were "collectable art". But then they started looking a lot like securities, with collections, series, "floor prices", fractional ownership, secondary markets, and such. See [1] The US test for whether something is a security is use, not form. If there's a billion dollar market in trading buttons, it becomes a security. There are NFTs representing land in virtual worlds. Most of the sellers sold land before actually getting the virtual world working. That's a clearly a speculative investment which depends upon on the promoters finishing the project. This is exactly like selling real land in a not yet built subdivision, which is a security offering in the US. See "Swampland in Florida" in Wikipedia. (Although China allows this; there are people stuck paying mortgages on unbuilt buildings, which is not going well.) There's the DAO concept, where the token holders own the thing and can vote on running it. That looks a lot like a stock IPO in the early stages. In the later stages, when all tokens have been sold, there's an unexpected kicker. Owners of the DAO may be personally liable for its losses.[2] Not just for the amount they paid. A DAO is a partnership or unincorporated association, and debts pass through to the members. [1] https://www.pymnts.com/nfts/2022/pymnts-nft-series-can-nfts-be-securities-the-sec-says-yes/ https://www.pymnts.com/nfts/2022/pymnts-nft-series-can-nfts-... [2] https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/voter-beware-personal-liability-for-dao-7040503 https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/voter-beware-personal-liab...