3 ms·
> And this is precisely the way our legal system is designed to work. Underlying it is the idea that it's better for 100 people to go unpunished, then to have u
by Silhouette 15y ago
> And this is precisely the way our legal system is designed to work. Underlying it is the idea that it's better for 100 people to go unpunished, then to have used the state's monopoly on force to injure one innocent person.
It's not really that simple, though, is it? Different kinds of law require a different burden of proof to be met before the legal system will punish or compensate.
In criminal cases, the standard in many places is "beyond reasonable doubt" or something roughly equivalent. This echoes the sentiment you described.
However, in civil cases, where we are talking about damages being assessed if and only if the case is lost, the burden is typically much lower, often something resembling "on the balance of probabilities".
And on the balance of probabilities, anyone trying to weasel their way out of being punished for infringing copyright who has no case stronger than the form arguments I mentioned before is guilty as sin.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoYes, I agree with everything you just said. Maybe I'm reading too much into your previous statement. But what I got out of it was the idea that because in aggregate so much of the activity is infringing, that it would make moral sense to shut down everything. I don't think it's correct to use the standards of proof necessary in individual cases to draw conclusions about entire classes of people. (and let me apologize in advance if I was indeed finding meanings that you hadn't intended)