3 ms·
> has been decolonised and now invokes the concept of mauri, or life force, to give the atomic theory a new spiritual dimension. Uh, last I checked, Euro-centr
by zozbot234 4y ago
> has been decolonised and now invokes the concept of mauri, or life force, to give the atomic theory a new spiritual dimension.
Uh, last I checked, Euro-centric biology or chemistry didn't involve talking about Wille zum Leben or élan vital. Why does 'decolonized' science need to get involved with this totally unscientific woo?
- viraptor 4y agoI've definitely been taught about a few of the early ideas around biochem. Alchemy, will to live, the misunderstanding around ether in physics, the various conflicts around how life begins, and probably others I forgot. You don't learn "the unscientific woo", you learn the historical context of how we got to the current understanding.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoAlchemy is unscientific by its nature - let's mix random substances to get gold.
- shrthnd 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goethean_science https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goethean_science => https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Failure_mode_and_effects_analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Failure_mode_and_effects_analy...
- viraptor 4y agoYou missed the point. Yes, it's unscientific, (well, not entirely - the attempts given knowledge at the time were very scientific, claims of success weren't) but the historical context about how chemistry evolved is still valuable. The whole idea of why it didn't work is scientific information. We didn't learn alchemy. We learned about alchemy.
- Joker_vD 4y ago...okay, forget all the physical and chemical knowledge you have that was discovered after the year 1300 and propose a better method to learn how to produce gold. Where would you even start?
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoNot by mixing goat piss with hair of a virgin in moonless night.
- scarmig 4y ago...how do you know that doesn't work? Sometimes surprising and interesting things happen when you experiment. Maybe goat piss with hair of a virgin seems weird, but burying shit in your backyard for awhile, digging it up, and mixing it with burnt wood seems pretty odd too when you think about it.
- leereeves 4y agoIs that a recipe for gunpowder?
- Ancapistani 4y agoIt seems to be missing sulfur, but otherwise - yep. If memory serves, one of the big reasons for Britain’s naval supremacy for a long time was their discovery and exploitation of large deposits high-quality of saltpeter in India. Before that, they had “saltpeter plantations” with rows of organic waste soaked with human an animal urine and left to dry in the sun. Before that, it was groups of the King’s men going around the countryside and scraping the stone foundations of buildings and cemetery monuments.
- Joker_vD 4y agoMy point exactly; people really like to equate "unscientific" with "turned out to be wrong". Chemistry is such a huge field that it's a small miracle we managed to figure out at all, no small thanks to Boyle who actually introduced the very concept of chemical elements.
- roenxi 4y agoThat is perfectly scientific. It becomes unscientific is when people pretend it worked, or that they'd ever seen it work. Materials science follows in the footsteps of the alchemists, keeping alive the grand tradition of mixing random stuff together to see what happens. They too are frequently mixing things together in the hope of getting specific outcomes - usually it doesn't work. Science is about how people deal with evidence. There wasn't any reason to think that gold couldn't be produced by mixing stuff together in the days when alchemy was popular. After all, a bunch of other substances could be made by mixing things, and it is obviously possible to mix liquids and get solids.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoWhy is that unscientific?
- PubliusMI 4y ago
- boomboomsubban 4y agoBiology is to tell one's way of living, we've used the word for so many centuries we forget that the roots "bio" and "logy" are Greek unscientific woo.
- martopix 4y agoThis article makes a point but we should be careful to see what was actually going on there. It's possible that the concept of mauri is introduced in the historical context of biology precisely together with élan vital and Wille zum leben and in the same terms. Or maybe not. I suspend judgement until I hear both sides.