3 ms·
> Well, it's a typical hydrogen news story. Yeah, if you combined all the published results on generating hydrogen from water, you'd have perpetual motion. Sea
by Animats 4y ago
> Well, it's a typical hydrogen news story.
Yeah, if you combined all the published results on generating hydrogen from water, you'd have perpetual motion. Search with Google for "hydrogen from water breakthrough":
* Revolutionary technique to generate hydrogen
* A breakthrough method uses solar energy to produce hydrogen
* Israeli scientists make breakthrough on producing 'green' hydrogen fuel
* CRUCIAL BREAKTHROUGH IN HYDROGEN ENERGY
* Australian Lab Turns Hydrogen Into Green Energy With Secret
* UCSC Makes Green Hydrogen Breakthrough
* New breakthrough in the study of hydrogen production by
* A new way to generate hydrogen fuel from seawater (Stanford)
* SunHydrogen has developed a breakthrough technology to produce renewable hydrogen using sunlight and any source of water.
* HyTech Power may have solved hydrogen, one of the hardest ...
* Universal Hydrogen's decarbonizing technology is coming to
These go back years.
- PaulHoule 4y agoThe difference is that there is serious interest in 2022 in green hydrogen to replace hydrogen from methane steam reforming or the shift gas reaction and coal.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoHaving a "serious interest" and earnestly wanting it this time doesn't change the fundamental fact that you need a lot of power to crack water apart. There's simply no way around that, all improvements found will be marginal at best.
- DesiLurker 4y agoI wish somebody would do a very simple roundtrip calculation for each of these 'breakthroughs' and publish it. all i want to know is the efficiency, cost & power density these on consumption side so I can decide which applications this works best in. on the production side same thing except for power density. the fact that its incredibly hard to find these numbers makes me think that these are mostly puff pieces for hydrogen before BEV eats their lunch. green/blue/gray hydrogen is mostly BS.
- PaulHoule 4y agoThe main interest now is not for ‘dispatchable energy’ but for industrial uses of hydrogen, metallurgy, etc. There is a lot of competition for energy storage such as conventional batteries, vanadium flow batteries, compressed air, pumped hydro, etc. I think fuel cell cars have been dead since Tesla made attractive BEV cars.
- DesiLurker 4y agowhy would I care about hydrogen when I have a perfectly good electrical system ready in hand. hydrogen's main selling point is energy density, which makes is good on paper for 'mobile' applications. if you forgo that than there are plenty of good energy carries like NG/gasoline or electricity which round-trip much better in efficiency terms. I am not sure if there is a sudden step up in industrial uses of H. on face value this looks more like groundwork for some upcoming fossil greenwashing subsidy that uses hydrogen to justify public funds.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoI'm not sure you understood this: "The main interest now is not for ‘dispatchable energy’ but for industrial uses of hydrogen, metallurgy, etc." He's not talking about hydrogen as a store of energy. He's talking about hydrogen to be used in industrial processes that require hydrogen input. Energy density has nothing to do with it, and the superiority of NG/gas/electic for carrying energy isn't relevant. > I am not sure if there is a sudden step up in industrial uses of H Step up? There is existing demand for hydrogen which this would, presumably, be more efficient at meeting. If they're not meeting that demand for hydrogen by cracking water apart, they'll do it by cracking natural gas apart instead.
- somewhat_drunk 4y agoLook up Paul Martin on linkedin for a thorough examination of H2 as a fuel, including round-trip efficiency.
- 4y ago
- pencilguin 4y agoThe amount of energy to crack water is already only a small multiple of what you get back when you get the products back together. The improvements are in the cost of equipment per unit output capacity, and the production rate per unit volume of said equipment. Improvements are cumulative. Airports, steel mills, and ammonia synthesizers will need to produce huge amounts of H2, soon, so reductions are important.
- threeseed 4y agoExactly the same thing can be said about battery and solar technologies. But eventually research does reach a point where they make a difference to ordinary end users.
- bb88 4y agoRight, but also things like electricity was harnessed a mere 100 years or so after its discovery -- so it might take another 100 years before it's practical. The other problem is that we have an infrastructure built up for electricity today. This is not the case for H2. It's not that we can't make it, but, electricity is far cheaper to transfer across a continent than H2.